95-year-old allegedly beat Holocaust survivor roommate to death at New York nursing home
Share and Follow

NEW YORK — The violent death at a New York nursing home of an 89-year-old holocaust survivor and great-grandmother, allegedly at the hands of her 95-year-old roommate, has left her family broken.

Police said they found 89-year-old Nina Kravtsov, who was born in Ukraine and was a Holocaust survivor, with head injuries in her room.

“The way she died is like in a Stephen King horror movie. This doesn’t happen in real life,” said the attorney for the victim’s family, Randy Zelin.

Kravtsov was rushed to the hospital, where she later died of blunt force trauma, the medical examiner said.

The alleged murder weapon was a leg rest from 95-year-old Galina Smirnova’s wheelchair that was found discarded outside of the building.

“She was asleep sometime around 9:00. And by 10:00, she was beaten to a pulp,” Zelin said.

According to prosecutors, she was discovered by a staff member at Seagate Nursing Home, washing blood off herself and around the room she had shared with Kravtsov for only two days.

Kravtsov’s family’s attorney, Randy Zelin, says dementia plays a legal role in this case in two ways.

First, in a likely civil suit against Seagate, which had been Kravtsov’s home for several years, arguing that it shouldn’t have paired a patient with dementia with a roommate in a brand new environment without some supervision.

And second, if the defense makes the case that Smirnova didn’t know what she was doing.

“Dementia can bring on unprovoked out of nowhere a fit of complete rage. So defensively, that’s the defense. Now it’ll be interesting to see how that plays in against the backdrop of apparently discarding the piece of the wheelchair, washing her hands in the bathroom. Now suddenly we begin to see maybe I do know what I was doing,” Zelin said.

She was arraigned on Wednesday morning in Brooklyn criminal court and is being held without bail.

Attorney Randy Zelin says a team at his office will be seeking justice for the family, looking to hold Seagate responsible, whether it could have prevented the tragedy with different protocols or staffing.

Our sister station WABC has reached out for comment from the nursing home.

Copyright © 2025 WPVI-TV. All Rights Reserved.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
Key accuser in Alexander brothers rape case dies just one week before federal trial begins: report

Lead Witness in Alexander Brothers’ Federal Trial Passes Away Days Before Court Date: Report

The woman who initially accused Oren and Alon Alexander of rape, a…
Kamala Harris, Chicago news: Ex-VP, Mayor Brandon Johnson join MLK interfaith breakfast honoring Dr. Martin Luther King Jr.

Kamala Harris and Chicago’s Mayor Brandon Johnson Unite at MLK Interfaith Breakfast to Honor Dr. Martin Luther King Jr.

CHICAGO (WLS) — Chicago commemorated the legacy of Dr. Martin Luther King…
Arlington Heights officials to make push to keep Chicago Bears in Illinois as teams looks to build stadium

Arlington Heights Rallies to Retain Chicago Bears as Plans for New Stadium Emerge

The Chicago Bears are preparing for their upcoming showdown with the Rams…
Three illegal migrants charged with attempted murder of ICE agents

Three Undocumented Immigrants Face Charges for Alleged Attempted Murder of ICE Agents

In a recent incident in Minneapolis, three individuals without legal immigration status…
Father credits 7-year-old daughter with saving his life after fall in Lynwood home; police, fire chiefs congratulate her

Heroic 7-Year-Old Daughter Saves Father’s Life After Lynwood Home Accident; Commended by Police and Fire Chiefs

A 7-year-old girl from Lynwood, Illinois, is earning praise for her heroic…
How Kyle Tucker's $240 million contract is stoking lockout fears

Kyle Tucker’s $240 Million Deal Sparks Discussions on Potential Lockout Concerns

The recent buzz isn’t just about the “cha-ching” echoing from Kyle Tucker’s…
'Paradise' star and author Sarah Shahi reveals what helped her build her dream life and some 'Paradise' secrets

Actress and Author Sarah Shahi Shares Key Insights on Building Her Dream Life and Unveils Behind-the-Scenes Details from ‘Paradise

Sarah Shahi, widely recognized for her captivating performances on screen, is now…
Illegal alien with 24 convictions among ‘worst of the worst’ arrested in Minnesota ICE operation: DHS

High-Risk Illegal Immigrant with 24 Convictions Captured in Minnesota ICE Sweep: DHS Labels as ‘Worst of the Worst

EXCLUSIVE TO FOX: In a significant development, the Department of Homeland Security…