‘There were red flags’: Parents React to Devil’s Den ‘Killer’ Teacher, Who Played ‘Truth or Dare’ with Girl Students
Share and Follow

A former teacher, accused of killing ta couple at an Arkansas state park last month, reportedly showed “red flags” as a school teacher, and had been put on administrative leave prior to the Devil’s Den tragedy.

As CrimeOnline previously reported, Andrew James McGann, 28, is facing two counts of capital murder for the deaths o Clinton Brink, 43, and Cristen Brink, 41.

Police found the couple stabbed to death on June 26, at the Devil’s Den State Park in West Fork, Arkansas. The pair reportedly died protecting their young daughters, ages 7 and 9, who managed to escape unharmed.

Police arrested McGann a few days later at a Springdale hair salon, around 3o miles from the state park.

McGann reportedly did not resist arrest as police removed a black and white haircut cape and placed him in handcuffs.

James Andrew McGann at Lupita’s before his arrest/KNWA

McGann Switched Teaching Positions Several Times

In the spring of 2023, while McGann worked at Donald Elementary School in Flower Mound, Oklahoma, the school placed him on administrative leave, according to the Associated Press.

A spokesperson for the Lewisville Independent School District reportedly said that McGann had been placed on leave due to issues concerning classroom management, professional judgment, and favoritism toward certain students.

McGann stepped down from his position in Lewisville in May 2023, as confirmed by the district.

The following school year, he took a teaching role for fifth grade in Broken Arrow, Oklahoma, before moving on to work in Sand Springs, another district in the Tulsa area, from summer 2024 until May 2025.

FOX 7 Austin reports that officials from both districts confirmed that McGann cleared all background checks.

He was scheduled to start work at Springdale Public Schools on August 11.

Parents React

A parent of a student in McGann’s fifth-grade class recalled that McGann typically appeared “reserved” and “not super friendly,” describing their initial meeting as “just off-putting.”

“He wouldn’t look at me really, wouldn’t talk to me. He would only really talk to the kids, and he would just walk away,” Kyle Swanson said. “I don’t know, it was a strange interaction.”

Sierra Marcum, whose son was in McGann’s fourth-grade class, told AP that McGann appeared “pretty cold” and seemed “disinterested in his students.”

Marcum reported that her son frequently came home upset over McGann’s behavior, leading her to raise these issues with the school principal.

Parent Lindsay Polyak told NewsNation that her son, 10, noticed favoritism toward girls in the class.

“There were red flags,” Polyak said. “My son would say [McGann] liked to play tag at recess; he plays Truth or Dare with the girls. And then I start hearing these things like he’s giving out candy. He gives candy out in class, but, really, it’s for the girls.”

“They flocked to him,” she said.

Arraignment Scheduled

Meanwhile, McGann made his first court appearance last week in Washington County, where he learned the charges against him.

ASP Director Col. Mike Hagar said Thursday that the attacks appeared to be random in nature, and that there is no evidence that the couple’s daughters were the intended targets.

“It appears to be a completely random event,” Hagar said. “We have no reason to believe there was any known association between our suspect and our victims.”

McGann remains behind bars without bail. He’s scheduled to be arraigned August 25.

Check back for updates.

[Feature Photo: James Andrew McGann/Washington County Detention Center and the Brinks/Facebook]

Share and Follow
You May Also Like

Two Men and One Woman Arrested in Tennessee Quadruple Homicide Case, While One Suspect Still at Large

The Tennessee Bureau of Investigation has arrested three individuals in connection to…

Babysitter Convicted of Murder After Toddler’s Tragic Death

Inset, left to right: Kimora Launmei Hodges (Roseville Police Department) and her…

Federal Judge Condemns DOJ’s Support for Alina Habba Argument

Alina Habba, an attorney for former President Donald Trump, speaks outside at…

Erik Menendez Returns to Prison Following Hospitalization for Medical Reasons

Erik Menendez, who along with his brother was convicted of the 1989…

Police Report: Man Attacks Woman on Bus, Cutting Her Throat

Inset: Robert J. Rhoades (Tulsa Police Dept.). Background: Rhoades being arrested after…

Police Report Man Killed His Grandparents

Inset: Jeremyah Campbell (Brevard County Sheriff”s Office). Background: Home in Melbourne, Florida,…

Gainesville Woman Detained in Downtown Incident Involving Officer Assault and Disorderly Behavior

Staff report GAINESVILLE, Fla. – Tayana Nalany Lebron-Alvira, 18, was arrested early…

Understanding Trump’s Investigation into Jack Smith for Alleged Hatch Act Violations

Inset: Jack Smith speaks about an indictment of former President Donald Trump,…