Amish woman accused in son's death pleads not guilty by reason of insanity
Share and Follow

NEW PHILADELPHIA, Ohio (WJW) — An Amish woman indicted on murder charges following the deaths of her 4-year-old son and 45-year-old husband pleaded not guilty by reason of insanity Monday.

Last week, a grand jury indicted Ruth Miller, 40, of Millersburg, Ohio, on seven counts, including aggravated murder, endangering children and domestic violence.

Ruth Miller. Photo courtesy Tuscarawas County Sheriff’s Office

Miller sat quietly during an arraignment in New Philadelphia on Monday, as her attorney confirmed for the court that they are pleading not guilty by reason of insanity to the charges.

“Based upon the facts … this case would not have happened but for a mental defect that would have prevented Miss Miller from appreciating the wrongfulness of her conduct,” said defense attorney Ian Friedman.

According to investigators, Miller is believed to have been experiencing a “spiritual delusion” when she allegedly threw her 4-year-old son, Vincen Miller, into Atwood Lake on Aug. 23.

Miller’s 45-year-old husband, Marcus Miller, is also believed to have drowned after swimming into the lake on his own accord, reportedly as part a religious test, according to investigators.

The bodies of Marcus and Vincen Miller were recovered from the bottom of the lake by dive teams.

Body camera video obtained by affiliate WJW shows Miller speaking with a ranger at the scene. When she was asked where her son was, she said, “I gave him to God.”

Credit: Tuscarawas County Sheriff’s Department

Miller also crashed a golf cart into the lake with her 15-year-old daughter and twin 18-year-old sons on board.

“There clearly was a serious mental disease that she faced. It was evident to the first responding officers, the first responders and unfortunately it was a tragedy that happened that day,” Friedman said. “People generally think that if someone is found not guilty by reason of insanity, they’re just released to the street. They are released to the custody of a lockdown hospital.”

The indictment, handed up Thursday, brings seven total counts: individual felony counts of aggravated murder, murder and felonious assault in the death of her 4-year-old son Vincen Miller; and three misdemeanor counts of domestic violence and one misdemeanor count of endangering children related to the crash involving her older children.

She faces a minimum sentence of 20 years to life in prison if convicted on the aggravated murder charge.

On Monday, Judge Michael Ernest ruled that Miller will be held in the county jail until a bond hearing can be held later this month. He also ruled that at this point, she can have no contact with her three surviving children.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
Nickelodeon composer Guy Moon, 63, killed in horror car crash in LA

Beloved Nickelodeon Composer Guy Moon Tragically Dies in Los Angeles Car Accident at 63

Renowned Nickelodeon composer Guy Moon has sadly died at 63, leaving his…
Journalist’s dangerous obsession with a forgotten serial killer unraveled her reality

Journalist’s Deep Dive into Obscure Serial Killer Unveils Unsettling Truths

Laura Greenberg, a journalist driven by an unyielding quest to comprehend the…
DC pipe bomb suspect makes first court appearance; family yells support

DC Pipe Bomb Suspect Enters Not Guilty Plea for Planting Devices at DNC and RNC Headquarters

The individual accused of placing pipe bombs outside the headquarters of both…
FDA upgrades nationwide cheese recall to highest danger level after listeria-causing bacteria found

FDA Escalates Cheese Recall to High Alert Due to Listeria Contamination Risk

The reclassification comes after identifying Listeria monocytogenes, a harmful bacterium known for…
Driver appears to ram U-Haul truck through crowd during Iran protest in Los Angeles

U-Haul Truck Allegedly Driven into Crowd at Los Angeles Iran Protest

A tense scene unfolded in Los Angeles as a U-Haul truck reportedly…
More than a dozen train cars derailed near Texas/Louisiana border

Major Train Derailment Near Texas-Louisiana Border: Over a Dozen Cars Off Track

Authorities are still investigating the cause behind a train derailment in Texas…
Expert warns of 'extreme violence' in Venezuelan mining as Trump admin eyes mineral reserves

Venezuelan Mining Crisis Escalates: Expert Predicts Extreme Violence Amid U.S. Interest in Mineral Reserves

The Trump administration’s renewed focus on Venezuela’s mineral wealth could pose significant…
Huge $25MILLION reward offered for capture of Maduro's right-hand man

$25 Million Bounty Announced for the Arrest of Key Maduro Associate

The Trump administration has announced a $25 million bounty for information that…