Charlie Kirk's accused assassin stares down death penalty case with limited defense options
Share and Follow


NEWYou can now listen to Fox News articles!

OREM, Utah – The murder case against the man accused of killing conservative speaker Charlie Kirk is already facing major legal hurdles — from questions about defense funding to whether the crime even qualifies for the death penalty under Utah law.

Tyler Robinson, 22, is being held without bail at the Utah County Jail. Prosecutors say he climbed onto a rooftop at Utah Valley University, shot Kirk from about 200 yards away and fled before surrendering near his home in Washington, Utah.

Defending Robinson is proving to be no simple task. Utah requires attorneys in death penalty cases to have prior trial and capital case experience, and at least two must be appointed. That level of commitment can consume a year or more of full-time work, experts told Fox News Digital, forcing lawyers to set aside other clients and personal obligations.

“It’s a huge undertaking to represent someone in a case like this,” Utah criminal defense lawyer Randall Spencer, who has handled multiple capital cases, told Fox News Digital. “It really is a sacrifice for defense attorneys who take on this kind of work.”

Even if the death penalty is pursued, Spencer said the process could take years, with long appeals and significant emotional strain for everyone involved.

Robinson is set to appear in Utah County court on Sept. 29 for a hearing where he must decide whether to challenge the evidence at a preliminary hearing or proceed directly to arraignment. If the case advances, Rice said the court will determine probable cause before Robinson enters a plea.

Even if prosecutors pursue the death penalty, experts said appeals and delays could stretch the case out for years. More likely, they noted, Robinson could eventually agree to a plea deal to avoid trial.

“The system will play out in a fair way,” Spencer said.

Utah Gov. Spencer Cox has said that the state plans to seek the death penalty if the case moves forward to trial. President Donald Trump also weighed in, saying he hopes Robinson receives the death penalty if convicted.

Stepheny Price covers crime, including missing persons, homicides and migrant crime. Send story tips to stepheny.price@fox.com.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
Trump vows no 'Bad Santas' in America, piles praise on Christmas Eve

Trump Pledges to Keep ‘Bad Santas’ Out of America, Celebrates Christmas Eve Spirit

First Lady Melania Trump and President Donald Trump continued a cherished tradition…
Christmas returns to Holy Land cities as Bethlehem’s Christian population dwindles, Nazareth remains strong

Bethlehem’s Christian Population Declines as Nazareth Remains Resilient Amid Christmas Celebrations in the Holy Land

This year’s Christmas festivities have returned to the historic cities of Bethlehem…
Zelensky says Ukrainians just want Putin dead as his country and Russia trade record deadly overnight drone strikes

Zelensky Reveals Ukrainians’ Ultimate Wish Amid Escalating Drone Warfare with Russia

In a dramatic escalation overnight into Christmas, Russia and Ukraine exchanged a…
Make-A-Wish brings back annual Holiday Wish Line messages

Spread Joy: Make-A-Wish Revives Beloved Holiday Wish Line for Heartfelt Messages

The CEO of Make-A-Wish describes their hotline as a “powerful antidote” to…
Chicago Christmas 2025: Hundreds of Christmas Day meals delivered to West Englewood shelter by St. Sabina Church volunteers

St. Sabina Church Volunteers Spread Holiday Cheer with Meal Deliveries to West Englewood Shelter on Christmas 2025

In a heartwarming gesture just in time for Christmas, hundreds of meals…
Robocalls are surging to six-year high, according to new report

Robocall Volume Hits Six-Year Peak, New Report Reveals

ST. PETERSBURG, Fla. — For most cell phone users, robocalls are a…
Tense bodycam footage shows cop shove state trooper driving local rep

Dramatic Bodycam Video Captures Tension as Officer Confronts Trooper Escorting Local Representative

A tense exchange unfolded in Tennessee when a local police officer confronted…
Florida man kills wife, shoots stepdaughter over NFL game argument before taking own life

Tragic NFL Dispute: Florida Man’s Deadly Rampage Leaves Family Devastated

A tragic incident unfolded in Florida this week when a man fatally…