Why was Mica Miller’s death ruled a suicide?
Retired death investigator Barbara Butcher discussed the case exclusively with Oxygen, explaining how investigators determine a cause of death in the case examined by Netflix’s Death of the Pastor’s Wife.
“It is generally protocol that any violent death should be treated as a homicide first, until ruled out,” The Death Investigator with Barbara Butcher host said. “And that way, you don’t have a mindset of walking in and saying, ‘Oh, it’s a suicide.’”
Butcher said investigators do not base such a ruling on a single detail. “It’s not any one thing. It’s the police, the medical examiner, and then that victimology,” she said. “So all these things point toward the idea that Mica Miller took her own life, and that was the ultimate determination of the medical examiner and the police department.”
After the Netflix documentary’s release, some members of the public and Mica’s family said they believe her ex-husband, John Paul Miller, may have been connected to her death, despite the official ruling.
“I think people don’t really understand how to deal with the horror,” Butcher said. “The grief, the ultimate sadness of a tragic event like this young woman taking her life.”
What Happened to Mica Miller?
Mica was found dead in the water at Lumber River State Park in 2024 after suffering a fatal gunshot wound.
According to a statement from the Robeson County Sheriff’s Office, doorbell-camera footage showed her leaving her apartment at 11:38 a.m. that day. At 12:12 p.m., she entered Dick’s Pawn Shop in Myrtle Beach, where surveillance video showed her buying a handgun.
MORE STORY: NBC Reporter Eliana Moreno’s Brother Warns of Scammers Exploiting Her Helicopter Crash Death
The sheriff’s office said Miller called 911 at 2:54 p.m. and reported that she planned to die by suicide.
A fisherman later heard crying followed by a gunshot, and Miller’s body was subsequently found in the water.
Why Do Mica Miller’s Friends and Family Suspect Foul Play in Her Death?
Mica’s family and friends were immediately suspicious about the circumstances of her death, pointing to years of alleged emotional abuse and John Paul’s seemingly inability to let her go. She had also reportedly applied for a restraining order against John Paul, Time reported.
John Paul has adamantly denied any involvement in her death. The sheriff’s office also confirmed that he was not in the state of North Carolina that day.
What Did the Sheriff’s Office Conclude About Mica Miller’s Death?
After reviewing surveillance footage, interviews, physical evidence and the report from the North Carolina Medical Examiner’s Office, the Robeson County Sheriff’s Office concluded in May 2024 that the death was a suicide.
“Unfortunately, rumors and conspiracy theories were spreading quickly, and assumptions were being made. However, in the end, we must make decisions based on the facts, and evidence that has been gathered,” they wrote in a statement. “While I know it’s not what many people wanted to hear, the evidence is quite clear and compelling, and we are as saddened as anyone that this occurred.”
ALSO READ: Emily Willis’ Last Texts Before She Was Left Paralyzed