As far as the show is concerned, it appears as though Colton’s luck in the castle may now be running out. After mistakenly identifying Big Brother‘s Tiffany Mitchell as a Traitor, resulting in her banishment from the game, some in the Faithful camp have begun to question Colton’s leadership abilities and his true motivations. In fact, at the most recent roundtable, Colton was accused of doing the same thing that Michael Rapaport accused him of prior to his banishment, i.e., bringing up the name of someone completely new and derailing the plan formulated by his teammates.

While “conniving, colluding, commiserating” Colton was also behind Rapaport’s banishment in Episode 5, even he admitted that it was less about aiming to take out a Traitor than it was about getting rid of a bad Faithful. It’s the kind of chaos that got Rapaport taken out, and is now putting heat on the former Bachelor. That chaos ultimately led to four players voting to send him packing, making it nearly a three-way tie to banish between Ron Funches, Lisa Rinna, and Colton. At one point, he even threatened to take Lisa down with him, which some fans felt was too personal.

Another viral TikTok posted by a creator who goes by Bravholics Anonymous posed a question about why he only seems to be hunting women he suspects of being Traitors.

“I’m sitting here watching Traitors, and I can’t help but notice Colton is only going after women. What do we think of that?” the creator says in the video, which has nearly 50,000 likes on it and hundreds of comments. One particular comment, however, was hoisted to the top of the comment section by fans of the show as Lisa Rinna wrote, “I know what I think of that.”