Amish woman accused in son's death pleads not guilty by reason of insanity
Share and Follow

NEW PHILADELPHIA, Ohio (WJW) — An Amish woman indicted on murder charges following the deaths of her 4-year-old son and 45-year-old husband pleaded not guilty by reason of insanity Monday.

Last week, a grand jury indicted Ruth Miller, 40, of Millersburg, Ohio, on seven counts, including aggravated murder, endangering children and domestic violence.

Ruth Miller. Photo courtesy Tuscarawas County Sheriff’s Office

Miller sat quietly during an arraignment in New Philadelphia on Monday, as her attorney confirmed for the court that they are pleading not guilty by reason of insanity to the charges.

“Based upon the facts … this case would not have happened but for a mental defect that would have prevented Miss Miller from appreciating the wrongfulness of her conduct,” said defense attorney Ian Friedman.

According to investigators, Miller is believed to have been experiencing a “spiritual delusion” when she allegedly threw her 4-year-old son, Vincen Miller, into Atwood Lake on Aug. 23.

Miller’s 45-year-old husband, Marcus Miller, is also believed to have drowned after swimming into the lake on his own accord, reportedly as part a religious test, according to investigators.

The bodies of Marcus and Vincen Miller were recovered from the bottom of the lake by dive teams.

Body camera video obtained by affiliate WJW shows Miller speaking with a ranger at the scene. When she was asked where her son was, she said, “I gave him to God.”

Credit: Tuscarawas County Sheriff’s Department

Miller also crashed a golf cart into the lake with her 15-year-old daughter and twin 18-year-old sons on board.

“There clearly was a serious mental disease that she faced. It was evident to the first responding officers, the first responders and unfortunately it was a tragedy that happened that day,” Friedman said. “People generally think that if someone is found not guilty by reason of insanity, they’re just released to the street. They are released to the custody of a lockdown hospital.”

The indictment, handed up Thursday, brings seven total counts: individual felony counts of aggravated murder, murder and felonious assault in the death of her 4-year-old son Vincen Miller; and three misdemeanor counts of domestic violence and one misdemeanor count of endangering children related to the crash involving her older children.

She faces a minimum sentence of 20 years to life in prison if convicted on the aggravated murder charge.

On Monday, Judge Michael Ernest ruled that Miller will be held in the county jail until a bond hearing can be held later this month. He also ruled that at this point, she can have no contact with her three surviving children.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
Parent responsible for lockouts at four Duval schools arrested in Texas, police say

Texas Authorities Arrest Parent Linked to Lockdowns at Four Duval Schools, Police Report

Authorities have charged 39-year-old Matthew Piner with threatening to use violence against…
Mica Miller's husband is indicted for shock acts before wife's death

Tragic Turn: Mica Miller’s Husband Indicted for Disturbing Actions Preceding Her Death

Mica Miller’s husband is now facing a lengthy prison sentence after allegedly…
New Epstein files reveal photos of women with vile messages on them

Shocking Epstein Documents Uncover Disturbing Photos with Offensive Messages

A fresh set of documents released by the House Committee on Oversight…
Florida executes man convicted of killing airman and girlfriend in 1987 home invasion

Florida Carries Out Execution for 1987 Home Invasion Murders: Justice Served for Airman and Girlfriend

In Florida, the state carried out the execution of a man on…
Sports reporter’s 3-year-old opened door for grandpa who then found couple dead in home: report

Tragic Discovery: Reporter’s Toddler Uncovers Chilling Scene in Family Home

In a heartbreaking turn of events in Alabama, a 3-year-old child unwittingly…
Detransitioner Chloe Cole shares complications after gender procedures

Former Transgender Teen Chloe Cole Discusses Challenges Post-Gender Surgery

Chloe Cole, a young woman who has experienced the contentious world of…
Exclusive | Oct. 7 survivor Omer Shem Tov to warn TPUSA conference 'evil is spreading' after 505 days in captivity

Exclusive: Oct. 7 Survivor Omer Shem Tov to Address TPUSA Conference, Warning of the Global Spread of Evil After 505 Days in Captivity

WASHINGTON — A former hostage, who endured over 16 months of captivity…
Split image of a man pointing a finger to his face (left) and a selfie of another man on the right.

Brooklyn Stabbing Survivor Elias Rosner Advocates Against Bullying After Attack

A Jewish man stabbed in the chest in New York City recently…