More than three decades after Susan Smith drowned her two young sons, their father, David Smith, says the passage of time has taken something painful from him too: many of his memories of the boys.
“I remember maybe quotes that they used to say, a few of those,” David Smith told People in an interview published Nov. 18. “Words they used to spell or pronounce in their own childish ways. But memories, there aren’t any.”
David still vividly recalls the sweet way 3-year-old Michael talked about his baby brother, Alex, who was 14 months old.
“Michael was a big fan of the movie 101 Dalmatians, but he pronounced it ‘Domashafens.’ It was ‘101 Domashafens,’” the 56-year-old recalled. “And instead of saying, ‘Alex is my brother,’ he would say, ‘He’s my brudder.’ Those are the kinds of words I remember.”
Although David says his sons remain “always alive in my heart,” he has been careful not to surround himself with too many reminders of the tragedy.
“We have some pictures around the house,” he said, “but I’ve never wanted to create a shrine because I knew that wouldn’t be healthy for me.”
Susan is serving a life sentence for the 1994 murders of her sons. She strapped the boys into their car seats, drove her Mazda into South Carolina’s John D. Long Lake and left them to drown.
At first, Susan claimed that a fictional carjacker had taken the children. After a nine-day search, however, she confessed to killing them and directed investigators to the lake. The vehicle was discovered upside down with both boys still secured in their car seats. In one heartbreaking detail, according to CNN, Michael’s hand was resting against a window.
Susan pleaded not guilty. Her attorneys argued that severe depression had driven her to attempt a murder-suicide.
Although prosecutors pursued the death penalty, Susan was convicted of two counts of murder in July 1995. She received a life sentence with the possibility of parole.
David has remained determined to keep Susan in prison as she prepares for her second parole hearing on Nov. 19.
In 2024, the parole board unanimously rejected her request after David delivered an emotional statement opposing her release.
“God gives us free choice, and she made a free choice to end their lives,” David said at the time. “This wasn’t a tragic mistake… she deliberately intended to end their lives.”
As he prepares to attend the upcoming hearing, David worries that Susan could finally be released—an outcome he says would be “an injustice.”
“So many people tell me that it won’t happen, and I wish that would make it so it wouldn’t happen, but it’s not a guarantee,” he told People. “The decision is entirely up to the parole board. I’m just worried that this could be the time she is granted parole.”