Tensions between Saudi Arabia and the European Union have intensified as a dispute over fossil fuels threatens to derail a global climate agreement.
Turkey and Australia, the conference co-hosts, produced a fourth draft on Sunday morning in an effort to bridge the widening divisions between participating nations.
However, the text still makes no explicit mention of moving away from fossil fuels — the omission that previously prompted warnings of possible walkouts.
The EU and Pacific island states have exchanged increasingly sharp words with Saudi Arabia and other oil-producing countries. Those nations have pressed negotiators to keep fossil fuels out of the agreement while including carbon-removal technologies.
Tuvalu’s climate minister, Maina Talia, said it appeared that negotiators were ‘negotiating with the Saudis’. Ireland’s Climate and Energy Minister Darragh O’Brien warned that the world’s prospects of reaching an agreement were ‘diminishing by the hour’.
Mr Talia, whose low-lying Pacific nation faces an existential threat from rising seas, said that if countries could not address fossil fuels, ‘then we are wasting our time here’.
The conference in Antalya was due to conclude on Friday, but negotiators remained deadlocked over the wording of the final agreement.
The talks have now become the longest UN climate conference on record, running more than 44 minutes beyond the scheduled closing time.
Opening the closing plenary on Sunday morning, COP31 President Murat Kurum acknowledged that ‘no one has got everything they wanted’ after days of negotiations between national delegations.
Mr Kurum said that ‘everyone can find something of themselves in this text’ and urged delegates to believe they were ‘on the verge’ of a historic decision.
COP31 President Murat Kurum (C) spoke during the Closing Plenary session on what was meant to be the final day of the COP31 UNFCCC Climate Conference on November 20
Maina Vakafua Talia, Tuvalu’s Minister for Home Affairs, Climate Change and Environment, speaks to journalists during a press conference at the COP31 UN Climate Change Conference in Antalya, Turkey, on November 21
Addressing the closing plenary, Mr O’Brien said: ‘The drafts put before us does not begin to address the climate emergency that we face and therefore the European Union cannot accept it.’
He said the proposal ‘fails to meet the moment the world faces’.
‘At a point where the world urgently needs action to avert disastrous levels of global warming, the draft cover decision falls well short.’
Mr O’Brien said the EU would not support an agreement that failed even to mention fossil fuels.
‘We will not accept a COP that greenwashes fossil fuels,’ he added.
The plenary was delayed repeatedly as negotiators conducted last-minute shuttle diplomacy.
Delegations at the venue — where catering stalls and exhibition stands had already been dismantled — expressed little confidence that a deal was close.
Observers of the closed-door negotiations said Saudi Arabia and other major oil producers were fighting to exclude fossil fuels from the text while securing support for carbon removal.
Hopes of an agreement remained low as countries contended with rising oil prices and geopolitical tensions linked to the war in Iran.
The summit comes after a series of climate-related disasters from Europe to Nepal and Indonesia, while a super El Nino pattern increases the risk of further extreme weather.
An earlier draft released this week called for an accelerated phase-out of fossil fuels. But a shorter version issued on Thursday removed every reference to coal, oil and gas.
Fossil fuels are the leading cause of climate change, yet their future remains one of the most contentious issues at the UN negotiations.
The dispute forced the summit to continue well beyond its original Friday deadline.
On Saturday, negotiating teams had to rearrange flights, despite having little confidence that an agreement would be reached.
The EU and Saudi Arabia were brought together on Saturday as Turkey and Australia made an urgent attempt to broker a compromise.
People protested outside the plenary ahead of the Closing Plenary session on what was the scheduled final day of the COP31 UNFCCC Climate Conference on November 20
Several delegations, speaking anonymously because of the sensitivity of the talks, said countries were considering leaving the conference without a deal.
Jennifer Morgan, a former German climate minister and senior fellow at The Fletcher School at Tufts University, said: ‘After the presidency ignored the views of 150 countries and tabled a very weak text, negotiations are on the brink.’
Environmental campaign group 350.org said it was disappointed that the draft failed to refer explicitly to fossil fuels while encouraging the use of carbon-removal technologies.
IN CASE YOU MISSED IT: President Trump Celebrates Winning The Republican Primaries…How Will The GOP Establishment Try To Stop Him Next? – NewsFinale
‘Carbon capture is one of the biggest scams of the overshoot era, and our leaders are on the verge of falling for it,’ said Sara Shaw, the organisation’s campaigns and networks director. She was referring to efforts to trap carbon dioxide before it enters the atmosphere.
Critics argue that these technologies are costly and have not been proven at scale. They warn that including them in the agreement could allow oil and gas production to continue.
The latest draft followed intensive consultations involving Australia, which is leading the negotiations, Turkey, which is hosting the conference, and almost 200 delegations representing some of the world’s richest, poorest, largest and smallest countries.
The presidency gave nations several hours to submit objections, with a further session scheduled for later on Sunday to begin the approval process.
Australia, backed by Turkey, has been tasked with finding a compromise between countries most vulnerable to climate change and those whose economies rely on the production or consumption of fossil fuels.
This is the first COP since the UN’s environmental body confirmed that global temperatures were on course to surpass 1.5 degrees — the threshold countries agreed more than a decade ago to try to avoid, beyond which the effects of extreme weather intensify.
With expectations already subdued, Australia’s lead negotiators had sought a broad political agreement to capture the outcomes of COP31 and send a signal about the direction of future climate action.
Instead, the latest version of the proposed ‘cover decision’ made no mention of fossil fuels.
Houses lie partially submerged in muddy water along a riverside after flash floods at Trishuli Bazar in Nepal’s Nuwakot district after deadly floods in August
Such wording is strongly opposed by petrostates and countries dependent on fossil fuels, including Saudi Arabia. A Saudi official declined to comment.
‘The situation is difficult, and the outcome is uncertain. The oil-producing countries are putting up a fierce fight,’ a German official said.
Warnings of a walkout on Saturday led Turkey and Australia to arrange an emergency meeting between the EU and Saudi Arabia, but the sides still failed to reach a compromise.
The newest draft makes an indirect reference to a 2023 global agreement to shift away from fossil fuels, but stops short of naming those fuels directly.
‘We are very disappointed with how the text looks,’ Antigua and Barbuda’s environment minister, Michael Joseph, told AFP after leaving the COP31 presidency’s offices.
‘I can’t honestly say that I’m okay with it passing’ in its current state, Mr Joseph said.
The draft also retains a controversial proposal to expand carbon capture and storage, a technology promoted by the fossil fuel industry but criticised by opponents as expensive and ineffective at reducing emissions.
The call to increase carbon capture — a technology backed by the fossil fuel industry — in the previous draft also faced strong resistance.
Critics cite its high costs and limited record of cutting emissions, warning that it could prolong dependence on fossil fuels.
A group of 12 European and developing countries, including France, Panama and the Solomon Islands, issued a letter on Friday demanding that the agreement include ‘a clear transition away from fossil fuels’.
Panama’s environment minister, Juan Carlos Navarro, accused a ‘petroleum mafia’ of obstructing progress and threatened to leave the talks unless a stronger agreement was produced.
Meanwhile, the OPEC oil cartel said on X that its secretary-general, Haitham Al Ghais, had met Russian presidential climate envoy Ruslan Edelgeriev at COP31 on Friday.
A man checked his phone near a building collapsed due to an earthquake, in Reok, East Nusa Tenggara province, Indonesia, in August
Coal generates around one-third of the world’s electricity, while fossil gas accounts for another fifth.
Efforts by Saudi Arabia, India and Kenya to postpone the next series of reports from the UN’s Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change have added to tensions.
The draft says the reports will be important to a planned review of global efforts to cut carbon emissions in 2028.
Dozens of countries across Europe, Africa and the Pacific want the assessments from the world’s leading scientific authority on climate change published in time for that crucial review.
Nations have also clashed over how to respond to the expected breach of the 1.5C warming limit established under the Paris climate agreement.
The latest draft expresses ‘deep concern’ about missing the target but removes an earlier commitment to bring warming back below 1.5C as soon as possible this century.
The negotiations remain stalled by long-standing complaints that wealthy countries are failing to meet their responsibilities to help developing nations cope with climate change.
Developing countries were angered by the removal of a $120billion (£91.74billion) target for climate adaptation finance.