We’ve all faced that frustrating moment: stepping out with lashes that look stunning—long, voluminous, and dramatically perfect—only to glance in a mirror later and find that your mascara has betrayed you with flakes and smudges. Despite our wishes, the “raccoon chic” look hasn’t caught on and likely never will. So, it’s time to switch to a mascara formula that can withstand the day and keep you looking flawless for those after-work plans.

It’s a fact: not all mascaras are made the same. Some clearly outperform others. Deciphering which ones will earn a place in your makeup arsenal just by reading product descriptions can be daunting. But fear not, as we’ve done the legwork for you. By sifting through countless reviews, we’ve curated a list that simplifies your search.

Discover the eight best mascaras available on Amazon that are guaranteed not to smudge, run, or flake—each one endorsed by shoppers like you. Keep reading to find your new go-to mascara.