New Photos of Brooklyn Beckham and Nicola Peltz Speak Volumes

With their eyes concealed by dark sunglasses and their faces tilted toward the ground, Brooklyn Beckham and Nicola Peltz appeared weighed down as they...
HomeEntertainmentWhy Actor and Dancer Harry Shum Jr.’s Shocking DWTS Elimination Wasn’t a...

Why Actor and Dancer Harry Shum Jr.’s Shocking DWTS Elimination Wasn’t a Surprise

Harry Shum Jr. and Jenna Johnson’s elimination from Dancing With the Stars Season 35 on Tuesday night, coming just one week after Jenna Dewan and Val Chmerkovskiy exited the competition, feels like a clear message: viewers may be growing tired of the show’s familiar advantages.

After weeks of minimizing their previous dance experience, both Dewan and Shum Jr. finally appeared to face the consequences of having entered the competition with a significant head start. Before becoming actors and appearing in ABC series such as Grey’s Anatomy and The Rookie, both stars had worked as professional dancers. Their departures, alongside those of their married professional partners, raise an important question: are fans frustrated by celebrities with extensive dance backgrounds, or are they specifically objecting to Johnson and Chmerkovskiy receiving two seemingly unbeatable partners?

The issue has surfaced repeatedly throughout the season. Britt Stewart, a seven-season professional who has never won the show and has often been paired with contestants unlikely to advance far, once named Shum Jr. as her dream partner. Instead, the Glee alum was matched with Johnson, a two-time champion. Fans criticized producers for overlooking Stewart — notably, the only Black woman to serve as a professional dancer on DWTS during the show’s 21-year history — while giving a highly capable contestant to a professional who had already won twice.

Viewers were similarly upset when Dewan was paired with Chmerkovskiy, who finished in second place the previous season and has won three times with Rumer Willis, Laurie Hernandez, and Xochitl Gomez. As a result, an anti-Chmerkovskiy and Johnson mood appeared to take hold online before the season even began, with some fans arguing that the two professionals continue to receive preferential treatment.

The situation became even more complicated midway through the season, when both teams were caught up in controversy after Chmerkovskiy posted a social-media comment that jokingly threatened violence against judge Carrie Ann Inaba. Following Inaba’s criticism of an illegal lift in Johnson’s choreography, which prompted a tense exchange between the two women, Chmerkovskiy wrote on Instagram, “You almost saw Fresh Prince enter the ballroom last night.” Many interpreted the remark as a reference to Will Smith slapping Chris Rock at the Oscars. Chmerkovskiy was subsequently suspended for one week, forcing Alan Bersten to dance with Jenna — and, arguably, revealing a partnership that might have made more sense from the beginning.

Amber Glenn, Connor Wood, Rylee Arnold, Harry Shum Jr., Jan Ravnik, and Jenna Johnson on stage.
Disney

Several factors may have contributed to Dewan and Shum Jr. leaving before the finale. Still, the combination of substantial dance experience and pairings that appeared to favor two already accomplished professionals was always likely to become a major obstacle. It is impossible to know whether either contestant would have advanced further with Stewart, Bersten, or another professional. Dewan and Shum Jr. may simply not have connected with viewers as strongly as Tatyana Ali or Connor Wood. Even so, it is worth examining how the competition reached this point.

Dancing With the Stars is never likely to feature a cast made up entirely of celebrities who have never danced before. That would be impractical, particularly when actors often take basic dance lessons to strengthen their resumes. But having two contestants who previously earned a living as dancers creates a particularly steep challenge for the rest of the cast. That is why, after watching Dewan say goodbye, my immediate thought was: Harry is probably next.

Dancing With the Stars is streaming on Disney+ and Hulu. The Season 35 finale airs live on Tuesday, November 24, at 8 p.m. ET/5 p.m. PT.

Disney+ offers several subscription options, allowing viewers to choose the plan that best suits them. The ad-supported plan costs $12.49 per month, while the ad-free option costs $21.49 per month or $214.99 per year.

Disney+ is also available in bundles with Hulu, HBO Max, and ESPN+, enabling subscribers to combine as many as three services and save more than 40% each month. Plans range from $12.99 per month for Disney+ and Hulu with ads to $34.99 per month for Disney+, Hulu, and Max without ads.