Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez Debuts Glam Makeover on Fox News With Paris Hilton to Discuss Explicit Deepfakes

New York Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez made a polished return to Fox News, appearing on the network for the first time in years to discuss...
HomeNewsHow the UK’s Youth Jobs “System Reset” Could Cost Billions

How the UK’s Youth Jobs “System Reset” Could Cost Billions

A proposed strategy to reduce youth unemployment would demand a wholesale reset across the public sector and billions of pounds in annual investment, while delivering only modest savings over the next decade.

Former minister Alan Milburn has called on Andy Burnham to support a multibillion-pound funding package, arguing: “We have to put our money where our mouth is.”

Without what he describes as “radical reforms”, up to 1.27 million people under 25 could be classed as Neet — not in employment, education or training — within five years.

However, it remains uncertain whether the Prime Minister will be able to find the necessary funding. The proposals include an immediate £500 million “down payment” next year, while the report forecasts net savings of only £200 million by 2036-37.

Reform’s Treasury spokesman Robert Jenrick wrote on X: “Alan Milburn’s £200million savings by 2036 is the equivalent of just five hours of welfare spending. That’s about the time it takes to download Grand Theft Auto VI.”

Although Mr Milburn has set out an ambition of achieving “Neet Zero”, the measures are expected to reduce the current rate by only around half — from 13 per cent, or 981,000 people aged 16 to 24 across the UK, to 6.8 per cent in 2036.

Here are the main recommendations contained in his 278-page review.

The report identifies the shrinking availability of the “first rung on the career ladder” as a central factor behind the crisis. Youth employment fell by 4.3 per cent — around 330,000 people — between December 2022 and the end of last year.

Former minister Alan Milburn has urged Andy Burnham to come up with a 'multi-billion pound investment' for youth unemployment

Former minister Alan Milburn has called for Andy Burnham to back a “multi-billion pound investment” in tackling youth unemployment

It delivers a sharp criticism of the combined effect of Labour policies, including higher minimum wages, increased employer National Insurance contributions and new rights introduced through the Employment Rights Act.

Pay costs for workers aged 18 to 20 have risen by 65 per cent in five years. At the same time, the higher National Insurance rate and lower payment threshold have added roughly £800 a year to the cost of employing someone full-time.

“There is nothing progressive about pricing young people out of work,” the review states.

Mr Milburn does not advocate completely reversing Rachel Reeves’ measures. Instead, he proposes a five-year transition aimed at reducing National Insurance costs for employees aged 21 to 24.

When the state of the public finances permits, the threshold at which employers in sectors such as retail and hospitality begin paying National Insurance for workers aged 21 to 24 should rise from £5,000 to £10,000, he says.

Supporters say the change could help preserve Saturday jobs, allowing a young shop worker to complete 15 hours a week before their employer becomes liable for National Insurance.

The review also urges ministers to take a measured approach to the Labour manifesto promise of bringing the minimum wage for 18 to 20-year-olds into line with the National Living Wage. It says the Low Pay Commission should determine the speed of that convergence while prioritising youth employment.

It further highlights possible “unintended consequences” from Angela Rayner’s proposed restrictions on zero-hours contracts. Ministers are urged to assess how the rules, which are still being developed, could affect young workers. Mr Milburn also wants a Youth Opportunity Test to ensure that tax decisions, public spending and new regulations are examined for their impact on the next generation.

Mr Milburn's report warns of the 'unintended consequences' of Angela Rayner's crackdown on zero-hours contracts

Mr Milburn’s review highlights the possible “unintended consequences” of Angela Rayner’s planned crackdown on zero-hours contracts

Have your say

Should taxpayers spend billions on youth employment when earlier reforms have delivered only limited results?

Speaking at Google’s central London offices as he launched the review, Mr Milburn also criticised Sir Keir Starmer’s unsuccessful attempt last year to reduce sickness benefits, describing it as “just a fiscal grab”.

The report says too many children feel disconnected from school, with persistent absence now two-thirds higher than it was before the pandemic.

“Technology has brought huge benefits, but the amount of childhood lived through a screen raises legitimate concerns about sleep, relationships, physical activity, attention and wellbeing,” it says.

According to the review, the roots of the problem can appear during the toddler years. It calls for stronger parental support through “family hubs” and proposes raising the proportion of reception-age children considered school-ready from 75 per cent to 90 per cent. It also recommends a statutory Key Stage 3 assessment of writing, numeracy and speaking skills to identify pupils at risk of becoming Neets.

Schools should be judged partly on how effectively they prepare pupils for employment, Mr Milburn says. A new measure tracking what students do after leaving school should be introduced by 2028.

The report also sets a target of almost doubling the number of apprenticeships, from 172,000 last year to 270,000 within a decade.

More than half of Neets report having a health condition, while the proportion of young people with disabilities has more than doubled over the past 15 years. The review points to a sharp increase in mild mental health conditions, with Covid, “the rise of toxic social media” and loneliness identified as contributing factors.

Young people should receive “immediate access” to support, the report says, with the NHS creating a new digital entry point for mental health services. Instead of waiting for a referral or formal diagnosis, they should be able to find online help, including talking therapies and short counselling courses.

It also recommends removing NHS funding from private ADHD clinics whose business model is described as “cash for diagnosis”.

By 2027, responsibility for signing fit notes should be transferred from GPs, who currently classify almost everyone they assess as being unfit for work.

The number of young people claiming incapacity-related benefits, including Personal Independence Payment (PIP), has more than doubled since 2012 to approximately 250,000.

“Staggeringly, the number of young people claiming PIP is expected to quadruple over just a quarter of a century from 2013 to 2037,” the report says. It adds that the rise in benefit claims has “far outweighed” changes in the level of ill health among young people.

Mr Milburn argues that “crude cuts” would be counterproductive. Leaving young people without support, he says, would simply shift the costs to health services, housing and the criminal justice system.

However, he acknowledges that his proposal for an entirely new benefits framework for under-25s would involve difficult changes.

“They could mean some people get less financial support at the beginning of their benefit claim,” the review says. Young people would no longer rely on a universal credit health top-up or PIP, instead receiving a new Youth Allowance, while protection would remain available for those who are permanently unable to work.

Alongside a guaranteed level of support, the proposals would create what the report calls an “opportunity guarantee” from the state.

A Youth Opportunity Service would act as a single access point for options ranging from government-subsidised employment — with employers receiving £3,000 for each young person hired — to further education, volunteering and Armed Forces cadetships.

As a final safety net, a young person who remained out of work would be offered a genuine, paid six-month position with an employer, funded and arranged by the state.

The proposed timetable would see a young person meet a named adviser within 14 days, receive a personalised Participation Plan within four weeks and have a substantive form of support or activity in place within four months.

Those who repeatedly refuse to take part could eventually lose their Youth Allowance, the report warns.