Cops arrest wrong woman in fatal drug overdose case: Lawsuit
Share and Follow

Northern State Correctional Facility in Newport, Vermont (Department of Corrections).

A woman named Alicia M. Kelley is suing a Vermont police officer after he allegedly issued a warrant for her arrest for selling heroin that led to a fatal overdose.

The problem? He obtained a warrant for the wrong Alicia M. Kelley.

Kelley filed the lawsuit in Vermont”s U.S. District Court on June 30. According to the suit, the origin of the mishap happened on June 8, 2018, when a 21-year-old woman overdosed on heroin in the bathroom of a Dunkin’ in Brattleboro. She died three days later.

Love true crime? Sign up for our newsletter, The Law&Crime Docket, to get the latest real-life crime stories delivered right to your inbox.

Brattleboro Police Department Sgt. Greg Eaton, who is the only defendant named in the suit, learned a former Dunkin’ employee named Alicia M. Kelley sold the victim the heroin that led to the fatal overdose. The drug deal was captured on surveillance camera and a Dunkin’ manager identified Kelley as the suspect, the lawsuit said.

Nearly a year later, in May 2019, Eaton applied for and obtained a warrant for Kelley’s arrest. Eaton allegedly used a Department of Motor Vehicle’s database to identify the wrong Alicia M. Kelley. The women were born roughly five months apart in 1988. Kelley’s lawyers allege Eaton “did not attempt to confirm that he had the correct date of birth” for the suspect nor compare photos of the two women.

On July 13, 2022, some three years after the warrant was issued, the plaintiff Alicia M. Kelley, who was pregnant at the time, was at her North Troy home with her two children and parents when deputies from the Orleans County Sheriff’s Office arrived to place her under arrest.

More from Law&Crime: ‘Sleep it off’: Woman forced to give birth ‘while standing upright on a concrete floor’ in jail, staffers posed for pictures with the newborn after, lawsuit says

Kelley “became distraught, panicked, and was brought to tears,” the lawsuit stated. Her parents told deputies there must be some mistake but their pleas did not change the outcome. The kids became “very upset,” according to the lawsuit. The sheriff’s office posted on social media about the arrest, her lawyer Brian R. Marsicovetere noted.

Cops transported Kelley to Northern State Correctional Facility in Newport on a $25,000 bond. She spent the night and a judge lowered her bond to $10,000 which her parents paid the day after her arrest, the lawsuit said. Once prosecutors realized the mistake, they filed a motion to vacate all of her bond conditions. The Alicia M. Kelley allegedly responsible for the drug overdose death remains wanted, per plaintiff lawyers.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like

Man Held Baby Over Balcony and Threatened Gun Violence, Police Report

Share copy link Background: Washington Manor apartments can be seen off of…

James Craig Murder Trial: Prosecutors Say Former Dentist ‘Meticulously’ Planned Wife’s Poisoning Death, Jury Deliberates

The fate of former Colorado dentist James Craig is in a Centennial…

Man Arrested in Oregon for Washington State Murder of 23-Year-Old Mom

An arrest has been made in a deadly shooting in Washington state…

Police Report: Man Allegedly Planted Bomb in Former Landlord’s Lawn Mower

Background: The area of 7900 State Route 22 in Salem Township, Pennsylvania…

Where Is Bryan Kohberger Currently? A Look Inside the High-Security Prison Housing Another Notorious Criminal

Bryan Kohberger, who’s now serving out multiple life sentences for fatally stabbing…

Daughter Charged with Murder After Mother Found Stuck to Bed, Says DA

Inset: Tyrossale Peak (Richmond County Sheriff’s Office). Background: The 2900 block of…

Crucial Update Unveiled Regarding Suspect in Arkansas Hikers’ Double Murder Investigation

As the search continues for the man accused of killing a couple…

Man Allegedly Shoots and Runs Over Pregnant Girlfriend

Dakota Greeley (Jefferson County Jail). A Pennsylvania man will spend the rest…