Ed Miliband has said Andy Burnham’s agreement with the EU will proceed even if the dispute over university tuition fees—potentially costing the higher education sector £500 million—remains unresolved.
The Foreign Secretary also indicated that the UK could eventually seek to rejoin the European Union, despite the historic Brexit vote a decade ago, saying that “all options were on the table”.
Speaking to the BBC, he said: “We will look at the benefits and the costs of all the different options.”
Although Mr Miliband said he accepted the outcome of the 2016 Brexit referendum, he argued that “the world has changed massively” since the vote.
“Europe is changing too, so we’ve got to look at what that means. It’s not about this parliament, we’re respecting the red lines in this parliament,” he said.
His comments came as the Prime Minister faced growing criticism over his unilateral move towards closer European ties following yesterday’s meeting with EU leaders, with opponents accusing him of abandoning Brexit promises.
Mr Burnham told the EU that Britain was prepared to discuss rejoining the bloc after securing what he described as a “reset deal” in Brussels. He called the agreement a “win win” and said it could increase the UK economy’s output by as much as £17 billion a year.
The deal includes a reciprocal youth mobility scheme giving 100,000 Europeans aged between 18 and 31 the right to live, work and study in the UK for three years. It also covers an arrangement allowing Britain to follow certain EU regulations from 2028 in exchange for removing checks on British food exports, as well as an agreement on emissions trading schemes.
The Prime Minister said the next year would be used to “brainstorm” ideas with the EU about the future relationship between Britain and the bloc. He described the measures as “incremental steps only” and suggested they were probably “the limit” of what he could achieve before the next general election.
He is expected to set out more of his approach in a 10-year plan due to be unveiled next month.
Ed Miliband signalled that the UK could rejoin the EU despite the historic Brexit vote a decade ago, saying “all options were on the table”
Despite Labour ministers presenting the Prime Minister’s agreement as a success, he was widely viewed as having been caught off guard by EU leaders’ demand that Britain reduce tuition fees for European students in return.
The apparently unexpected last-minute dispute threatened to derail the formal approval of the proposed Brexit reset.
A six-month deadline has now been established to reach an agreement, setting the stage for a potentially bitter dispute.
The Prime Minister also unsettled critics by saying he would explore proposals for even closer ties with the EU in the months ahead.
Only this summer, during the Makerfield by-election—which saw him return to Parliament and begin his short journey to Downing Street—he promised voters that he was “not proposing the UK considers rejoining the EU”.
Appearing to qualify those earlier remarks, Mr Burnham said yesterday that polling indicated the British public “want closer ties” with the EU and that the agreement would deliver them.
But during a week in which former Labour minister Alan Milburn unveiled a plan aimed at helping young Britons struggling to find work, Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch said the agreement would leave young people competing with EU nationals for the same jobs.
She also dismissed the Prime Minister’s economic projections, claiming he had “plucked” the £17 billion figure from the air. Ms Badenoch said it was “not fair” for British farmers to be required to follow rules drawn up in Brussels.
Reform UK leader Nigel Farage was among prominent Brexit supporters to condemn the deal. He called it a “betrayal of the British people” and said it gave the EU an opportunity to “try and humiliate” the UK. He also described Mr Burnham as a “total fraud”.
Lord Frost, the former UK Brexit negotiator, also pointed to what he described as Mr Burnham’s broken promises to voters in Makerfield. “Rarely have we seen so clear a betrayal,” he said.
Writing in today’s Daily Mail, former Conservative minister Michael Gove said: “The deal concluded with the European Union yesterday takes Britain backwards – back to more migration from the EU, back to the EU setting rules for British businesses we can’t veto, back into the interminable process of seeing Brussels expand its reach into all our lives.”
The vice-chancellor of the University of Manchester warned that any decision to charge EU students the same tuition fees as UK students could cost his university up to £7 million a year. Across the higher education sector, the total cost could reach an estimated £500 million.
Under the EU’s proposal, annual fees for individual students could fall from as much as £38,000 to £9,970.
Professor Duncan Ivison also cautioned that EU students could take places currently available to domestic applicants if universities were unable to create additional capacity.
He told Radio 4’s Today programme that the change would have “really clear consequences” and could remove “£500 million from the higher education sector at a time when it is under a lot of pressure”.
“There are genuine issues to iron out. We would have to find at least another £6.5 to £7 million ourselves. It is also not clear we can increase the number of places for EU students.”
However, Ed Miliband insisted that the Brexit reset agreement would go ahead despite the continuing negotiations over tuition fees.
At yesterday’s press conference, European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen said she was “confident” a solution would be reached. Prime Minister Andy Burnham replied: “Me too.”
European Council President Antonio Costa, Britain’s Prime Minister Andy Burnham and European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen
In an interview with the BBC’s Sunday with Laura Kuenssberg programme, due to be broadcast tomorrow morning, Mr Miliband rejected suggestions that the reset agreement would depend on the EU’s university fee demands.
Seeking to play down the dispute, he said it was “absolutely clear” that the agreements on food exports, youth mobility and energy would remain in place.
“President von der Leyen… was very clear about this at the press conference we just had. She said there are those three agreements and then there’s a separate piece of paper and a separate issue, which is looking at the issue of tuition.”
He confirmed that the agreements would begin the legislative process in 2028 and claimed the new arrangements would come at “no cost” to UK taxpayers.
Liberal Democrat leader Sir Ed Davey, a prominent supporter of closer European ties, said the UK needed more than minor changes to its relationship with the EU.
“A youth mobility scheme is a big step forward, but it’s nowhere near enough. We need a whole new deal that actually works for Britain, and fast.”
According to government documents, the new youth experience scheme will begin “no later than January 2030”, while the emissions trading systems agreement will take effect at the start of 2028. The arrangement means £6.5 billion worth of British exports—including steel and aluminium—will be exempt from EU carbon border taxes.
Britain and the EU also agreed to establish a new “structured dialogue” on migration and to work more closely under the Channel action plan, which is intended to disrupt people-trafficking networks.
European Council President Antonio Costa said the bloc was “open to having the closest possible relationship” with Britain, but stressed that the EU remained committed to the rules of the single market, including freedom of movement.
Meanwhile, a source described as a senior ally of the Prime Minister told today’s Times that Mr Burnham was determined to take the UK back into the European Union.
“He wants to rejoin. That’s the truth of it,” the source said.
“He feels it very deeply and thinks he is on the right side of public opinion. The idea that this is being driven by anyone other than him, or that it’s simply clever positioning or tactics, is wrong. It’s just what he believes.”
But in a tense exchange on Radio 4 this morning, Environment Minister Angela Eagle repeatedly declined to answer presenter Justin Webb’s questions about how the government would resolve the university tuition fee dispute.
She offered no further detail beyond saying that negotiations would continue for six months, prompting Mr Webb to accuse her of “point blank refusing to address the concerns of universities”.