Appeals court halts Chutkan's order for DOGE records
Share and Follow


A federal appeals court on Wednesday temporarily blocked an order from U.S. District Judge Tanya Chutkan directing Elon Musk and the Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) to turn over records and answer questions about its efforts to slash the federal bureaucracy.

A three-judge panel on the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit granted a stay of Chutkan’s directive, suggesting that the lower court judge must rule on the Trump administration’s motion to dismiss before allowing any discovery. It’s not a final ruling on whether DOGE must eventually turn over the records.

Soon after the panel’s decision, Chutkan canceled a status hearing scheduled for Thursday.

Chutkan’s order granting discovery marked the first time a judge ordered Musk to produce documents in a legal challenge to his and DOGE’s efforts to downsize the federal government and cut costs.

She said her order was meant to allow identification of DOGE personnel and “the parameters of DOGE’s and Musk’s authority.”

The request for information about DOGE came in a lawsuit by a coalition of states, led by New Mexico, which claims Musk’s vast role heading DOGE is unconstitutional since he wasn’t confirmed by the Senate. They’re seeking to block DOGE from accessing seven federal agencies.

Though the billionaire tech mogul is said to be leading DOGE’s sweeping cost-cutting efforts, the White House has maintained that Musk is not technically a part of DOGE, instead serving as a senior adviser to the president.

Chutkan, an appointee of former President Biden who also oversaw the federal election subversion criminal case against President Trump, previously declined to grant the request from the 14 Democratic state attorneys general for a temporary restraining order after finding they had not made the necessary showing of irreparable harm.

However, in a footnote, the judge suggested that the Justice Department may have stretched the truth in court filings regarding the breadth of DOGE’s power over personnel issues. She reminded the government of its duty to “make truthful representations to the court.”

DOGE has drawn dozens of legal challenges over its rapid efforts to install employees at federal agencies with an aim of cutting trillions of dollars in government spending.

The Democratic-led states are seeking to block Musk and DOGE agents from accessing confidential data at the Office of Personnel Management, the Department of Education, the Department of Labor, the Department of Health and Human Services, the Department of Energy, the Department of Transportation and the Department of Commerce. 

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
Prince William and Kate join King Charles and Camilla at Sandringham

Royal Family Reunion at Sandringham: Prince William, Kate, King Charles & Camilla Gather in Style

The Princess of Wales charmed onlookers with her warm smile this past…
Trump-backed candidate Asfura wins Honduras presidential election

Historic Victory: Trump-Endorsed Asfura Triumphs in Honduras Presidential Election

In a significant political shift for Central America, Nasry Asfura has clinched…
Portnoy unleashes on Ross for coaxing NFL star into antisemitic dance

Portnoy Criticizes Ross for Encouraging NFL Star’s Controversial Antisemitic Dance

Dave Portnoy recently criticized online influencer Adin Ross following an intense exchange…
Pope Leo XIV mentions Gaza in his first Christmas homily

Pope Leo XIV’s Historic Christmas Homily: A Powerful Message on Gaza

Pope Leo XIV delivered a poignant message in his first Christmas homily,…
Doctors blamed my baby's issues on weight... he had a brain disease

Doctors Initially Attributed My Baby’s Symptoms to Weight, Later Diagnosed Brain Disease

A mother from Kentucky alleges that medical professionals brushed off her infant’s…
Christmas returns to Holy Land cities as Bethlehem’s Christian population dwindles, Nazareth remains strong

Bethlehem’s Christian Population Declines as Nazareth Remains Resilient Amid Christmas Celebrations in the Holy Land

This year’s Christmas festivities have returned to the historic cities of Bethlehem…
'If you need us, call us': Fire officials urge chimney inspections to prevent holiday fires

Prevent Holiday Fires: Fire Officials Stress the Importance of Chimney Inspections

With the holiday season upon us and chimneys across the nation coming…
Ten housing markets are crashing like the Great Recession

Top 10 Housing Markets Plummeting: Are We Facing Another Great Recession?

The U.S. housing market is experiencing a subtle but notable downturn. After…