Shari Franke, the eldest daughter of parenting influencer Ruby Franke, is urging Utah’s parole board to keep her mother behind bars.
In a forceful letter opposing Ruby’s possible release, Shari described her mother as “a monster” and said she would not accept Ruby’s apology for the abuse that led to her imprisonment.
“I’ve had to struggle with what forgiveness means over the last 4 years. Maybe my definition is a little different than most,” Shari wrote in the letter, which she shared on social media. “I will never accept Ruby’s apology for what she has done. She has been a monster her entire adult life, and there’s no way that’s changed in 3 years.”
Ruby is serving a sentence of four to 30 years after pleading guilty in December 2023 to four counts of aggravated child abuse. That same month, her co-defendant, licensed therapist Jodi Hildebrandt, also pleaded guilty to four counts of aggravated child abuse. Hildebrandt operated an online self-improvement program with Ruby.
The two women are scheduled to appear separately before the parole board for the first time on Dec. 7.
Although Shari said she cannot attend the hearings in person, she made clear in her letter that she opposes parole for both women. She also detailed the lasting emotional impact the abuse has had on her family.
“It’s been 4 years since I last talked face to face with Ruby,” Shari wrote. “It was the most stressful experience of my life. She told me that through my speaking out against her publicly, I didn’t want to be part of the family.”
Shari said she was separated from her siblings for a year. During that period, however, she became increasingly worried that “something terrible was happening” inside the home and contacted police and child protective services in an effort to protect them.
Ruby Franke Arrested After Son Crawled Through Window
Authorities intervened in August 2023 after Ruby’s 12-year-old son escaped through a window at Hildebrandt’s home in Ivins, Utah, and sought help from a neighbor.
“The neighbor observed duct tape on the boy’s ankles and wrists, severe wounds, and malnourishment,” Washington County prosecutors wrote in an account of the case. “He quickly contacted law enforcement who, upon arrival, learned that potentially more children remained inside Ms. Hildebrandt’s home and in harm’s way. The officers responded to Ms. Hildebrandt’s home, placed her under arrest, and conducted a search of her sizable property where they found Ms. Franke’s 9-year-old daughter, petrified and hiding in a closet.”
Ruby’s criminal charges involved the abuse of her two youngest children. Shari has also alleged that her mother abused her son Chad Franke, who is now an adult, years before Ruby’s arrest. According to Shari, Ruby has never accepted responsibility for that alleged abuse.
YOU MIGHT ALSO LIKE: Ex-Ukrainian Commander Says He Did Everything to Stop Russian Forces
“I was forced to watch and listen to her beat my brother Chad mercilessly,” Shari wrote. “I would slide him tissues under the door for the bloody noses she gave him, and we would often talk together about calling CPS on our own mother. In her mind, all her problems started and ended with Jodi. Until she realizes that is not the case, and acknowledges she has issues that go way beyond Jodi, I don’t think she can fully heal.”
Shari said she has worked to rebuild her life since Ruby’s arrest but acknowledged that moving forward has been challenging.
“To me, forgiveness means I get to live my life in a way where I am not held back by Ruby. Every year, I am a little happier than the last,” she wrote. “But I think I will forever have trauma around what Ruby has done to me and my siblings. Even after being in therapy for 3 years, I continue to have nightmares at least weekly of being trapped back in Ruby’s home, trying to save my siblings from her.”
She also said she did not believe Ruby would have stopped the abuse if her 12-year-old brother had not “miraculously saved himself and my sister.”
“Ruby would have killed them,” Shari wrote. “Even after she was arrested, she stayed stoic and silent in interrogations. It was only after she learned Jodi had turned on her that she began to talk and apologize.”
Shari Franke Asks Parole Board to Keep Ruby Franke in Prison
Shari argued that “3 years cannot fix a lifetime of hurt” and asked the parole board not to release her mother.
“For the first time in our lives, my family is happy. We are happy without Ruby,” she wrote. “Even if she got out, I fear she would try to insert herself into our lives directly or indirectly, despite the fact she has a no contact order.”
Shari also asked officials to deny parole to Hildebrandt.
“She has repeatedly tried to take back her plea deal, or shorten her prison sentence,” Shari wrote. “She is not sorry, and she is one of the most dangerous people I know.”
Shari characterized Hildebrandt as a “master manipulator” who can read social situations and present herself in whatever way she believes will earn someone’s trust.
The parole hearings are scheduled for 9 a.m. and 9:30 a.m. on Dec. 7 in the Utah Board of Pardons and Parole courtroom at the Utah State Correctional Facility.