A hotel guest died from carbon monoxide poisoning after a handyman was allegedly told to cover chimney pots with plastic bags, a court has heard.
Graham Holden, 66, was found dead at the Royal Hotel in Morecambe, Lancashire, on November 6, 2021.
His death was initially attributed to heart failure.
Several weeks later, however, five members of a family staying in the same room became seriously ill, Preston Crown Court was told.
An investigation found that a handyman had been instructed to seal the chimney pots with plastic bags and duct tape, potentially preventing lethal fumes from escaping.
Prosecutors said the risk of death was “reasonably foreseeable” when the work was carried out.
Liam O’Hagan, 52, director of Bay Rooms Ltd, which was responsible for the hotel’s guests and maintenance, denies gross negligence manslaughter.
He denies ordering the work. His defence told jurors that, even if he had done so, the handyman — a professional roofer — did not believe there was a problem.
Graham Holden, 66, was staying at the Royal Hotel in Morecambe, Lancashire, on November 6, 2021, when he died in circumstances initially believed to involve heart failure
Director Liam O’Hagan, 52, denies gross negligence manslaughter after the court heard that hotel chimneys had been sealed with plastic bags and duct tape, stopping them from carrying exhaust fumes away from the “old, defective” boiler
Fire crews outside the Royal Hotel in Morecambe, Lancashire, on Boxing Day 2021, after a family staying in the room where Mr Holden died fell ill with carbon monoxide poisoning
Mr Holden, from Burnley, was staying at the hotel on November 5, 2021, after an argument with his partner, prosecutor Craig Hassall KC told the jury.
The couple bought a takeaway and returned to the room to talk, he said.
While there, Mr Holden complained of indigestion before falling asleep during the conversation.
His partner left the hotel and returned home, leaving him asleep in the room.
The next morning, housekeeping staff went to check on Mr Holden after he failed to leave at the agreed checkout time.
They found him dead in bed and contacted the emergency services.
An inquest was opened because of the unexpected death but was closed several weeks later after a post-mortem concluded that he had died from heart failure, prosecutors said.
READ MORE: Jack Clark, UK State-School Graduate, Poised to Become an Anthropic AI Billionaire
On Boxing Day 2021, though, the hotel was evacuated after five members of a family staying in the same room became seriously ill.
A handheld carbon monoxide monitor gave a positive reading after the alarm on December 26, 2021. Fire crews later returned wearing breathing apparatus, Preston Crown Court heard
Rebecca Murray, a nurse, vomited several times. One of her children complained of feeling sick before collapsing on the bathroom floor.
Another child appeared shaky and struggled to stand, while her third child collapsed outside after going to the car with her husband.
The family were taken to hospital and treated for carbon monoxide poisoning.
Firefighters searching the hotel for further casualties used a handheld carbon monoxide detector, which flashed a warning and displayed “HIGH HIGH,” Mr Hassall said.
The crews left the building before returning in breathing apparatus.
Gas safety investigators found that the boiler, manufactured in 1995, had not been serviced or maintained since the O’Hagan family took over the hotel in 2012, the prosecution said.
Engineers described its condition as “immediately dangerous”.
Together with the blocked chimneys, which prevented dangerous fumes from escaping, the conditions proved fatal, prosecutors said.
A second post-mortem found high levels of carbon monoxide in Mr Holden’s blood and no evidence of a history of heart problems.
Home Office pathologist Dr Alison Armour recorded the cause of Mr Holden’s death as carbon monoxide poisoning.
Mr Hassall told jurors: “We accept that neither Liam O’Hagan nor anyone else involved in running the Royal Hotel wanted to harm their guests, still less did they want Graham Holden to die.
“But they took the risk of continuing to use an old, defective boiler and blocking the chimney that was meant to carry away its exhaust fumes.
“Taking those risks cost Mr Holden his life, and we say that Liam O’Hagan is criminally responsible.”
Mr O’Hagan, of Bolton-le-Sands, Lancashire, denies gross negligence manslaughter.
The trial is continuing.
IN CASE YOU MISSED IT: Nurse Accused of Offering Man Sex Shares Their Text Messages