It comes as no surprise that Roy Keane has voiced his doubts about appointing Michael Carrick as the permanent manager of Manchester United. However, Gary Neville’s similar stance might raise a few eyebrows among fans and pundits alike.

Keane was forthright in his assessment, stating, “Even if United were to win every match from now until the season’s end, I wouldn’t recommend Carrick for the job. The club requires a manager with more experience and a larger presence.”

He elaborated on the monumental scale of the challenges United will face in the coming years, emphasizing the need for someone capable of clinching league titles. “Do I genuinely believe Michael Carrick is the right person to lead Man United to league victories? I’m not convinced,” Keane remarked.

Adding to the discussion, Neville reflected on the club’s recent decision-making patterns, commenting, “Manchester United has made several emotional decisions over recent years.” His words suggest a need for a more strategic approach in choosing their next manager.

Neville added: ‘Manchester United have acted emotionally a few times over the last few years.

‘The familiarity is back, they play with intensity and quality.

‘I think it’s right that he has the baton until the end of the season and hands the baton over to a Tuchel.

‘Carrick will recognise what I’m saying.’