Portrait of Marlean Ames sitting in a chair in a law office.
Share and Follow

A WOMAN who says she was passed over for a promotion because she is straight just scored a big win in the Supreme Court.

The justices ruled Thursday in her favor, slamming a rule that made it harder for “majority” workers to sue for discrimination.

Portrait of Marlean Ames sitting in a chair in a law office.

Marlean Ames was a longtime employee at the Ohio Department of Youth ServicesCredit: Reuters
The U.S. Supreme Court building.

The Supreme Court sided Ames, who said her gay boss unfairly passed her over for a promotionCredit: Reuters
Woman and man sitting at a conference table during a meeting.

The court unanimously backed Ames, with support from both conservative and liberal justicesCredit: Reuters

The case stems from a dispute in Ohio.

Marlean Ames, an employee at the Ohio Department of Youth Services since 2004, claimed she lost out on a job offer because her boss, who is gay, picked another gay woman for the role instead.

Ames filed what is known as a “reverse discrimination” lawsuit, and ended up losing in lower courts because of a controversial requirement.

That rule, known as the “background circumstances” test, made it harder for straight or white workers to sue.

To move forward, people like Ames had to show proof that their employer was biased against the majority, like stats or a pattern of past incidents, CNN reported.

She couldn’t provide that, and judges tossed her case as a result.

However, the Supreme Court struck that standard down, with liberal Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson writing the majority opinion that explained the decision.

Jackson said it was wrong to apply different rules based on someone’s race, gender, or sexual orientation.

“These requirements do not vary based on whether or not the plaintiff is a member of a majority group,” she wrote.

She called the background circumstances rule a “judge-made” test that “flouts that basic principle.”

Supreme Court rules people CAN wild camp in National Park

The court’s decision was unanimous, with both conservative and liberal justices backing Ames.

The ruling wipes out the extra hurdle for plaintiffs like her in at least five appeals courts across the country.

It doesn’t mean Ames automatically wins her case, but now she gets another shot in court.

Her lawyer celebrated the move as a major win for fairness.

“We wanted to make sure that the same laws and standards apply to everyone,” Xiao Wang, who directs the University of Virginia School of Law’s Supreme Court Litigation Clinic, told CNN.

“This Supreme Court ruling makes it easier for courts to root out unlawful discrimination in the workplace.”

In the footnotes of the official Supreme Court opinion, Justice Clarence Thomas agreed with the ruling, but added a harsh warning about DEI efforts.

He wrote that major companies were “obsessed” with diversity programs and had gone too far.

“American employers have long been ‘obsessed’ with ‘diversity, equity, and inclusion’ initiatives and affirmative action plans,” Thomas wrote.

“Initiatives of this kind have often led to overt discrimination against those perceived to be in the majority.”

BACK TO THE COURTS

The case was heard in February 2025 and drew strong support from justices during oral arguments.

Even the Biden and Trump administrations said the court of appeals’ reasoning was flawed and needed to reconsider.

Still, Ohio officials are standing firm.

“The court made clear that this case is not over,” said Dominic Binkley, a spokesperson for Ohio Attorney General Dave Yost.

“We look forward to fully pressing those arguments as the case moves forward because the Ohio Department of Youth Services did not engage in unlawful discrimination.”

Since she started working for the department, Ames steadily rose through the ranks before the alleged snub in 2017.

The new ruling sends her case back down for further proceedings, but with a level playing field this time.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like

Trump Criticizes NBC Reporter for Question on Thanksgiving Costs at Walmart

During a press briefing on Friday, President Trump sharply criticized an NBC…

House Republican Foresees Prolonged Government Shutdown Stretching Past Thanksgiving

On Friday, Rep. Tim Burchett (R-Tenn.) expressed his belief that the current…

Trump Officially Backs Ramaswamy in Ohio Governor Race

Former President Donald Trump has thrown his support behind Vivek Ramaswamy in…

Patriots Owner Robert Kraft Criticizes Zohran Mamdani Following His Historic Mayoral Victory in New York

New York City mayor-elect Zohran Mamdani’s victory speech has been labeled as…

Therapy Dog Honored with Humane Society Award for Consoling Grieving Nashville Students

The American Humane Society has recognized a retired therapy dog from the…

Keeley Hawes Reflects on 21 Years with Matthew Macfadyen: Embracing Marital Ups and Downs and the Joy of Turning 50

Keeley Hawes reveals an unexpected aspect of the Met Gala: its surprisingly…

Ben Shapiro’s Fiery Clash with Megyn Kelly: The Tucker Carlson Defense Debate Ignites

Ben Shapiro recently expressed strong disapproval towards Megyn Kelly after she defended…

Inside Condé Nast: Viral Video Unveils ‘Woke’ Staff Clash Leading to Mass Layoffs

This week, Condé Nast found itself at the center of two…