![]()
NEW YORK – As investigators work to determine why a New York City building collapsed and killed eight people, accounts from residents and workers are highlighting two neighboring sites at the center of the inquiry: the apartment building that gave way and the construction project being excavated beside it.
Lawsuits filed after the Nov. 11 collapse in Brooklyn point to several potential sources of responsibility, including the construction site’s owner and contractors, the engineering company that designed the excavation plan and the owner of the collapsed building. Several injured workers have also begun pursuing possible claims against the city agency responsible for overseeing construction safety.
Investigators are examining whether the deep excavation planned for a new building weakened the foundation of the three-story structure at 1321 Flatbush Ave., ultimately causing it to fall into the adjacent worksite.
A lawsuit brought by five injured construction workers alleges that the excavation at 2625 Bedford Ave. did not have sufficient retaining walls, shoring or underpinning to protect the neighboring building. The suit also claims work continued after cracks began appearing in the building’s facade.
“The shoring that they were planning to keep the collapsed building up was severely insufficient,” said Jonathan Damashek, an attorney representing injured workers. He questioned whether the city should have approved the excavation plans and whether the contractors performed their work negligently.
Damashek’s lawsuits accuse several defendants, including construction manager Townhouse Homes, of putting cost-cutting ahead of public safety.
The legal battle is unfolding as families bury the victims, including two children. City officials said Wednesday that another building next to the collapsed structure will also need to be demolished after the disaster stripped away one of its exterior walls.
Tenant says construction work next door led to cracks
Buildings Commissioner Ahmed Tigani said the city would do “everything we can to understand exactly how this collapse occurred, so that the responsible parties can be held to account.” His department is bringing in an independent engineering consultant, while Brooklyn prosecutors have opened their own investigation.
In an email Friday, the Buildings Department said it had reviewed the excavation and support plans and determined that they met city requirements. The agency said private inspectors hired by developers are responsible for examining certain phases of construction and verifying what was actually installed.
The department did not respond when asked whether it had reviewed a preconstruction survey describing the adjoining wall of the collapsed building as being “in poor condition with noticeable cracks.”
The nearly century-old brick building already had a troubled history, with more than 90 unresolved citations involving exposed electrical wiring, leaking roofs, defective doors and other alleged housing code violations.
According to a lawsuit filed by tenant Dengane Omari Jack, the conditions deteriorated further after construction began next door.
Jack said he lost an extensive record collection and other belongings in the collapse. He alleged that he warned the landlord about cracks near the entrance but was dismissed. After he submitted photographs of the damage, the lawsuit says, he was told the problem was not the landlord’s responsibility and could not be repaired.
Builder and excavation engineer have faced lawsuits
As the investigation continues, the city is reviewing more than 160 construction sites connected to companies involved in the 2625 Bedford Ave. development, which was planned as a mixed-use apartment and commercial project.
Townhouse, also known as Promont, has been active in New York’s construction industry for roughly 30 years.
The company was accused in 2016 lawsuits of damaging a neighboring building during a Manhattan renovation, allegations it denied. It was also accused of undermining nearby structures during excavation, pile driving and steel-beam installation for a Brooklyn hotel. The company’s attorneys have not addressed the claims in the hotel-related case.
MORE ON THIS: Wikipedia Details and Age of Muhammadsober Faizov, the Suspect in Moscow Assault – NewsFinale
Townhouse principals, representatives of other companies named in this report and the property owners did not respond to requests for comment from The Associated Press.
Jieming Wang, the excavation engineer for the Bedford Avenue project, has also been named in lawsuits. Court records show that at least a dozen cases have blamed excavation plans prepared by his New Jersey-based firm, LMW Engineering Group, for damage to neighboring properties.
A 2015 lawsuit claimed that LMW’s work at a Manhattan excavation site caused sloping floors, damaged doors and windows and destroyed utility pipes in a nearby building.
Another lawsuit filed in 2016 said soil removal undermined the wall of a building beside a Queens excavation. In a 2020 case, the firm was accused of failing to conduct required testing and monitoring at another Queens site. That lawsuit alleged that a neighboring building’s foundation became unstable, its gas and hot-water systems were damaged and an architectural arch partially pulled away from the structure.
LMW, which has worked on bridges, airports and other projects since its founding in 1998, denied the claims in the 2015 and 2016 lawsuits but did not respond to the 2020 case. Other lawsuits were settled outside court.
City fined project during demolition phase
The Bedford Avenue development first drew a Buildings Department violation in March, when crews began demolishing an existing structure without enough netting and other safeguards to prevent debris from falling or flying.
Demolition contractor N Tech Design of America was ordered to stop, but city records show that it continued working and was cited again in April. The company admitted both violations and paid $12,500 in fines.
N Tech representative Aramis Brown told local outlet The City Reporter that the company completed its work in May and was not involved in the excavation or the collapse.
Excavation began in September after the city granted permission.
Collapsed building owner was on “worst landlords” list
Olufemi Falade, the owner of the collapsed building, has controlled a number of Brooklyn properties through different corporate entities. He has appeared six times over the past decade on the New York City public advocate’s list of the city’s “100 worst landlords.”
Falade, a licensed professional engineer, spent 12 days in jail in 2006 after failing to correct violations at a dozen buildings. Then-Housing Commissioner Shaun Donovan described him as “one of the most egregious examples we’ve seen citywide of flouting the law and forcing his residents to live in horrible conditions.”
After his release, Falade told the Village Voice that tenants were not paying rent. “People want something for nothing,” he said.
Falade has not responded to AP requests for comment since the collapse.
At a vigil near the disaster site Wednesday, housing activists, faith leaders and other community members demanded accountability from Falade and the developers.
“New housing cannot come at the expense of tenants’ lives,” said Judith Douglas, a Flatbush tenant advocate.
Copyright 2026 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed without permission.