Penny Lancaster faced an embarrassing moment during her first appearance on Celebrity Masterchef on Tuesday when judges found one of her creations unfit to eat.

The model and Loose Women panelist, 50, joined Melanie Sykes, Nabil Abdulrashid, and Megan McKenna in the challenge to prepare her inaugural dish of fried calamari with homemade tartare sauce.

Despite Penny’s initial confidence in her culinary skills, judges John Torode and Gregg Wallace pointed out her mistake of using whole eggs instead of just the yolks. This error resulted in a condiment that resembled a ‘raw egg/oil milkshake’ rather than the expected tartare sauce.

Nervous: Penny Lancaster was left red-faced during her Celebrity Masterchef debut on Tuesday when her food was deemed inedible by judges

At first, Penny exhibited a sense of self-assurance, expressing to the camera that her performance was exceeding her expectations and hoping to avoid any mishaps. However, she was soon caught off guard by what she humorously referred to as ‘tartare sauce-gate’.

As she presented her dish, Penny admitted, “That tartare sauce doesn’t look like the tartare sauce I’d normally have,” to which Gregg responded, “You used whole eggs instead of egg yolks.”

Delivering the true blow of the situation, John stated: ‘What I’ve got in here is a raw egg/oil milkshake. Unfortunately, I can’t eat that.’

It wasn’t all hopeless for Penny, as the judges complimented her calamari and she exclaimed, ‘well, I got half of it okay!’

Ew: While Penny seemed to think she was doing well, show stalwart John Torode and Gregg Wallace informed her that she had used whole eggs rather than yolks – leading to her inedible condiment coming out as a ‘raw egg/oil milkshake’

Not great? The model and Loose Women star, 50, appeared alongside Melanie Sykes, Nabil Abdulrashid and Megan McKenna, when she was tasked with making her first meal of fried calamari and homemade tartare sauce

All was not lost however, as Penny then wowed the judging panel with her next rounds which sent her flying into the semi-finals.  

She conjured up a pan-fried turbot with buttered spinach and hollandaise, leaving  guest chef Mitch Tonks ‘gobsmacked’ and branding the dish ‘fabulous’. 

He said: ‘The fish is cooked perfectly, it’s wonderfully seasoned, the flavour of the hollandaise is good, I haven’t got a fault with it, it’s really good’.

Gregg then exclaimed: ‘Where did you come from!?’, while John branded the dish ‘absolutely perfect’.

Delicious: She conjured up a pan-fried turbot with buttered spinach and hollandaise, leaving guest chef Mitch Tonks ‘gobsmacked’ and branding the dish ‘fabulous’

She then made a chicken and coconut curry, green papaya chutney, grated apple, turnip and carrot salad and coconut rice – inspired by the Seychelles.

Gregg continued the praise saying: ‘I found myself going from bowl to bowl to bowl and finding it difficult to stop, you have had what we call in the industry and very good day.’

He then branded her ‘a stand out cook’ and sent her to the finals, while  Britain’s Got Talent star, Nabil, was sent home. 

A great day: Gregg continued the praise saying: ‘I found myself going from bowl to bowl to bowl and finding it difficult to stop, you have had what we call in the industry and very good day’