Although Sarah Paulson shared the screen with Kim Kardashian in Ryan Murphy’s latest series, All’s Fair, it turns out the SKIMS founder isn’t her top pick among the Kardashian-Jenner siblings.

During an eventful night on Watch What Happens Live with Andy Cohen on Tuesday, November 4, Paulson made waves not just with her Bravo opinions but also with her candid Kardashian ranking. When Cohen posed the question of how she’d rank Kim and her sisters—Kourtney, Khloé, Kylie, and Kendall—Paulson didn’t hold back.

“Khloé is my absolute favorite,” Paulson admitted, with Cohen chiming in to share that Khloé tops his list as well. “I adore Khloé. Kim is next. Then it’s Kylie, Kendall, and Kourtney,” she revealed.

Despite Kim not taking the top spot in her rankings, Paulson expressed that she thoroughly enjoyed working with the reality TV icon on All’s Fair. The actress was pleasantly surprised by Kim’s unexpected sense of humor.

“We shared a lot of laughs,” Paulson recounted. “There was one unforgettable moment when, during a scene, I accidentally spat a popcorn kernel in her face while yelling. Kim’s reaction was priceless, and it sent us into fits of laughter. We ended up getting a bit of a scolding from Glenn Close and had to take a break to compose ourselves. It was a delightful surprise to discover that side of her.”