A vulnerable British music tutor told a man accused of grooming and murdering her that she “couldn’t be without” him in the months before her death, a court has heard.
Sonia Exelby travelled from her home in Portsmouth to Florida in October last year to meet Dwain Hall, a 54-year-old mechanic who was fascinated by the Egyptian god of death.
The 32-year-old, who had a long history of mental health difficulties, spent two years communicating with Hall on a hardcore fetish website and offered to pay him to help end her life in a brutal act.
Prosecutors allege that Ms Exelby changed her mind after arriving in the US and travelling with Hall to a secluded Airbnb near Reddick, Florida.
Hall is accused of ignoring her alleged change of heart, continuing to assault and abuse her before stabbing her to death. He denies kidnapping and murdering Ms Exelby.
A jury at the Marion County Judicial Center in Ocala, central Florida, has been shown messages exchanged between Ms Exelby and Hall during the months before her death.
Hall used the online name “Alphasadist”, while Ms Exelby went by “Already Yours” on the extreme pornography website Motherless.
Sonia Exelby, 32, travelled from Portsmouth to the US in October last year to meet Dwain Hall, a 54-year-old self-described “sadist” fascinated by the Egyptian god of death
Jurors at the Marion County Judicial Center in Ocala, central Florida, have been shown messages exchanged by Ms Exelby and Hall before her death
Hall has denied the charges of murder and kidnapping
Prosecutors say Ms Exelby changed her mind after travelling with Hall to an Airbnb near Reddick
In one message, Ms Exelby wrote: “I got worried about you, I’m lost without my alpha sadist.”
In another, she said: “Like so happy my cheeks ache from grinning. I’ve missed my alpha more than I could imagine… absence does make the heart grow fonder. I can’t be without you.”
Jurors heard this week that Ms Exelby had bipolar disorder and bulimia, had begun self-harming and had twice attempted to take her own life through an overdose.
She spoke to numerous men on Motherless, telling them that she wanted to die but did not believe she could do it herself.
However, prosecutor Amy Berndt said one man became particularly significant.
“He groomed Sonia, he wanted the job of being her executioner and that person was the defendant Dwain Hall,” she told jurors.
Special agent Rebekah McKinzie, from Florida state police, took the jury through the digital evidence detectives uncovered linking Hall and Ms Exelby.
Hall operated several Motherless accounts, including one named SilverWolf44646. Its profile stated: “Live in FL sadist want to find my own little sex doll for all sorts of things.”
Ms Exelby’s profile description read: “Life’s a bitch and then you die and now life’s finally stopped being a bitch.”
In October last year, Ms Exelby told her long-term partner Stevie Hunt that she planned to stay with her sisters for the weekend. Instead, she boarded a flight to Florida.
Two days later, Mr Hunt discovered an email she had sent to herself from the plane. The message was “full of sorrow, depression, regret and death and it talked about suicide”, the prosecutor said earlier this week.
It read: “As soon as the wheels leave the ground, I wish I was home, can’t get off the plane… I want to beg for help so badly.
“Oh god, I feel so sick… why am I here, why? If I wasn’t numb I’d never have gotten out of the house, this would be impossible, although I’m hurting more than I ever have.”
Mr Hunt alerted British police, who notified authorities in the US. Detectives linked Ms Exelby to Hall after her bank cards were repeatedly used by a breakdown company he owned.
Investigators later found Ms Exelby’s half-naked body in a shallow grave near Marion Oaks, the small suburban community where Hall lived. She had suffered four stab wounds.
Police established that Ms Exelby had visited an Airbnb with Hall. He told detectives they had engaged in consensual rough sex there, but denied killing her.
However, officers discovered that Hall had sent a knife to a friend. Testing showed that it contained Ms Exelby’s blood.
An examination of Hall’s phone allegedly showed that he had attempted “to erase every trace of Sonia”, including numerous nude photographs and a video he had tried to delete.
Detectives also found a collection of “horrific” photographs and videos depicting women being tortured.
“Evidence that the reason the defendant beat, stabbed and murdered Sonia was for his own sadistic pleasure,” the prosecutor told the court.
Ms Exelby’s sister Gemma Isaj gave evidence in court in Florida this week
Four of Ms Exelby’s siblings travelled to the US to confront the man accused of killing her, after raising money online to meet the considerable cost of the trip.
Her sister Gemma Isaj gave evidence in the Florida court just a few feet from Hall, who was wearing a purple shirt and grey trousers.
Fighting back tears, she told the court that Ms Exelby had revealed in November 2024 that she was “really terrified” because men she encountered online while seeking support in suicide forums had made “horrible threats” against her.
“Sonia said she was trying to gather evidence because she couldn’t bear that people were being hurt,” Ms Isaj told the court.
“I could see how scared Sonia was.”
Ms Isaj said she contacted police and a mental health crisis team at the time.
Mr Hunt gave evidence remotely from the UK. He said that after police became involved over the 2024 incident, he removed Ms Exelby’s passport and kept it safely for about six months to protect her.
He described his partner of 16 years as “the most incredible woman I’ve ever met” and “the nicest, kindest person I ever met in my life”.
The trial is continuing.
For confidential support, call Samaritans on 116 123, visit samaritans.org or visit www.thecalmzone.net/get-support