Can $1,000 at birth change a child's future? A Republican proposal aims to find out
Share and Follow


WASHINGTON (AP) — When children of wealthy families reach adulthood, they often benefit from the largesse of parents in the form of a trust fund. It’s another way they get a leg up on less affluent peers, who may receive nothing at all — or even be expected to support their families.

But what if all children — regardless of their family’s circumstances — could get a financial boost when they turn 18?

That’s the idea behind a House GOP proposal backed by President Donald Trump. It would create accounts for all babies born in the U.S. over the next four years with $1,000 that would accrue interest until the children reach adulthood. At age 18, they could withdraw the money to put toward a down payment for a home, education or to start a small business. If the money is used for other purposes, it’ll be taxed at a higher rate.

It builds on the concept of “ baby bonds,” which two states — California and Connecticut — and the District of Columbia have introduced as a way to reduce gaps between wealthy people and poor people.

Rep. Blake Moore, a Republican from Utah, spearheaded the effort to get the initiative into a massive House spending bill. In an op-ed for the Washington Examiner, he said wealth inequality has soured many people on capitalism. “Trump Accounts,” as the proposal calls them, could be the antidote, he said.

“We know that America’s economic engine is working, but not everyone feels connected to its value and the ways it can benefit them,” Moore wrote. “If we can demonstrate to our next generation the benefits of investing and financial health, we can put them on a path toward prosperity.”

The bill calls for the money to be handled by investment firms.

The bill would require at least one parent to produce a Social Security number with work authorizations, meaning the U.S. citizen children born to some categories of immigrants would be excluded from the benefit. But unlike other baby bond programs, which generally target disadvantaged groups, this one would be available to families of all incomes.

“When little baby is born they’re gonna start off with a thousand dollars and if we do a good job of investing their money — we’re going to go with one of the investing guidelines, who the hell knows if they’re any good — but they have a chance to be very rich,” Trump said at a rally last week in Pittsburgh. “It’s going to be very cute to see.”

Economist Darrick Hamilton of The New School, who first pitched the idea of baby bonds a quarter-century ago, said the GOP proposal would exacerbate rather than reduce wealth gaps. He envisioned a program that would be universal but would give children from poor families a larger endowment than their wealthier peers, in an attempt to level the playing field. The money would be handled by the government, not by private firms on Wall Street.

“It is upside down,” Hamilton said. “It’s going to enhance inequality.”

Hamilton added that $1,000 — even with interest — would not be enough to make a significant difference for a child living in poverty.

A Silicon Valley investor who created the blueprint for the proposal, Brad Gerstner, said in an interview with CNBC last year that the accounts could help address the wealth gap and the loss of faith in capitalism that represent an existential crisis for the U.S.

“The rise and fall of nations occurs when you have a wealth gap that grows, when you have people who lose faith in the system,” Gerstner said. “We’re not agentless. We can do something.”

The proposal comes as Congressional Republicans and Trump face backlash for proposed cuts to programs that poor families with children rely on, including food assistance and Medicaid.

Even some who back the idea of baby bonds are skeptical, noting Trump wants to cut higher education grants and programs that aid young people on the cusp of adulthood — the same age group Trump Accounts are supposed to help. Pending federal legislation would slash Medicaid and food and housing assistance that many families with children rely on.

Young adults who grew up in poverty often struggle with covering basics like rent and transportation — expenses that Trump Accounts could not be tapped to cover, said Eve Valdez, an advocate for youth in foster care in southern California.

Accounts for newborn children that cannot be accessed for 18 years mean little to families struggling to meet basic needs today, said Shimica Gaskins of End Child Poverty California.

“Having children have health care, having their families have access to SNAP and food are what we really need … the country focused on,” Gaskins said.

___

The Associated Press’ education coverage receives financial support from multiple private foundations. AP is solely responsible for all content. Find AP’s standards for working with philanthropies, a list of supporters and funded coverage areas at AP.org.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
Research reveals health impacts of fluoride… as RFK Jr calls for ban

Study Unveils Fluoride’s Health Effects Amid RFK Jr.’s Call for Prohibition

A comprehensive new study has confirmed that the addition of fluoride to…
Two Clay County deputies injured in on-duty dog attack: CCSO

Clay County Deputies Sustained Injuries in On-Duty Canine Incident: CCSO Reports

In Clay County, a routine call for service on Foxtail Avenue took…
Spain is hit with a THIRD train crash leaving several injured

Third Train Collision in Spain Results in Multiple Injuries

Spain has experienced its third train incident in a short span, as…
Video captures Detroit student allegedly wielding box cutter in classroom chase as teacher intervenes

Detroit Classroom Chaos: Student Armed with Box Cutter Chased Down by Heroic Teacher

A startling video captures the moment a female student pursued a classmate…
Trump cancels Canada's invite to Board of Peace as Europeans boycott

Trump Revokes Canada’s Board of Peace Invitation Amid European Boycott

In a recent development at the World Economic Forum, former U.S. President…
'Remote Invite Scam': Hackers using calendar app to access computers, steal money, information, security experts, local woman warn

Cybersecurity Alert: Hackers Exploit Calendar Apps to Breach Systems and Steal Sensitive Information, Warn Experts and Victim

CHICAGO (WLS) — Security experts are sounding the alarm about a rapidly…
RHONY alum Bethenny Frankel reveals chronic kidney disease diagnosis

Bethenny Frankel Opens Up About Chronic Kidney Disease Diagnosis: A Candid Look Into Her Health Journey

Bethenny Frankel has revealed that she is facing stage two chronic kidney…
Trump orders a massive armada toward Iran with ominous warning

Trump Dispatches Powerful Naval Armada Towards Iran Amid Rising Tensions

Donald Trump has issued a warning to Iran, asserting that the United…