Fear is returning to The Valley. Charlton’s 1-0 defeat by Bolton on Tuesday night, their fourth consecutive loss, was met by a chorus of boos that reflected the supporters’ frustration.
The Addicks have now gone 11 games without a win and are hovering just above the Championship relegation zone. It is a familiar and deeply unwelcome position for a fanbase that has already travelled this difficult road and has no desire to do so again.
That is especially painful after Charlton believed those dark days were finally behind them. Just 10 weeks ago, they were top of the table after beating Preston to complete a run of three victories at the start of the season, including a memorable triumph in front of a record Championship crowd of 62,264 at West Ham.
It now looks like a false dawn. For the first time since Nathan Jones took charge, Charlton’s progress has stalled and, for the moment, the club is moving backwards.
Charlton appeared destined for relegation to League Two for the first time in their history when Jones arrived in February 2024. Instead, they went 14 matches unbeaten and survived. After spending eight of the previous nine seasons in the third tier, Jones guided them back to the Championship through the play-offs at the next opportunity and then kept them there last season.
For a club that had endured years of instability, a period of consistency and gradual improvement seemed within reach. Jones is Charlton’s ninth managerial appointment since June 2016. Now, however, the question is how much longer this situation can continue before nine becomes 10.
Fear is returning to The Valley, with Charlton 11 games without a win and hovering just above the Championship relegation zone
For the first time under Nathan Jones, Charlton’s progress has stalled and the club is currently going backwards
‘If I hadn’t done what I’ve done at this football club, it would have been an easier decision for them [the owners],’ Jones told South London Sport this week. ‘I have to win football games. Win games or you don’t survive.’
His next opportunity comes against ninth-placed Sheffield United on Saturday afternoon. Jones maintains that he has a strong relationship with the Charlton board. New chief executive Ben Mansford, formerly of Leeds, Blackpool and Barnsley, ended the club’s 19-month wait for an appointment to that role and twice attempted to hire Jones at his previous clubs. Jones is also understood to retain the support of his players.
It may be best not to remind him, though, that both Alan Pardew and Chris Powell lost their jobs after defeats by the Blades.
‘We’ve spent a lot of time in League One recently and I think there is a kind of head-in-hands worry at the moment: please let’s not go back there again,’ Heather McKinlay, chair of the Charlton Athletic Supporters’ Trust, tells Daily Mail Sport.
‘At the moment, it feels more like duty than fun. I think we have become a little bit worn down because we’ve been through the mill so much with the changes of ownership and the shenanigans over the nearly 20 years since we were in the Premier League.’
They have been through the mill, with many of those problems caused by the people in charge. Former owner Roland Duchatelet, who still owns The Valley and Charlton’s training ground, once accused supporters of wanting the club to fail. Fans responded to his comments and the club’s mismanagement by carrying a red coffin to The Valley, followed by a crowd of mourners in a mock funeral protest against his ownership.
They also threw hundreds of plastic pigs onto the pitch during one match, used beach balls to stop another and sent a black cab to Belgium as a ‘Taxi for Roland’.
Within weeks of Duchatelet selling Charlton to businessmen Tahnoon Nimer and Matt Southall for £1, the pair became embroiled in a bitter public dispute. Nimer accused Southall of using club money to fund his lifestyle, an allegation Southall denied. The claims included renting a £150,000-a-year London flat and providing a fleet of Range Rovers to associates. Charlton supporters responded by occupying the boardroom in protest. Thomas Sandgaard, the next owner, was arrested by the FBI this year and charged with fraud. He denies any wrongdoing.
IN CASE YOU MISSED IT: Hamas commander Hatem Alramery who oversaw rocket launches blown up by Israeli warplane as terrorists reject ceasefire – NewsFinale
Charlton’s impressive away victory at West Ham in August now appears to have been a false dawn
Jones is Charlton’s ninth manager in the last 10 years, but how much longer can he continue?
‘Charlton fans are a proactive lot,’ McKinlay adds. ‘If they feel they can make a difference, they’ll do something. I don’t feel we can do anything right now other than cheer them on. I think the ownership want the club to succeed. The manager wants the club to succeed. The players want the club to succeed. There’s not really a baddie in this.’
As one club insider put it this week, there is something reassuring, in a strange way, about football being the main problem for once rather than events off the pitch.
Even so, questions remain. The current ownership group, known as Global Football Partners, consists of seven shareholders, each holding more than five per cent. It is still unclear who is driving the project. Sources suggest some shareholders are more prepared than others to invest, while there have been murmurs that the club could once again be for sale. Charlton insist they are simply seeking additional investment to help move the club forward.
Recruitment has done little to improve the situation. The summer was dominated by talk of ‘evolving’ from a side capable of winning League One and surviving in the Championship into a team equipped to compete at this level.
Yet the club’s net spending this summer was only £1.5million. Charlton failed to sign the right winger they needed after a late deal for Crystal Palace winger Jesurun Rak-Sakyi collapsed. Instead, they brought in teenager Junior Nkeng, who has not played a minute. The lack of a creative midfielder is just as apparent.
Some of the players who did arrive have also struggled to make an impact. Millenic Alli enraged supporters during the Bolton defeat when, in stoppage time and with Charlton chasing an equaliser, he headed the ball blindly into open space. Nathaniel Chalobah joined as a free agent from Sheffield Wednesday with a reputation for injuries. He showed his quality early in the season, was sidelined, returned and is now injured again.
Then there is the strange uncertainty surrounding midfielder Timothy Ouma. The Kenya international travelled to represent his country during the recent international break and has not been seen since. Ouma has not been included in a single matchday squad since the break and has a history of this, having also failed to return from international duty while on loan at Lech Poznan.
Asked about the situation a few weeks ago, Jones said: ‘We will address those rumours when they become relevant. Anything we need to put out, we will put out.’
Kenya midfielder Timothy Ouma travelled to represent his country during the recent break and has not been seen since
Nathaniel Chalobah (right) joined as a free agent from Sheffield Wednesday with a reputation for injuries. He was sidelined, returned and is now injured again
Charlton have remained tight-lipped over whether Ouma is still absent, although one insider admitted they had not seen him since the players returned from international duty. The Kenyan FA did not respond to requests for clarification.
That makes the decision to release club captain Greg Docherty in the summer look even more questionable, with Charlton now appearing short of leadership. Jones has been forced to keep reshuffling his squad and line-up, throwing the pieces into the air and seeing where they land. Some supporters have dubbed it selection and formation roulette.
The Welshman is not to everyone’s taste and is often mocked for his David Brent-style manner, but there remains a belief, including within Jones himself, that he can reverse the decline. ‘He’s a maverick, but he’s our maverick,’ McKinlay says with a laugh.
Time is beginning to run short, however. If Charlton cannot rediscover their direction soon, the alternative is already too alarming to contemplate.
YOU MIGHT ALSO LIKE: Meet Peter Dager: The Actor Behind Santi in ‘Stick’ on Apple TV+