Trump’s ODNI Chief Says No Coordinated Attack on U.S. Systems

Director of National Intelligence Jay Clayton told House lawmakers that a series of outages across the country—including disruptions that grounded flights—was caused by maintenance...
HomeEntertainmentThe Traitors: New Blood Finalists on Comforting Winner Shane Beatty

The Traitors: New Blood Finalists on Comforting Winner Shane Beatty

The Traitors: New Blood finalists understand why some viewers were baffled by how quickly they forgave Shane Beatty for joining the Traitors at the last possible moment and claiming the entire $246,000 prize. To them, however, the reaction made perfect sense.

**Spoiler alert: This article contains details from the two-episode finale of The Traitors: New Blood, now streaming on Peacock**

By the end of the 12-episode NBC reality competition, Abbey Benjamin and Wyatt Gillespie were standing alongside Beatty at the Circle of Truth. All three chose to end the game rather than continue with another banishment. Benjamin and Gillespie were both convinced Beatty was a Faithful, making the iron worker’s revelation all the more devastating. He was a Traitor — and promptly broke down in tears.

Although Benjamin and Gillespie had just been denied a share of a life-changing prize, they almost immediately moved to comfort Beatty. His guilt over deceiving the group had clearly overwhelmed him. Some viewers at home struggled to understand how the Faithfuls could console him after such a major betrayal, but Gillespie said it felt like the only appropriate response in the moment.

“It was a very difficult thing to do, but in that moment, I feel like I could emotionally regulate myself very well because I look over at a guy who is feeling guilt, and guilt is a way worse feeling than having lost,” Gillespie told DECIDER during a joint interview with his fellow finalists.

Beatty had played nearly the entire season as a Faithful and was visibly overcome with emotion. He repeatedly apologized to Gillespie and Benjamin, explaining that he had been given an ultimatum after Joe Vanella’s banishment: accept recruitment into the Traitors or be murdered. Gillespie said that explanation did not change the outcome, but it did make his response clear.

“To me, in that moment, I just immediately had to go say to my boy, like, ‘It’s okay, I would have done the same exact thing.’ Like, I love you, you love me, this is a game at the end of the day. So, I couldn’t be happier with him. He did exactly what I would’ve done in that moment, and I hope he would’ve come up and hugged me if I was a Traitor.”

Wyatt Gillespie and Abbey Benjamin hug Shane Beatty after his 'Traitors: New Blood' win
Photo: NBC

What do the finalists say to viewers who believe Beatty’s victory was unfair? Why did they keep controversial Faithful Jay Vinnredge in the game for so long? And what advice do they have for future contestants? Read on for DECIDER’s full interview with the The Traitors: New Blood finalists.


DECIDER: Guys, I didn’t know I needed a box of tissues for that finale. I felt so comforted watching Abbey and Wyatt go up to Shane after his win. How did you put aside your own heartbreak and hurt to comfort him?

WYATT GILLESPIE: It was a very difficult thing to do, but in that moment, I felt like I could regulate my emotions because I looked over at a guy who was feeling guilt. Guilt is a way worse feeling than losing. So I immediately had to go over to my boy and say, “It’s okay. I would have done the exact same thing.” I love you, you love me, and this is a game at the end of the day. I couldn’t be happier for him. He did exactly what I would have done, and I hope he would have come up and hugged me if I had been a Traitor.

And Shane, there are some people online who — and I think this is an unfair argument — say that it’s unfair for a Traitor to step in at the 11th hour and then win it all. What do you say to that?

SHANE BEATTY: I would say, how is it unfair if nobody has ever done it except me — a recruited Traitor? How is that unfair? Everyone who does it gets voted out.

VICTOR VOLLBRECHTHAUSEN: Yeah, boo-hoo. You did it. Everyone gets kicked out. That’s fair.

GILLESPIE: If you can’t take the heat, get out of the kitchen. This is what we signed up for.

BEATTY: Realistically, I was nervous that if I had started the game as a Traitor, I would have been out of there. I don’t know how Joe and Tomica managed to do it for so long without panicking, because I was nervous.

KATIE FITES: There was panic. It got a little bad, I think.

BEATTY: It looked like you were just chilling in your confessionals. I had never actually seen you before, and then I saw you and thought, “Oh, she’s just chilling.”

FITES: There are two things. First, I would have been more upset if Shane hadn’t even tried to defend me. He did. If he hadn’t written my name down, he would have gone home, and I would never expect someone to sacrifice their game for someone else. You can try to a certain extent, but it’s the name of the game.

FITES: Second, there was so much heat on me. People always say, “It’s not a game to make friends. I don’t want to see relationships develop.” But I genuinely think the reason this group made it to the end is that we were making decisions based on who we wanted to keep working with. We were thinking, “I don’t want to send my best friend home.” It really does become a social game. That’s why people criticize you, Victor, and say, “He doesn’t have a social game.” I’m like, “Well, you do.” But he did have some credibility.

Meanwhile, Jay — how did that happen? I’ve seen people say that if you were eventually going to get rid of him, you should have kept him until a banishment where there was no reveal.

FITES: That’s what I’m saying. It’s not that Jay wasn’t a best friend, but there were people you had closer connections with — people you wanted to reach the end with.

BENJAMIN: From a Faithful’s point of view, we really believed Alan had chosen three Traitors at the beginning and that one of them had been recruited, so we thought there were still two Traitors in the game. Jay had been so chaotic during the missions that we figured he was either a bad Faithful who would be difficult to take into the final mission or a Traitor.

BENJAMIN: We were almost afraid to get a Traitor out right before the end because there could have been another recruitment that night. Of course, we didn’t know Shane had already been recruited.

VOLLBRECHTHAUSEN: For me, it came down to who I wanted to win with. Part of you thinks, “I could be very, very wrong. Who am I okay losing to?” With this group, if I had won or lost to any of them, I would have been okay with it. When I walked out of the Circle of Truth, I thought, “Dang, I lost, but they’re going to win without me,” and I was able to accept that. I did not imagine it would be him.

VOLLBRECHTHAUSEN: I’m not going to come in here today and pretend I thought it could be Shane. I didn’t think that even a little bit.

BEATTY: I wanted you to stay.

VOLLBRECHTHAUSEN: Of course you wanted me to stay!

BEATTY: I threw green, so I thought, “All right.”

GILLESPIE: That’s when I knew!

BEATTY: When they threw red, I thought, “Oh no, don’t do that.”

GILLESPIE: Looking back, I’m like, “Man, I’m actually an idiot.” This man threw green right in front of me, and I completely missed it. But I was emotionally distressed.

BENJAMIN: Looking back, it was obvious that we were going to banish Victor — love you, Vic — because he was all over the place. He could have been a Faithful, or it could have been Traitor-on-Traitor. He was just a huge question mark.

GILLESPIE: He didn’t go because we thought he was a Traitor. He went because he was an untrustworthy Faithful.

VOLLBRECHTHAUSEN: All right.

BENJAMIN: I felt like he was a question mark.

DECIDER: Abbey, by the end, we see you mention twice that Clyde had brought up Shane’s name. You even wondered whether the wool had been pulled over your eyes.

ABBEY BENJAMIN: The only thing Clyde had on Shane was the sound of heavy footsteps. That’s it.

VOLLBRECHTHAUSEN: I swear I only heard Shane’s name mentioned once. I wish Clyde had done that.

BENJAMIN: That was all there was. I couldn’t throw red and vote Shane out based solely on heavy footsteps. I couldn’t do that. And if he was a Faithful, I would have felt terrible.

FITES: When you said, “It’s one of the boys,” you told me you thought it was Shane.

BENJAMIN: I knew it was a boy.

FITES: And I said, “I don’t think it’s Shane. I think it’s Victor.” Sorry. I was also trying to gaslight everybody on that final day.

GILLESPIE: What viewers don’t see is that Victor and I went into full psychosis with each other. We had a 20-minute conversation where we just stared at one another saying, “I think it’s you,” and the other person replied, “I think it’s you.” We were just locked in.

FITES: You can’t understand how intense the Round Tables are or how much people lose their minds. It may look performative, but the game is designed to isolate you. You become so immersed that you start thinking, “Maybe I’m here because it really is someone I trust.”

VOLLBRECHTHAUSEN: Katie genuinely thought I was a Traitor.

FITES: I convinced myself. I was thinking, “That is so weird, Victor. It’s literally you.”

Oh, like a Donna Kelce secret Traitor or something?

FITES: Exactly. That could have been happening. I genuinely thought, “Why would you say that?”

Victor, I do want to turn to you because every time I started to get behind you in this game, you would say something like, “I wish we were Bonnie and Clyde, not Romeo and Juliet.”

FITES: She’s got the quotes ready.

VOLLBRECHTHAUSEN: You can’t get behind that? That isn’t a banger of a line?

Where do these Victor-isms come from?

VOLLBRECHTHAUSEN: I have no idea.

GILLESPIE: “Pitter-patter, let’s get at ’er!”

VOLLBRECHTHAUSEN: There are a lot of voices in my head, and sometimes the filter doesn’t catch all of them. That’s what happens when you film me for 20 days in a castle in Scotland. I had a lot of fun.

Traitors New Blood contestants in studio
Photo: DECIDER

It sounds like you all had fun. There’s definitely room for some of you to return for a mixed season. Abbey, I saw that you met Lisa Rinna. Shane, I know Snake Daddy Rob Rausch follows you on Instagram. Have you spoken with any of the celebrity players from The Traitors?

BENJAMIN: I met Boston Rob and got to attend a golf tournament with him. Unfortunately, I couldn’t talk about the game because only two episodes had aired at that point.

FITES: I’ve spoken with Parvati [Shallow] from Season 2.

She’s great — love Parvati. Shane, have you had any conversations with the celebrity players before or after your win?

BEATTY: I’ve spoken with some of them, but I really want to focus on the New Blood players. We need more regular people in the cast. It’s cool to watch celebrities from another season and bring them back, but let’s get more people like us. This season gave us Katie, Victor, Shane, Wyatt and Abbey B. I have nothing against celebrities, but winning means more to us.

BENJAMIN: We need the money. For celebrities, it’s more about coming in and having fun. We have fun too, but this is a much more serious opportunity for us.

FITES: Shane showed up to an open casting call in New York and won!

VOLLBRECHTHAUSEN: That’s incredible.

FITES: He’s the ultimate superfan story — someone who gets cast and then completely dominates the game.

GILLESPIE: He has the best story ever.

BEATTY: Celebrities are cool, and I talk to some of them. I look up to many of them because I wouldn’t be interested in reality competition shows without them. But I want to focus on the civilians. You know what I mean?

Katie, you touched on this, but celebrities are already comfortable with production and have experience in front of cameras. Were there moments when you felt you had to play things up more than you normally would?

BENJAMIN: I think it was more real and raw. I genuinely forgot the cameras were there half the time. When we watch it back, that’s the first time we’re seeing it, and I’ll say, “I don’t remember doing that.” We were truly living in the moment.

BEATTY: Celebrities may be used to this, but it doesn’t matter which actor you cast — you can’t recreate the finale and the emotions we experienced. You can’t fake that. If you mix celebrities with civilians, the celebrities may run circles around us, use their fame to make us feel inferior, and then stab us in the back. You know what I’m saying?

VOLLBRECHTHAUSEN: I don’t know. I would hold my own. I think we could all hold our own alongside Shane.

BEATTY: I’m just saying, some of these people are used to doing this.

GILLESPIE: Victor would be the first one eliminated.

FITES: As far as production goes, I do think all of us were very genuine. The only time I felt nervous about a camera was when I was failing a mission. I was thinking, “Get out of my face.” During the Death Parade, when I was rolling those barrels, I saw a camera operator come toward me and started cursing. It was NBC, so they couldn’t use that footage.

VOLLBRECHTHAUSEN: It took a while to get used to how many people were around. There are so many crew members on set every day. You don’t realize how much goes into the show until you’re there. Then you see the castle behind the scenes, with wires everywhere, equipment and crew kits all over the place. You’re in shock because you didn’t realize how real it would feel. A camera can be a foot from your face while you’re having an intimate conversation.

Let me wrap up here. Season 2 has been announced and is happening. What advice would you give to people hoping to be on The Traitors: New Blood next?

BENJAMIN: You have to apply — and keep applying. Apply, apply, apply. Even if you don’t get this season, you could get another one. I applied to Survivor eight years in a row. Every August, I sent in a video. Then I started watching The Traitors, became interested in it, submitted an application and got cast on this season.

FITES: Ninth time’s the charm. You know how it is.

BENJAMIN: I always felt like I was going to get on Survivor, but from my very first call, I knew this was different.

VOLLBRECHTHAUSEN: Go in knowing you can’t prepare for it.

BEATTY: Funny enough, everyone took notes, and I didn’t.

Peacock currently offers two subscription options: Premium with ads and Premium Plus without ads. Peacock Premium costs $12.99 per month, while Premium Plus is priced at $19.99 per month.

Subscribers can save money with Peacock’s annual plans, which provide 12 months of access for the cost of 10. The plans cost $129.99 with ads or $199.99 without ads.

Peacock Premium Plus is also available through Prime Video with a seven-day free trial, an option that is not available when subscribing directly through Peacock.