Ollie Watkins’ omission from Aston Villa’s side at Brighton may have marked the final stage of a saga that began more than 18 months ago.
The England striker addressed his team-mates on Monday to give his version of events and is now expected to complete his acrimonious move to Al Hilal in a deal worth approximately £50million.
Watkins’ decision to sit out Villa’s 4-0 defeat at the Amex, despite being the club’s only fit senior striker, deepened the divide between the player, the club and its supporters. Repairing that relationship was always going to be difficult. Yet the dispute did not emerge without warning.
Daily Mail Sport examines the events that led to this point — and considers what Aston Villa’s future may look like without Watkins…
The Arsenal approach
At some stage last week, Watkins held talks with Villa manager Unai Emery. The Spaniard came away believing that the 30-year-old was determined to join Al Hilal and willing to take significant steps to make the transfer happen.
Watkins did not train last week while waiting for Villa to accept an offer. Al Hilal failed to submit the required bid and, once Emery realised the striker would not take part in preparations, he decided not to select him against Brighton. With Tammy Abraham and Brian Madjo injured, Villa were left without a recognised striker and suffered a heavy defeat. Emery offered little public defence of Watkins, who was subsequently criticised by supporters online.
Unai Emery showed little sympathy for Ollie Watkins after the striker was unavailable for Villa’s opening-day trip to Brighton
Al Hilal, who have former Wolves captain Ruben Neves (furthest right) and ex-Chelsea centre-back Kalidou Koulibaly (second right) in their squad, must meet Villa’s £50m valuation
To understand the background, it is necessary to go back to a pivotal moment for both Villa and Watkins: Boxing Day 2024. Emery had selected the unpredictable but gifted Jhon Duran ahead of Watkins in the previous three league matches, and the Colombian had scored in each of them.
By the time Villa travelled to Newcastle, Duran appeared to have become Emery’s first-choice striker. The club also knew Arsenal were searching for a forward and had shown interest in Watkins, a lifelong Gunners supporter.
Duran was then shown a straight red card at Newcastle. After serving his suspension, he did not regain his place because Emery felt neither his form nor his attitude justified a return. When Al Nassr offered £70m for Duran, Villa chose to move on from a player who had become increasingly difficult to manage.
Villa were not prepared to sell both strikers in the same transfer window, leaving Watkins unable to secure his dream move to Arsenal. The Gunners’ offers never reached Villa’s £65m valuation. Watkins was disappointed, but Emery said: ‘Now we need him, like he needed Aston Villa.’
Emery has already seen Youri Tielemans, Morgan Rogers, Lucas Digne and Ezri Konsa leave this summer and wanted several experienced players to remain as he began building a new era.
The Spaniard will generally avoid blocking a player who wants to leave, but Watkins’ situation appeared to carry a more personal dimension.
YOU MAY ALSO READ: What Happened To Stella Magz? Tragedy Explained In Tiktok – NewsFinale
Two very different viewpoints
Watkins is the leading client of Two Touch, the agency founded by former Arsenal player Paolo Vernazza. His proposed move to Al Hilal would probably rank among the agency’s biggest deals, and Villa are unhappy with the way Vernazza has managed the situation. The agent may also reflect on whether he would handle certain aspects differently. Daily Mail Sport has attempted to contact the 46-year-old since Sunday, but he has not responded.
Jhon Duran appeared destined to become Villa’s leading striker 18 months ago before his sending-off at Newcastle
Aston Villa have already lost players including Youri Tielemans (left) and Morgan Rogers (right) this summer, with Watkins (centre) potentially next
Watkins is believed to earn slightly more than £100,000 a week at Villa, while Al Hilal’s proposed salary is understood to be considerably higher. He has also watched 28-year-old Konsa move to Arsenal for roughly the same fee Villa are seeking from Al Hilal. Watkins turns 31 in December, and if he felt Villa’s valuation was excessive for a player of his age, his view would be understandable. Villa, naturally, see the situation differently.
Under Emery, Watkins has developed into one of Europe’s finest strikers. The manager has consistently supported him, and Watkins repaid that faith by scoring 12 goals in 13 matches at the end of last season to earn his place in England’s World Cup squad.
With two forwards unavailable, Emery badly needed Watkins at Brighton. It was therefore no surprise that he appeared tense during the pre-match media duties. ‘Silence!’ Emery snapped when Sky Sports’ Johnny Phillips asked about Watkins’ absence. With Emery, saying less often signals that he is feeling more, not less, anger.
He looked close to the edge at the Amex, arguing with the fourth official more frequently than usual, becoming frustrated with the opposition bench and heading straight down the tunnel at full-time without shaking hands with Albion manager Fabian Hurzeler. Emery and Hurzeler are not close, but the reaction was still revealing.
What comes next?
A year ago, it seemed Emi Martinez had played his last match for Villa. Keen to join Manchester United or Atletico Madrid, the goalkeeper was left out of the team for a home defeat against Crystal Palace.
Emery appeared close to breaking point at the Amex, where he repeatedly challenged the fourth official and became increasingly frustrated with the opposition bench
Watkins scored 12 goals in the final 13 matches of last season to earn selection for England’s World Cup squad, scoring in the warm-up against Costa Rica
Martinez is still trying to secure a move away, although he knuckled down last season and helped the club win the Europa League. Watkins’ position, however, has appeared far more difficult to resolve since Sunday.
Whatever happens next, Watkins faces a major challenge in rebuilding his relationship with Villa supporters. There were already indications last season that his performances were declining, meaning a new contract may not have been the ideal outcome for either side.
Should Nicolas Jackson arrive, Villa would gain a striker with potential and an eye for goal. Emery knows him well from their time together at Villarreal. Villa have also made an enquiry about 20-year-old Bayer Leverkusen striker Christian Kofane, although the German club do not currently want to sell.
Whatever their preferred solution, Villa must settle Watkins’ future before Arsenal visit Villa Park on Monday.