Her former husband, relatives, friends and colleagues have all described her as a devoted mother and caring nurse.
Psychiatrists and other medical professionals have offered insight into her private thoughts and long-running mental health struggles.
Even several jurors waived their anonymity to speak about the criminal trial that captivated the nation earlier this year.
But Lindsay Clancy, the woman at the center of the tragedy, has said nothing publicly.
Now, as she prepares for a second trial over the deaths of her three children during what her defense says was a postpartum mental health crisis, could that finally change?
In an exclusive interview with the Daily Mail, Clancy’s attorney, Kevin Reddington, did not rule out the possibility that the mother of three could testify at her retrial.
“That’s one of those issues that you have to wait to find out,” he said with a smile.
The 36-year-old former labor and delivery nurse continues to struggle psychologically, while also confronting the knowledge that she killed her children—five-year-old Cora, three-year-old Dawson and eight-month-old Callan—in 2023.
She remains under suicide watch at Tewksbury Hospital in Massachusetts, where she receives round-the-clock care.
Still, Reddington believes Clancy will be able to endure the proceedings now that a retrial has been scheduled.
Lindsay Clancy and her attorney Kevin Reddington in court on Monday, where she learned she would face a second trial on first-degree murder charges
Clancy strangled her three children—five-year-old Cora, three-year-old Dawson and eight-month-old Callan—to death at her Duxbury, Massachusetts, home in 2023. She is pictured with her two eldest children and former husband, Patrick
“She’s a very strong person. She has a very strong faith. She knows that she’s supported by many, many people—family, friends and innumerable people,” he said.
“She knows she was caught in the vortex of a whirlwind of horrific medical care and terrible medication, and understands that this case has, and will continue to, shine a light on the treatment of women with mental health issues.”
Reddington spoke with the Daily Mail outside Plymouth County Superior Court in Massachusetts on Monday, shortly after prosecutors confirmed their plans to retry Clancy on first-degree murder charges and a new trial date was set.
The veteran defense lawyer, who was previously best known for representing Catherine Greig, the girlfriend of mobster James “Whitey” Bulger, responded to the decision to pursue the most serious charges. He also discussed the possibility of a plea agreement.
He described the personal toll the case has taken and the difficulties involved in selecting a jury for such a high-profile proceeding, especially after the controversy surrounding the juror who refused to join the others in reaching a verdict.
At Monday’s crucial hearing, Judge William Sullivan scheduled Clancy’s retrial for March 29, 2027. Prosecutors had sought a later date that year, but that timetable could have extended beyond the judge’s mandatory retirement and caused further delays.
Prosecutors Jennifer Sprague and Shanan Buckingham also indirectly confirmed that they intend to pursue first-degree murder charges again.
The Plymouth County District Attorney’s Office, led by Tim Cruz, first filed the charges just days after Clancy strangled her children and attempted to take her own life inside the family’s Duxbury home on January 24, 2023.
During her first trial, Clancy pleaded not guilty by reason of insanity. Her defense argued that she was not criminally responsible because she was experiencing postpartum psychosis and depression.
Eleven jurors concluded that Clancy was not criminally responsible, while the lone holdout, Michael Desronvil, believed she should be convicted of murder. The jury could not reach a unanimous decision, resulting in a mistrial and leaving prosecutors to decide whether to try her again and which charges to pursue.
Kevin Reddington spoke with the Daily Mail about a possible plea agreement and whether Clancy could testify
Sprague avoided directly answering the judge’s question about the charges on Monday, but said the retrial would require a jury. Her comment effectively signaled the prosecution’s intentions because Massachusetts law allows Clancy to choose a bench trial if she were facing lesser charges.
Clancy’s defense team learned of the prosecution’s decision only during the hearing.
Reddington said he was “not surprised,” adding: “I never expected anything less from Mr. Cruz.”
But he said he was “disappointed”—not only for Clancy, but also for everyone who will have to revisit the children’s deaths in court.
“I’m not surprised. I had pretty much predicted that all along,” he said.
“But I am very disappointed. I feel badly for Lindsay, for her family, for everybody this case has touched and will continue to touch, including the court staff, police, first responders, everybody. It’s just terrible. Patrick [Clancy] too—it goes on and on. And there will be jurors we don’t even know yet sitting here in the spring for five weeks. Terrible.”
It remains unclear whether the district attorney’s office consulted Patrick Clancy, Lindsay’s former husband and the children’s father, before making its decision.
Patrick attended the first trial only on the two days when prosecutors called him to testify.
After the mistrial was declared, his attorney said in a statement that “the prospect of reliving this tragedy through another trial is extraordinarily painful.”
In the three years since the killings, Patrick has worked to rebuild his life. He moved to New York and married again. He and his new wife, fertility specialist Dr. Rachel Danis, are expecting their first child.
Patrick Clancy with his three children. It is unclear whether the district attorney’s office discussed the retrial decision with him
Reddington said he was not surprised but was “disappointed” by the state’s decision to pursue the charges again, citing the impact on Clancy and both families
He could now be called to testify again about the deaths of his three older children just as he and Danis prepare to welcome their first baby together.
The Daily Mail has contacted the district attorney’s office for comment.
Beyond the emotional toll on the victims’ families, Reddington said finding an impartial jury for the nationally followed case will be a significant challenge.
“It’s a very emotional case. Nobody is more aware of the loss of these three children than Lindsay, her family and the people close to them.
“It’s a terrible, terrible case. People are entitled to their opinions, obviously. But I think we could try to pick a jury in Spain and still have difficulty.”
The first trial ended dramatically after allegations that the holdout juror had refused to apply the legal standard of reasonable doubt. It later emerged that Desronvil had previously been arrested in a domestic violence case, raising questions about whether he had been truthful during jury selection.
Desronvil’s attorney, Heather O’Connor, told the Daily Mail last week that her client had no doubts about Clancy’s guilt and had answered the jury questionnaire truthfully.
Citing the allegations, Reddington requested an investigation into Desronvil and sought dismissal of the charges on double-jeopardy grounds, arguing that the mistrial could have been avoided.
Judge Sullivan rejected both requests last week, clearing the way for the retrial.
Clancy’s attorneys are appealing the decision denying their motion to dismiss.
For now, however, the legal challenges surrounding the juror appear to have reached an end.
“I don’t even call him the holdout juror. I call him the obstructionist juror,” Reddington said of Desronvil.
“His shelf life is expired. And, as Ronald Reagan said, we’ll consign him to the dustbin of history.”
A bench trial could have eliminated concerns about selecting jurors and probably would have been considerably shorter than the seven-week proceeding held the first time.
Reddington said he and Clancy had not determined whether they would have chosen that option had prosecutors filed lesser charges.
“That depends on a lot of factors. Not least of all, I would have to speak with her at length and find out her position, then evaluate it, see who the judge is and consider that type of thing,” he said.
For now, Reddington maintains that he would not change his defense strategy if the case goes to trial again.
He said the only difference might be the witnesses called to testify.
One point, he said, is certain: there will be no plea deal before trial.
“Absolutely not,” he insisted.
Asked whether prosecutors could offer anything that might be considered, he replied: “I wouldn’t bet against myself. If they want to come and talk to me, they know where I am.”
The intense public interest in the case has also transformed Reddington’s life, turning him from a prominent Massachusetts attorney into a nationally recognized figure almost overnight.
The trial ended in a mistrial after Michael Desronvil refused to join the other 11 jurors in finding Clancy not guilty by reason of lack of criminal responsibility
Reddington is surrounded by media outside court. He went from being a prominent Massachusetts attorney to a national household name almost overnight
On social media, some users cast him as a feminist folk hero, while supporters appeared in clothing featuring his photograph and memorable courtroom phrases.
He also faced criticism, and during the final days of the trial he arrived at court with a private security guard.
“You’d have to ask my wife that question, to be honest with you,” Reddington joked when asked how the case had affected his life. “It’s been very emotional and draining for a lot of people, including myself.”
He acknowledged receiving threats but said he tries not to worry about them. “That comes with the terrain. So it’s not something to get stressed about.”
Instead, Reddington said his attention is firmly on Clancy and helping her face a second trial.
“She is a very kind, decent person who was a wonderful mother, wonderful wife and great nurse. People were lined up from here to Boston to testify on her behalf and speak about her character,” he said.
“There’s not a person in that courtroom, this county or this state who would have anything bad to say about her—other than the prosecution.”