In the ever-evolving world of beauty trends, it appears that the minimalist “clean girl” makeup is making way for the bold, full-glam style reminiscent of 2016. Central to this throwback trend is the art of eyeliner application.

Having a go-to eyeliner is essential for any makeup enthusiast. I’ve been loyal to my under-$5 Wet n Wild liquid liner for many years. If you haven’t yet found your perfect match, now’s the time to explore the options.

As someone who’s passionately embraced eyeliners (cat-eyes have been my signature look since my teenage years), I’ve experimented with hundreds of products. Here, I’ve compiled a list of top eyeliners that both shoppers and I repeatedly choose, with prices starting as low as $4.

Different eyeliner styles serve varying functions, so it might be wise to invest in a few to achieve a complete eye makeup look. Use a creamy, blendable pencil for that effortlessly smudged appearance, a long-wear pencil for defining your waterline, and a liquid liner for executing a sharp, precise cat-eye.

Whether you’re opting for budget-friendly choices like NYX and e.l.f. or indulging in luxury selections from Victoria Beckham Beauty and Stila, these top eyeliners will help you master the latest makeup trend.