Karen Read with her legal defense team during jury selection.
Share and Follow

KAREN Read has added a secret weapon to her defense team for her retrial, one that could potentially move the needle to score an acquittal this time around, an attorney has claimed.

As Read faces a second trial for the 2022 murder of her boyfriend John O’Keefe, a Boston police officer, she has added a new member to her defense counsel who served as an alternate juror on her first trial.

Karen Read with her legal defense team during jury selection.

Karen Read talks with her legal defense team during jury selection for her retrial on April 3 in Dedham, MassachusettsCredit: AP:Associated Press
Attorney Victoria George and lawyer David Yannetti at jury selection.

Attorney Victoria George was an alternate juror on Karen Read’s first trialCredit: AP:Associated Press
Photo of Boston Police Officer John O'Keefe.

Read is being charged with the murder of her boyfriend, John O’Keefe (pictured), who was found dead on a snowbank on January 29, 2022Credit: AP:Associated Press
Defense team members and defendant Karen Read at jury selection.

Members of Read’s defense team, (left to right): Victoria George, David Yannetti, defendant Karen Read, Alan Jackson, Elizabeth Little and Robert AlessiCredit: AP:Associated Press

Read is accused of intentionally reversing her SUV into O’Keefe on January 29, 2022, after a night of heavy drinking and leaving him for dead on a snowbank in Canton, Massachusetts, a suburb of Boston.

The adjunct professor, 45, and her defense team have denied the accusations, arguing she’s the victim of a cover-up by local law enforcement officials, who they claim were responsible for O’Keefe’s death.

The first trial, which stretched nine weeks and consisted of more than 65 witness testimonies, ended in a hung jury after jurors returned multiple times telling Judge Beverly Cannone they could not reach a verdict.

Cannone declared a mistrial, setting the stage for the high-profile retrial.

Read has assembled a legal dream team, which includes attorneys Alan Jackson, David Yannetti, Elizabeth Little, Robert Alessi, and most notably Victoria George, who served as an alternate juror in the initial trial last April.

George, a licensed civil attorney in Massachusetts who is now working for Yannetti’s law firm, joined Read’s defense team days before jury selection in the retrial was set to begin.

‘INVALUABLE ASSET’

She told Vanity Fair she joined the group of pink T-shirt loyalists advocating for Read’s innocence after leaving the first trial “wary, distrustful, and scared” of Massachusetts’ legal system.

“What happened to John O’Keefe was a tragedy,” George told the magazine.

“But just because something is sad doesn’t mean that the person in the defendant’s seat is responsible. I can feel bad for his family and believe she’s not guilty at the same time.”

Benjamin Urbelis, a trial attorney at Urbelis Law in Massachusetts, described George’s presence on Read’s defense as an “invaluable asset.”

Karen Read’s haunting admission to a friend after finding her boyfriend’s lifeless body revealed in new 20/20 special

“I think it’s absolutely a smart move by Karen Read and by her defense team,” Urbelis told The U.S. Sun.

“I don’t believe that Victoria George was brought in necessarily for her criminal defense acumen. It doesn’t appear that that’s her speciality, but she has a very unique perspective.

“She was obviously a juror, a sitting juror in the first trial, so she understands the tenor of that courtroom, especially in a trial like this.

“She understands what it’s like to feel as a juror sitting through a trial like this.”

Urbelis continued, “She understands how jurors perceive the witnesses, perceive the evidence, perceive most importantly, perhaps, the lawyers as they advocate for each of their sides.

“And she also, being an attorney herself, understands maybe another perspective on how to apply their defense case, given all of those considerations that sitting jurors might have.

“So, I think it’s an invaluable asset to the defense team. And as a trial lawyer in any case, especially a case like this that’s so complex, it’s always good to have multiple perspectives.”

Karen Read at a pre-trial hearing.

Karen Read appears in Norfolk County Superior Court for a pretrial hearing in May 2024Credit: Getty Images – Getty
Karen Read at a pre-trial hearing.

Read pictured outside Norfolk County Superior Court last MayCredit: Getty Images – Getty
Karen Read and her attorney in court during jury selection.

Karen Read speaking with her new attorney Victoria George during the first day of jury selection on April 1Credit: AP:Associated Press

RUDE AWAKENING

George underscored to Vanity Fair how several questionable, and “potentially unconstitutional,” decisions by Judge Cannone led to her joining Read’s team.

One was the egregious and sexist text messages by disgraced lead investigator Michael Proctor, where he called Read a “whack job and b***h” who should “just kill herself.”

The second instance for George came when Cannone dismissed a juror days before the start of closing arguments after Massachusetts State Police officer John Fanning reported the juror appeared to be “sympathetic to the defense.”

Fanning, who the defense said was one of Proctor’s supervisors and was also in the group text chain, reported the incident to the judge but said he had not personally witnessed the event, according to Vanity Fair.

Despite defense attorney Alan Jackson’s filing a motion to dismiss Fanning’s claims, citing no evidence presented, Judge Cannone sided with state prosecutors.

“I waited for nearly a year after the mistrial, hoping the court system would work as intended to remedy some of the wrongs in this case,” she told the magazine.

Urbelis told The U.S. Sun those moments for George were a rude awakening for a young attorney.

“I thought that was very interesting. It seems that she doesn’t have much experience as a criminal lawyer,” Urbelis said.

“But I often look at how I was in law school, and when I see young lawyers coming out of law school, we’re very optimistic, and we see the legal system in a certain way that after years of practice, we might see that that’s not always the case.

“I think that this might have been a very awakening experience for Victoria George, seeing that the system didn’t exactly play out how she would have expected or how she would have hoped as an attorney, or a legal professional.

“I can’t speak as to why she joined the defense team, but it seems that that might be a big factor that she wanted to provide any assistance she could to make sure that Ms. Reid gets a fair trial this time around, because apparently Victoria George did not feel that that was the case last year.”

Headshot of Benjamin Urbelis.

Benjamin Urbelis, a trial attorney at Urbelis Law, described Victoria George’s presence on Karen Read’s defense as an ‘invaluable asset’Credit: The U.S. Sun
Snow-covered house at night.

The apartment complex is Canton, Massachusetts, a suburb of Boston, where John O’Keefe’s body was found in January 2022Credit: Boston 25
Karen Read and her attorney, David Yanetti, at her trial.

Karen Read has denied any wrongdoing and argues she’s the victim of a cover-up by law enforcement officials in MassachusettsCredit: AP:Associated Press

SUPREME COURT PETITION

On Tuesday, Read’s defense team filed a petition with the Supreme Court, asking the justices to overturn two charges against her on double jeopardy grounds.

Under the Constitution’s Fifth Amendment, the double jeopardy clause prohibits anyone from being prosecuted twice for substantially the same crime.

Read’s attorneys asked the court to dismiss her charges of second-degree murder and leaving the scene of a collision causing injury or death.

The defense argued that after the first trial, jurors told them they came to an agreement that Read was not guilty of the two charges, but remained split on the manslaughter charge.

Read’s lawyers argued that because the jury’s deadlock “was limited to one of the three counts rather than all” she should not have to fight the charges again.

“In sum, the defense learned post-trial that the jury reached a verdict that was not announced,” the petition read.

“It was at least entitled to the opportunity to substantiate that fact in order to ensure Read is not unconstitutionally forced to stand trial for criminal offenses, including murder, of which she has already been acquitted.”

Share and Follow
You May Also Like

‘Human hand’ HAD to be involved in Air India crash disaster, pilot says…as he reveals billions-to-one odds of tech fault

AN EXPLOSIVE new theory from a top aviation expert has ignited fears…

Tsunami warning issued after massive 7.3 magnitude earthquake strikes off US coast

A HUGE 7.3 magnitude earthquake has struck off the coast of Alaska.…

GOP senators warn Trump that firing Powell would send 'shock wave' through economy

Senate Republicans are warning President Trump that it would be a big…

Nigel Farage sparks row with claim ‘convicted sex offenders’ among 20k Afghans airlifted into UK in top-secret mission

Nigel Farage has sparked a furious row after he claimed “convicted sex…

My daughter Amy Bradley vanished on family cruise 27 years ago… eerie clues PROVE she’s still alive & being held captive

EMBARKING on her first ever Caribbean cruise, Amy Bradley was excited for…

Neighbor feud erupts over 9ft ‘Mexican drug cartel’ style privacy fence around home – owner was hit with $1k fine a day

A JUDGE got involved in a dispute between neighbors over a prison-style…

Couple arrested after cops seize 21 surrogate children including 17 TODDLERS at California mansion

A COUPLE has been arrested after it was alleged they had 21…

Connection Between Mercury Public Affairs and Ukraine: Trump’s $2 Billion Deal in Kyiv

A recent FARA filing reveals Mercury Public Affairs, where Susie Wiles served…