Charlie Kirk's accused assassin stares down death penalty case with limited defense options
Share and Follow


NEWYou can now listen to Fox News articles!

OREM, Utah – The murder case against the man accused of killing conservative speaker Charlie Kirk is already facing major legal hurdles — from questions about defense funding to whether the crime even qualifies for the death penalty under Utah law.

Tyler Robinson, 22, is being held without bail at the Utah County Jail. Prosecutors say he climbed onto a rooftop at Utah Valley University, shot Kirk from about 200 yards away and fled before surrendering near his home in Washington, Utah.

Defending Robinson is proving to be no simple task. Utah requires attorneys in death penalty cases to have prior trial and capital case experience, and at least two must be appointed. That level of commitment can consume a year or more of full-time work, experts told Fox News Digital, forcing lawyers to set aside other clients and personal obligations.

“It’s a huge undertaking to represent someone in a case like this,” Utah criminal defense lawyer Randall Spencer, who has handled multiple capital cases, told Fox News Digital. “It really is a sacrifice for defense attorneys who take on this kind of work.”

Even if the death penalty is pursued, Spencer said the process could take years, with long appeals and significant emotional strain for everyone involved.

Robinson is set to appear in Utah County court on Sept. 29 for a hearing where he must decide whether to challenge the evidence at a preliminary hearing or proceed directly to arraignment. If the case advances, Rice said the court will determine probable cause before Robinson enters a plea.

Even if prosecutors pursue the death penalty, experts said appeals and delays could stretch the case out for years. More likely, they noted, Robinson could eventually agree to a plea deal to avoid trial.

“The system will play out in a fair way,” Spencer said.

Utah Gov. Spencer Cox has said that the state plans to seek the death penalty if the case moves forward to trial. President Donald Trump also weighed in, saying he hopes Robinson receives the death penalty if convicted.

Stepheny Price covers crime, including missing persons, homicides and migrant crime. Send story tips to stepheny.price@fox.com.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
Hegseth tells China's defense chief US will 'stoutly defend its interests'

US Asserts Firm Stance on Defense Interests in Talks with China’s Defense Chief

On Friday, Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth delivered a firm message to China’s…
ICE officer shoots illegal immigrant during Phoenix traffic stop gone wrong, both hospitalized

Phoenix Traffic Stop Turns Chaotic: ICE Officer and Immigrant Hospitalized After Shooting Incident

An officer from Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) and a Honduran man…
Pritzker urges calm ahead of ICE raids over Halloween weekend

Governor Pritzker Calls for Community Calm Amid Planned ICE Raids During Halloween Weekend

In Broadview, Illinois, Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem has declared that immigration…
Jury begins deliberations in Julio Foolio's murder trial after Alicia Andrews' defense in court

Jury Deliberations Commence in High-Profile Julio Foolio Murder Trial Following Alicia Andrews’ Compelling Defense

Deliberations are underway as jurors consider the case against Alicia Andrews, one…
An Oct. 30, 2025, booking photo of Cody Skaggs from the Kent County jail.

Former Convict in 1996 Murder Case Arrested After High-Speed Chase and Break-In at Retirement Home

PLAINFIELD TOWNSHIP, Mich. (WOOD) – A man who led police on a…
First Coast surfing legend, Biddy Hunter, dies at age 77

Celebrated First Coast Surfing Icon Biddy Hunter Passes Away at 77

Dennis “Biddy” Hunter, a prominent figure in the surfing community, brought international…
Peaceful protests in Chicago amid scrutiny of Border Patrol chief

Cartels Allegedly Offering $10,000 Bounty for Attacks on Border Patrol Agents, Memo Reveals

Federal authorities have issued a stark warning about a dangerous new strategy…
Videos show Sudanese commander Abu Lulu executing captives

Footage Emerges Allegedly Showing Sudanese Commander Abu Lulu Executing Prisoners

Sudan’s ongoing civil conflict reached new levels of brutality as a notorious…