Here's Why Richard Allen's Delphi Case File Remains Sealed

A photo shows Delphi Murders suspects Richard M. Allen.

Richard M. Allen.

Richard Matthew Allen, 50, the Indiana man accused of killing two teenage girls several years ago in the Delphi murders case, has received a court-appointed attorney, court records show.

The appointment comes after the defendant previously begged the court for a public defender because he did not anticipate the cost of legal representation in a high-profile double murder case.

“In the cause listed above, I, Richard M. Allen, hereby throw myself at the mercy of the court,” a letter submitted with the Carroll County Court earlier this month reads. “I am begging to be provide with legal assistance in a Public Defender or whatever help is available.”

According to court records reviewed by Law&Crime, attorney Andrew Joseph Baldwin with Baldwin Perry & Kamish, P.C., a Franklin, Indiana criminal defense law firm, was appointed to represent Allen.

The law firm is located near Indianapolis and roughly two hours south-southeast of Delphi, Indiana.

Law&Crime reached out to Baldwin’s law firm for comment on this story but no response was immediately forthcoming as of time of publication.

While details on the case have been scarce, prosecutors allege Allen murdered 14-year-old Liberty “Libby” German, and her friend, 13-year-old Abigail “Abby” Williams before abandoning their bodies near what is now a recreational trail. The two girls went missing while walking the Monon High Bridge Trail – a former railroad deck girder bridge – near Delphi, Indiana, on Feb. 13, 2017.

Liberty German and Abigail Williams. (Images via the FBI).

Liberty “Libby” German and Abigail “Abby” Williams. (Images via the FBI).

Law enforcement have previously said German and Williams lost a considerable amount of blood and that their bodies were later “moved and staged” to where they were eventually discovered.

The killer is believed to have left with a souvenir from the crime scene, police have alleged in a highly redacted search warrant that did not specify what was missing from the crime scene.

In late October of this year, authorities announced that an arrest had been made in the long-mysterious and haunting murders. On Oct. 31, 2022, Allen was publicly named as the suspect, charged with two counts of murder, and his mugshot was released. The state has been keeping mum, however, and the court overseeing the case sealed the probable cause affidavit and charging information against Allen.

The defendant is even being detained in an undisclosed location. The Indiana Department of Corrections previously told Law&Crime that the refusal to denote his location is for “Mr. Allen’s safety.”

Allen, in his letter to the court pleading for a court-appointed attorney, said the case against him had upturned his life beyond his finances and was negatively impacting his wife’s safety as well.

“At my initial hearing on Oct. 28, 2022, I asked to find representation for myself,” the defendant wrote. “However, at the time I had no clue how expensive it would be just to talk to someone. I also did not realize what my wife and I’s immediate financial situation was going to be. We have both been forced to immediately abandon employment, myself due to incarceration and my wife for her personal safety. She has had to abandon our house for her own safety. What little reserve there is will fail to even maintain the original residence.”

The next hearing in the case is currently slated for Nov. 22, 2022. Judge Frances C. Gull has decided that hearing will deal with evidentiary issues. She previously said she would quickly dispense with the defendant’s request for court-appointed representation.

[Image via mugshot]

Have a tip we should know? [email protected]

You May Also Like

Christopher Patrick Moynihan Gets to Prison for Jan. 6 Riot

Christopher Patrick Moynihan (via FBI court filings). The New York man who…

Man Found in Barrel of Concrete, Dismembered; Drug Dealer Charged With Murder

A North Carolina man with an “extensive criminal history” was charged with…

Fifth Circuit Strikes Down Domestic Violence Gun Law

A conservative appeals court has thrown out the federal law that prevents…

Jacob Chance Greer Sentenced on Child Porn Charges

Jacob Chance Greer (U.S. Marslahs Service) A 28-year-old man will spend decades…

Senators Press DOJ About Ex-FBI Chief Charles McGonigal

Charles McGonigal, former special agent in charge of the FBI’s counterintelligence division…

Up to 200 Alabama Inmates Could Be Released on Friday

Screengrab via WTVM. As many as 200 inmates in Alabama, some with…

Police Say Lindsay Clancy Is Getting Better ‘Daily’

Lindsay Clancy is accused of killing her three young children. A Massachusetts mother…

Accused Double-Killer Alex Murdaugh ‘Wardrobe Change’ the Night His Wife and Son Riddled With Bullets

A video shown to jurors in Alex Murdaugh’s murder trial on Wednesday…