Improperly plowed road led to water polo coach's death: Suit
Share and Follow

Colleen Lischwe, center (McKendree University).

The husband of a respected water polo coach who died earlier this year in a crash with a semi-truck is suing the State of Missouri claiming an improperly plowed highway led to her death.

Colleen Lischwe, 35, on Jan. 15 was driving her 2011 Toyota Prius east on Interstate 44 when she had an issue that caused her to try and pull over to the shoulder. However, because there was snow from a recent storm on the shoulder, she could not move all the way over, the lawsuit filed May 8 said.

More from Law&Crime: ‘Thought it was a joke’: Parents given ‘the wrong ashes’ of 2-year-old by crematory who let child’s body rot in his funeral clothes, lawsuit says

The driver of a semi-truck traveling around 65 mph behind Lischwe apparently did not see her car and plowed into the back of her. Lischwe’s Prius went over the snowbank and fell from the overpass down onto the city street below. She suffered “severe facial and head trauma” and massive internal bleeding, the suit said, which led to her death.

Now Lischwe’s husband Casey Colgan is suing the Missouri Highways and Transportation Commission (MHTC) for negligence, saying it failed to follow its own policies when removing snow from highways.

“Defendant MHTC, acting by and through its employees and agents, caused the portion of public highway on which Decedent was injured to be dangerous and unsafe for the public, and was negligent and breached its duties of care in several respects,” the lawsuit states.

The commission knew or should have known that improperly paved snow could create ramps along the highway, making an “unreasonable risk of injury to the public” including Lischwe.

Love true crime? Sign up for our newsletter, The Law&Crime Docket, to get the latest real-life crime stories delivered right to your inbox.

It does not specify an amount of damages Colgan is seeking but includes funeral expenses and pain and suffering. The Department of Transportation declined to comment when reached by local CBS affiliate KMOV.

Lischwe was the head coach for the men’s and women’s water polo team at McKendree University, a NCAA Division II school in Lebanon, Illinois. The impact was heavy on her student-athletes.

“Colleen embodied what it means to be a servant leader and cherished her opportunities to teach and develop young men and women. She was a close friend and colleague to many, and helped to create the special bond that exists within the McKendree community,” the school said in a press release.

After paying water polo at Marist College in New York, she became head coach of the Bearcat program in 2016.

In addition to Colgan, she left behind a 3-year-old daughter.

“She loved all her athletes and challenged them to develop strong character and respect for one another, alongside the technical skills and strategies of the game,” her obituary said.

A GoFundMe raised over $100,000 for her family.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like

January 6 Gunman Sentenced for Kidnapping: Latest Developments in High-Profile Case

Left: John Banuelos after his October 2025 arrest (Cook County Sheriff”s Office).…

Tragic Tale: Infant’s Heartbreaking End Alone in Motel Swing Sparks Outrage

Background: Bestway Inn Motel in Muncie, Indiana (WTHR). Insets, from left: Jacob…

Pre-Trial Diversion Breach: Man Arrested for Firearm Possession at UF Campus

Staff report GAINESVILLE, Fla. – University of Florida campus police have arrested…

Author of ‘How to Murder Your Husband’ Charged After Husband’s Tragic Shooting

What initially seemed like a tragic robbery at a Portland cooking school…

Man Allegedly Kills Former Partner’s Housemate at CVS, District Attorney Reports

Inset: Antonio Serrano (Clay County Sheriff’s Office). Background: The CVS in North…

Double Trouble: Police Nab Pair in Stolen Truck Linked to Home Invasion Heist

Staff Report GAINESVILLE, Fla. – In the early hours today, authorities apprehended…

Pregnant Police Victims Service Counselor Tragically Discovered Fatally Shot in Unoccupied Parking Lot

Samantha Dean spent her career advocating for victims of violent crimes, only…

Justice Served: Mother Sentenced for Attempted Murder of Disabled Son

Inset: Julie Myhre-Schnell (Ramsey County Jail). Background: The area in Ramsey County…