Natalie Fonseca, Nafis Reynolds tried to kill man: Deputies
Share and Follow

Natalie Foseca and Nafis Reynolds participated in robbing a man, slashing his neck, and tossing him off a bridge, deputies said. (Mug shot: Escambia County Sheriff

Natalie Fonseca and Nafis Reynolds participated in robbing a man, slashing his neck, and tossing him off a bridge, deputies said. (Mug shot: Escambia County Sheriff’s Office)

In what deputies are construing as an “unorthodox date,” a man hung out with a woman and another individual that she introduced as her “uncle,” according to authorities. But this woman and the “uncle” allegedly turned on the victim, sliced his neck, and tossed him off a bridge.

The victim survived the attack and managed to find a deputy, says the Escambia County Sheriff’s Office in Florida.

The arrest affidavit against the defendants, Natalie Fonseca, 25, and Nafis Naim Reynolds, 31, is a convoluted tale because authorities describe the victim’s story as partially shifting during the investigation. They acknowledged he only spoke Spanish, so the language barrier complicated the efforts at communication, but at one point, an investigator pressed him on certain discrepancies between his story and surveillance footage.

Nonetheless, it’s clear from the sheriff’s office that he was badly injured. A deputy first encountered the victim — bloodied, his face bruised and swollen — on the morning of Oct. 8 at the Cumberland Farms parking lot along Scenic Highway, according to documents.

Authorities described the man as barefoot and hardly able to stand. Dried blood covered his face, neck and hands. There were deep lacerations on the front and sides of his neck.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like

Karen Read Murder Trial: Jury Reaches Verdict in High-Profile Case Involving Death of Boston Police Officer

A Massachusetts jury found Karen Read not guilty in her murder retrial…

Police say adoptive parents confined boy in room for 10 years

Left to right: Nora Ramirez and Richard Ramirez (El Paso Police Dept.).…

‘Horrific’: Missing Man Found Sitting on Couch Near Dismembered, Rotting Human Remains

A South Carolina man who was reported missing last week was later…

Trump Administration Seeks to Dismiss Lawsuit Against Abrego Garcia

Left: Kilmar Abrego Garcia, a Salvadoran citizen who was living in Maryland…

Police suspect that the father accused of killing 3 girls may have changed his appearance

A composite image of what triple murder suspect Travis Decker may look…

Man shoots pregnant girlfriend while 3 children are in the room

Inset: Shaun Holiday (Brockton Police Dept.). Background: The apartment building where Holiday…

Man Arrested for Abandoning Disabled Victim After Offering Help

Staff report GAINESVILLE, Fla. – Damon Jacob Henry Worth, 28, of Hawthorne,…

Father convicted of fatally depriving 4-year-old daughter of food

Main: Rodney McWeay during his June 17, 2025, sentencing hearing in Atlanta…