California homeowners allege home insurance companies colluded to deny coverage
Share and Follow


LOS ANGELES — A group of California homeowners is taking on insurance companies that they say illegally coordinated to deny coverage to fire-prone areas, leaving thousands of displaced residents drastically underinsured as they fight for funding to rebuild.

The homeowners, many of whom were affected by the recent wildfires that torched large swaths of Los Angeles, have filed a lawsuit alleging that California insurance companies colluded in a “nefarious conspiracy” to shut out high-risk homeowners from the insurance market.

The complaint, filed Friday in Los Angeles County, accuses dozens of major insurance companies and their subsidiaries of collaborating in a “group boycott” of certain areas to eliminate competition and force homeowners toward the state’s insurer of last resort, a program known as the California FAIR Plan.

The lawsuits name California’s largest home insurers, including State Farm, Farmers, Berkshire Hathaway, Allstate and Liberty Mutual. None of them have provided a comment on the allegations.

The FAIR Plan has its own reserves and is intended to provide basic insurance to residents who cannot find a policy through the private marketplace. While it was created by the governor and the Legislature, and the state’s insurance commissioner has oversight, it is not a public program. The insurance companies named in the lawsuit jointly own and operate the FAIR plan, offering terms that limit their risk and place a higher burden on policyholders.

“They knew that they could force people, by dropping insurance, into that plan which had higher premiums and far lower coverages,” Robert Ruyak, an attorney with Larson LLP, the law firm that brought the complaint, said. “They realized that they could take this device, which is to protect consumers, and turn it into something that protected them.”

Ruyak argues the insurance companies knew they could limit their liability by directing policyholders onto the FAIR Plan, which allows companies to recoup up to half of their losses through premium increases, by agreeing that no company would insure high-risk areas.

“All of these insurance companies participate in the California FAIR Plan. They own it and manage it. It is not a California entity, it is not even a separate entity … the only way this scheme would work is if no one would pick up a dropped policy at any price, on any terms. And that’s what happened.”

Millions of U.S. homeowners have in recent years struggled to buy property insurance as companies have increasingly declined to offer coverage to people who live in high-risk areas, particularly as climate change has supercharged some natural disasters. An NBC News analysis in 2023 found that a quarter of all U.S. homes may be at risk of a climate-induced insurance shock.

California has been among the hardest hit by what some have called an “insurance crisis.” The state’s FAIR Plan, meanwhile, has been the subject of growing scrutiny and frustration from insurance regulators and customers.

The plaintiffs are asking for a jury trial and seeking payment for three times their damages. 

A separate class-action lawsuit filed Friday makes similar allegations.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
Cause of death revealed weeks after woman died following Universal Orlando ride: report

Shocking Discovery: Cause of Woman’s Tragic Death After Universal Orlando Ride Finally Unveiled

The identity and cause of death of a 70-year-old woman have been…
19-year-old charged with attempted murder of coworker at Oceanway McDonald's

Teenager Accused of Attempted Murder in Oceanway McDonald’s Incident

A 19-year-old named Malik McKinnon has been charged with shooting a coworker…
Meghan Trainor welcomes third baby with Daryl Sabara

Meghan Trainor and Daryl Sabara Joyfully Celebrate Arrival of Their Third Bundle of Joy

The pop sensation expressed heartfelt gratitude to her “incredible superwoman surrogate” as…
‘I don’t see this as getting better’: Data centers fuel concern over water, energy use, air pollution

Data Centers’ Environmental Impact: Unveiling the Water and Energy Crisis

Nestled between expansive agricultural fields and the stunning Great Lakes, Port…
Carlos Beltran Hall of Fame worthy despite sign-stealing scandal

Carlos Beltran’s Hall of Fame Debate: Can His Legacy Overcome the Sign-Stealing Scandal?

Carlos Beltrán’s reputation took a hit due to his role in the…
Trump rules out taking Greenland by force sparking stock market rally

Trump’s Greenland Decision Spurs Stock Market Surge: A Peaceful Resolution

President Donald Trump has officially renounced any intentions to seize Greenland through…
Arrest made in connection to stabbing at Brunswick home, police say

Police Arrest Suspect Linked to Brunswick Home Stabbing Incident

Grace Freeman, aged 33, is currently facing multiple charges, including aggravated assault,…
How Mossimo Giannulli feels about 'extremely angry' Lori Loughlin as they navigate divorce

Mossimo Giannulli’s Perspective on ‘Extremely Angry’ Lori Loughlin Amid Divorce Proceedings

Mossimo Giannulli will always hold love for Lori Loughlin. As reported by…