Two police officers have been dismissed for gross misconduct after serious failures in the investigation into a crash that killed three young people, the police watchdog has said.
Eve Smith and Darcy Ross, both aged 21, and 24-year-old Rafel Jeanne were found dead at the scene on the A48 in St Mellons, Cardiff, South Wales, on March 6, 2023—almost two days after they were last seen.
Sophie Russon, then 20, and Shane Loughlin, then 32, were also discovered inside the Volkswagen Tiguan. Both had suffered serious injuries.
The collision is believed to have taken place at around 2am on March 4, 2023.
The five occupants remained trapped in the vehicle for approximately 46 hours before they were found.
Gwent Police received the first missing-person report involving the group at about 7.30pm on March 4, according to the Independent Office for Police Conduct (IOPC).
PC Richard Hardwick and PC Lauren Livingstone faced disciplinary proceedings over the response, including allegations that they failed to search the homes of two women reported missing by their families.
The panel ruled on Friday that PC Hardwick breached professional standards by failing to search the properties of two missing young women, the watchdog said.
The mothers of Eve Smith and Darcy Ross comfort one another after two officers were dismissed for gross misconduct over the handling of the search for their missing daughters
Eve Smith was among three people found dead at the scene of the A48 crash in St Mellons, Cardiff, on March 6, 2023
Darcy Ross, 21, was found dead two days after she and her friends disappeared
Emma Borg, Eve Smith’s mother, holds a photograph of her daughter, who was reported missing before being found inside the wrecked vehicle
Following the officers’ dismissal, Eve Smith’s mother Emma Borg, pictured with Eve’s sister Lauren Doyle, described the decision as an ‘important step’ for the families
He later misled both his supervisor and IOPC investigators by claiming the searches had taken place, while also entering inaccurate information in a police log.
PC Livingstone was likewise found guilty of gross misconduct after failing to search the properties when she attended alongside PC Hardwick.
The watchdog said she deliberately used unclear wording in the police log, creating the impression that searches had been completed despite knowing they had not.
She was also found to have acted dishonestly by telling her supervisor that the searches had been carried out.
Both officers have been dismissed and will be added to the College of Policing’s barred list, meaning they will not be allowed to work in policing again.
The IOPC described their conduct as ‘inexcusable’ and said they had failed to meet the ‘fundamental basics of policing’.
Members of Eve Smith’s family let out sighs of relief as the panel’s decision was announced.
After the dismissals, her mother Emma Borg and sister Lauren Doyle said the ruling represented an ‘important step’ for the bereaved families.
Shane Loughlin, then 32, suffered serious injuries in the crash
Sophie Russon was found seriously injured inside the crashed Volkswagen Tiguan
Rafel Jeanne, 24, was among those found dead at the A48 crash scene
The group was not located until almost 48 hours after the car left the dual carriageway and struck trees in St Mellons, Cardiff
Darcy Ross’s relatives, including her mother Clare, joined them as the devastated families struggled to hold back tears and supported one another.
Ms Doyle said the family had ‘never wanted to spend years scrutinising police decisions—we simply wanted our girls found’.
Holding a photograph of Eve, Ms Borg said: ‘No finding or dismissal can undo what happened or bring Eve or Darcy back.
‘The search for the truth has come at an enormous emotional cost. We have been forced time and again to relive the most painful moments of our lives and describe experiences no family should ever have to endure.
ALSO READ: Thanksgiving Travel Faces Red Alert as Perfect Storm Takes Shape
‘There were times when it felt as though our own honesty and credibility were being questioned, when all we wanted was help to find our girls.’
Ms Borg added: ‘We trusted the police to carry out their duties, follow the correct procedures, and use their experience and resources to help locate Eve, Darcy and Sophie.
‘Instead, the dishonesty uncovered during these proceedings damaged the missing-person investigation and weakened the trust our families needed to place in those responsible for helping us.
‘These were not just administrative mistakes; these were our daughters.’
Lauren Doyle said the misconduct ruling was an ‘important step’, but added that the family’s search for answers was not over.
She said: ‘We lost far more than the 20 years Eve had lived.
‘We lost the next 50 or 60 years she should have had—the milestones, the laughter, the everyday moments and the future we always believed we would share.
‘We did not simply want more time; we wanted the life we were meant to have with Eve.’
Ian Arundale, who chaired the panel, said the officers’ conduct had affected Eve and Sophie’s families and friends, while also undermining public confidence in the police.
He dismissed both officers without notice, saying the seriousness of the case meant a final written warning would not have been sufficient.
Their actions, he added, had compromised the ‘integrity of a missing persons investigation’.
PC Hardwick faced six allegations, including claims that he falsely said he had searched the crash victims’ homes and then lied to both his supervisor and the police watchdog.
PC Livingstone faced four allegations, including dishonesty over the searches, an inaccurate police-log entry and misleading her supervisor.
Four allegations against Hardwick were proven in full, while two were proven in part. Every allegation against Livingstone was upheld.
Derrick Campbell, the IOPC’s director of engagement, said: ‘Our thoughts and sympathies remain with the families and friends of the young people who lost their lives, those who were seriously injured and everyone affected by this tragedy.
‘The conduct of PC Hardwick and PC Livingstone was inexcusable. Both failed to meet the most basic expectations of policing—to act honestly and with integrity.
‘Searching properties is a straightforward but vital part of the early response to a missing-person investigation.
‘PC Hardwick deliberately lied throughout the investigation, stating in police records and to his supervisor that the searches had been completed.
‘He then had another opportunity to give a truthful account to IOPC investigators, but lied to them as well.
‘PC Hardwick would have understood that the information he provided was false, yet chose to repeat it.
‘PC Livingstone had several opportunities to explain to the IOPC that the required searches had not taken place.
‘Instead, during her interview, she provided no account and said she could not remember the details of her visits to the homes of two young women reported missing.’
Chief Superintendent John Davies of Gwent Police said: ‘Our thoughts remain with everyone affected by these tragic events.
‘We offer our condolences to the families and friends of Darcy, Eve and Rafel, and recognise the continuing consequences for those who were injured that night.
‘We understand the devastating effect this case has had on the families, their friends and the wider community.
‘It was important that these matters were independently and thoroughly investigated in an open and transparent way, and that they were then examined by independent panel members during these hearings.
‘Although the independent panel has now reached its decision regarding two officers, we recognise that another hearing will take place to examine the conduct of two further officers connected to the handling of the missing-person reports.’
Two additional Gwent Police officers are still awaiting a gross misconduct hearing over their handling of the missing-person reports.