Florida serial killer fears spread after three women found dead in three days
Share and Follow

Authorities in Florida are addressing social media buzz concerning a supposed “serial killer on the loose” in Jacksonville, following the discovery of three deceased women in separate events over a span of three days.

The Jacksonville Sheriff’s Office (JSO) took to social media on Tuesday to directly counter these speculations, stressing that the incidents are not interconnected and reassuring the public as investigations proceed.

“Rumors of a serial killer in Jacksonville are circulating, but we can categorically state these claims are FALSE,” the agency announced on social media on Tuesday.

The statement further explained that detectives are examining each incident independently, “pursuing the facts and evidence,” and assured, “there is no threat to the public concerning these cases.”

Jacksonville Sheriff's Office car

A Jacksonville sheriff’s officer maintains vigilance while FBI and IRS agents carry out a search. (Bob Self/Florida Times-Union/USA Today Network via Imagn Images)

Despite that clarification, speculation continued to spread online, with many users drawing comparisons to crime thrillers or past serial killer cases.

“Isn’t this what the police say in every serial killer movie?” one Facebook user wrote.

Theodore Bundy in a blue suit sitting in court

Theodore Bundy, seated in court in July 1979, was charged with the murders of two Florida State coeds. (Getty Images)

Others invoked infamous cases like Ted Bundy and John Wayne Gacy, arguing that police in those eras also downplayed initial warnings.

Worries spread over the weekend after three women were found dead in different parts of Jacksonville within three days.

On Saturday, 24-year-old Cherrish Nunley, a mother of two, was found fatally shot in a parking lot, according to News4Jax. A GoFundMe page created for her family described her as a devoted mother and “a bright, beautiful girl” who was “killed in cold blood.”

Selfie of 24-year-old Cherrish Nunley

Cherrish Nunley, 24, was found shot and killed in a parking lot in Jacksonville on Nov. 15, according to a post from family members on a GoFundMe page. (GoFundMe)

The following day, a fisherman discovered the body of Tiffany Felton beneath a bridge on Blanding Boulevard, FirstCoastNews reported.

“This was an unnecessary killing,” AJ Jordan, outreach coordinator with MAD DADS, told the outlet. “Him or her left this lady under a bridge, under a bridge. It’s just, it’s just sad.” 

On Monday, deputies were called to a rooming house in the city’s Phoenix neighborhood, where another woman was found unresponsive, according to FirstCoastNews. A sheriff’s sergeant told the outlet that details surrounding her death were not immediately clear.

3800 Sunbeam Rd, Jacksonville, Florida

A body of a mother of two, Cherrish Nunley, was found dead behind a business near the 3800 block of Sunbeam Road in Jacksonville, Fla. (Google Maps)

Investigators say that, at this stage, the cases do not appear connected. Police have not confirmed whether any suspects have been identified or taken into custody.

While online speculation remains intense, authorities reiterated that there is no evidence linking the deaths or suggesting a broader threat.

“3 bodies in 3 days? Forgive me, but you can’t credibly say it’s not a serial killer if you haven’t solved it yet,” one skeptical user wrote.

Another commented, “Well… honestly there probably is one or two, but we just don’t know about it yet.”

“Our detectives are investigating recent homicide cases that involve female victims, following the facts and evidence in each case. We will share updates as soon as we are able to, but we want to reassure the community there is no danger to the public related [to] these incidents,” the department said.

Stepheny Price covers crime, including missing persons, homicides and migrant crime. Send story tips to stepheny.price@fox.com.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
Chicago Cardinal Blase Cupich, other Catholic leaders issue rare moral warning as tensions rise over Greenland

Chicago Cardinal Blase Cupich and Fellow Catholic Leaders Issue Uncommon Moral Advisory Amid Escalating Greenland Tensions

CHICAGO (WLS) — As international tensions escalate, particularly concerning Greenland and other…
FILE - A crowd marches across the Lefty O

US Political Tensions Ignite Calls for Action on MLK Day

As the nation marks the 40th federal observance of Martin Luther King…
This week on The Hill: Lawmakers scramble to avert partial shutdown

This Week on Capitol Hill: Legislators Work Diligently to Prevent Partial Government Shutdown

Lawmakers in both the House and Senate find themselves in a critical…
JSO: One injured in overnight shooting near St. Johns Town Center

Breaking News: Overnight Shooting Near St. Johns Town Center Leaves One Injured – Stay Informed

Authorities from the Jacksonville Sheriff’s Office have reported a shooting incident that…
Teen charged as adult after fleeing deputies investigating St. Johns County boy's kidnapping

Teen Faces Adult Charges After Fleeing Authorities in St. Johns County Kidnapping Case

Authorities are currently investigating whether 15-year-old Junior Bishop played a role in…
Russia plots major strike on Europe's largest nuclear plant power lines: source

Russia Allegedly Plans Significant Attack on Power Lines of Europe’s Largest Nuclear Facility: Source

Russia is reportedly gearing up to target the power lines of Europe’s…
Poison ends plans for 2026 comeback tour claims band member

Band Member Reveals Poison’s 2026 Comeback Tour Plans Have Been Halted

Plans for a 2026 reunion tour by the iconic heavy metal band…
Calor Ma Da Nescht, U-Haul driver who drove through anti-Iranian regime rally in Los Angeles, CA believes it was misunderstanding

Misunderstanding or Malice? U-Haul Driver’s Controversial Encounter at Los Angeles Anti-Iranian Regime Rally

In a dramatic turn of events last Sunday in Los Angeles, Calor…