A mother has told an inquest that she was denied access to her critically ill daughter at three hospitals before the 21-year-old died, weeks after receiving a Covid-19 vaccine booster.
Natalie Boyce, a fit and active law student, died at Melbourne’s Alfred hospital on March 27, 2022, five weeks after receiving a Moderna booster.
The Coroners Court of Victoria began examining her death on Monday, with her mother seeking answers about what happened.
Ms Boyce was in her fourth year of a Bachelor of Laws and Commerce at Deakin University. She was working four days a week and had adopted a fitness-focused lifestyle before she became ill.
She had also planned to travel to Greece for her 22nd birthday in June that year.
Counsel assisting the coroner, Rachel Ellyard, outlined Ms Boyce’s final weeks using evidence from a statement provided by her mother, Deborah Hamilton.
Ms Hamilton described her daughter as happy, healthy and energetic, as well as a successful university student and dedicated worker who had already accomplished a great deal at a young age.
The inquest heard that Ms Boyce received a Moderna Covid-19 booster on February 18, following Victoria’s record-breaking lockdowns.
At the time, Victorians had been told restrictions would continue unless they received three doses of a Covid-19 vaccine.
Sporty law student Natalie Boyce was 21 when she died at Melbourne’s Alfred hospital on March 27, 2022, five weeks after receiving a Moderna booster
The following day, Ms Boyce fainted and struck her head.
Over the next two weeks, she saw her general practitioner and attended Angliss Hospital and Monash Health’s Clayton campus before presenting at Mulgrave Private Hospital on March 5.
An electrocardiogram performed at Mulgrave indicated possible pericarditis, an inflammation of the sac surrounding the heart.
Her health deteriorated rapidly and she was transferred to The Alfred, where doctors placed her on life support within hours.
The court heard Ms Hamilton drove her daughter to Mulgrave after calling triple-0 and being told an ambulance would not be available straight away.
She briefly spoke to Natalie as paramedics prepared to take her to The Alfred.
“Tragically, as Ms Hamilton has explained in her statement, that was the last opportunity Natalie and her mother had to speak to each other,” Ms Ellyard said.
Ms Boyce remained at The Alfred for about three weeks without speaking to her mother again.
Natalie Boyce’s condition deteriorated rapidly after she was transferred to The Alfred, where she was placed on life support within hours
She died on March 27 after suffering cardiac arrest during an MRI scan.
Ms Hamilton, who raised Natalie and her older son Hayden as a single mother, later gave evidence to a Senate committee in May 2023.
She told senators she had felt powerless throughout her daughter’s treatment.
“I was not allowed into the hospital because of government Covid regulations,” she said, referring to Natalie’s time at Angliss.
At Monash, Ms Hamilton said she still had text messages in which her daughter pleaded for her to come and stay with her. She claimed Natalie was left sitting in a chair for eight hours during a visit lasting about 16 hours.
She said the experience at Mulgrave Private Hospital was different.
Staff allowed her to remain in the emergency department, but after following the ambulance to The Alfred at about 2.30am, she said she was refused entry and told to go home.
Ms Hamilton told senators that, during her daughter’s three weeks in intensive care, visits were initially restricted to one hour on three days each week. That was later increased to one hour per day.
Deborah Hamilton drove her daughter Natalie, pictured, to Mulgrave after calling triple-0 and being told an ambulance would not arrive immediately
Coroner Catherine Fitzgerald will investigate whether Ms Boyce had myocarditis, an inflammation of the heart muscle, and what caused the condition.
The inquest will also consider whether antiphospholipid syndrome, an autoimmune disorder diagnosed in 2016, contributed to her death.
Two other issues under examination are when her illness could reasonably have been identified as cardiac in nature and whether different or additional treatment before March 6 might have saved her life.
A forensic pathologist has proposed that Ms Boyce suffered a heart attack linked to myocarditis, which was likely triggered by a vaccine reaction in a person with her immune condition.
A cardiologist appointed by Moderna, which is represented at the inquest, has challenged that conclusion.
The US pharmaceutical company maintains that myocarditis was not the primary cause of Ms Boyce’s death and is expected to vigorously contest the claim.
The inquest heard that an expert panel advising the Therapeutic Goods Administration concluded Ms Boyce’s myocarditis was probably associated with vaccination, while noting that other factors may also have played a part.
The TGA has since recommended stronger myocarditis warnings in the product information for both Moderna and Pfizer vaccines.
Deborah Hamilton criticised former premier Dan Andrews over allegations that he received special treatment while in hospital for a back injury
At Angliss Hospital, tests for heart damage were performed and recorded as normal, although the inquest will assess whether the ECG contained indications of a cardiac issue.
Ms Boyce spent about 15 hours at Monash Health on March 3, where neither an ECG nor a troponin test was carried out.
The court heard a Monash review panel failed to reach a consensus on whether those tests should have been ordered.
The Alfred’s treatment is not being investigated because the court heard Ms Boyce was so seriously ill on arrival that different care would not have prevented her death.
The inquest was reminded that the case must be considered without hindsight and that “it’s not part of the coroner’s role to find fault or apportion blame”.
Instead, the process aims to establish what happened and identify ways to prevent similar deaths in the future.
The court also set clear boundaries around the inquiry.
“It is not about the pros and cons of vaccination,” Ms Ellyard said.
Ms Hamilton claimed an Alfred nurse told her Daniel Andrews could receive visitors whenever he wanted, without time limits, while he was hospitalised during Covid restrictions
Ms Hamilton spoke angrily about her daughter’s death when addressing the Senate committee.
“Victoria was one of the most locked-down places, and that is partly why Natalie had these vaccines,” she said.
She also criticised former Victorian premier Dan Andrews over allegations that he received preferential treatment while recovering in hospital from a back injury during the pandemic.
Ms Hamilton said an Alfred nurse had told her Mr Andrews was permitted to have visitors whenever he wanted, without time restrictions, while he was in hospital during lockdown.
“Daniel Andrews forced us,” Ms Hamilton told the Senate.
“I think Dan Andrews is the most corrupt person out there, and I don’t understand why he has different rules than the rest of us.
“It is just so unfair.”