Top conservatives blast MAGA for saying DHS shooting was justified
Share and Follow

Key figures from the MAGA movement have come under fire from fellow conservatives and the National Rifle Association for hastily supporting the Department of Homeland Security’s actions in the shooting of a protester in Minneapolis.

Following the death of 37-year-old nurse Alex Pretti on Saturday, Border Patrol Commander Greg Bovino commented, “The suspect was found with two loaded magazines and no identifiable ID.”

Bovino went on to suggest, “This appears to be a case where the individual intended to inflict significant harm and target law enforcement officers.”

However, Dana Loesch, a former spokesperson for the National Rifle Association and a notable advocate for Second Amendment rights, pushed back against the implication that Pretti was at fault solely for possessing a legally owned firearm.

“Comments like this are not constructive,” Loesch responded to Bovino’s statement.

‘What he has or didn’t have isn’t the issue. What he was doing, with or without it, is the issue. Did he draw on agents? Reach for it? Was it on him? Again, being armed is different from being armed in commission of obstructing federal LEO.’

Loesch also had stern words for a Trump-appointed prosecutor in California, who flippantly implied that Pretti had gotten what was coming to him. 

Bill Essayli, who is First Assistant US Attorney for the Central District of California, wrote on X: ‘If you approach law enforcement with a gun, there is a high likelihood they will be legally justified in shooting you. Don’t do it!’

Dana Loesch, the former national spokesperson for National Rifle Association, feuded on social media with fellow conservatives who quickly declared that the shooting of a protestor in Minneapolis by a Border Patrol agent was justified

Dana Loesch, the former national spokesperson for National Rifle Association, feuded on social media with fellow conservatives who quickly declared that the shooting of a protestor in Minneapolis by a Border Patrol agent was justified

Alex Pretti, a 37-year-old Minnesota resident and US citizen, was shot just after 9am near Glam Doll Donuts on the corner of 26th Street and Nicollet Avenue

Alex Pretti, a 37-year-old Minnesota resident and US citizen, was shot just after 9am near Glam Doll Donuts on the corner of 26th Street and Nicollet Avenue

Pictured: Federal agents surrounded Pretti after pepper spraying him and tackling him to the ground. Shortly after he was taken down to the sidewalk, an agent fired 10 shots

Pictured: Federal agents surrounded Pretti after pepper spraying him and tackling him to the ground. Shortly after he was taken down to the sidewalk, an agent fired 10 shots

Pictured: Loesch said Border Patrol commander Greg Bovino's statement on the shooting didn't help

Pictured: Loesch said Border Patrol commander Greg Bovino’s statement on the shooting didn’t help

Pictured: She also took issue with this statement from Bovino, when he said Pretti wanted to cause 'maximum damage and 'massacre' agents

Pictured: She also took issue with this statement from Bovino, when he said Pretti wanted to cause ‘maximum damage and ‘massacre’ agents

Loesch responded: ‘What does this mean to you? Do you believe that mere legal possession within the vicinity of LEO is a criminal offense or merits use of force as response? Language matters.’

Responsible Gun Owners of America also condemned Essayli, writing: ‘We condemn the untoward comments of @USAttyEssayli. 

‘Federal agents are not “highly likely” to be “legally justified” in “shooting” concealed carry licensees who approach while lawfully carrying a firearm. 

‘The Second Amendment protects Americans’ right to bear arms while protesting – a right the federal government must not infringe upon.’

Pretti was shot dead by a Department of Homeland Security agent on Saturday while protesting the arrest of an Ecuadorian migrant named Jose Huerta‑Chuma. 

DHS has noted that Huerta-Chuma has previously been charged with domestic abuse and driving without a license. 

Department of Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem said Pretti ‘brandished a gun’ at her agents.

She defended Pretti’s shooting as an act of self-defense. 

Video that has emerged since cast serious doubt on Noem’s assertion and led to condemnation from MAGA sources who accused her of speaking before she knew the full facts.

Department of Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem said Pretti 'brandished a gun' at her agents. Video that has emerged since cast serious doubt on Noem's assertion

Department of Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem said Pretti ‘brandished a gun’ at her agents. Video that has emerged since cast serious doubt on Noem’s assertion

Loesch also criticized Bill Essayli, First Assistant US Attorney for the Central District of California

Loesch also criticized Bill Essayli, First Assistant US Attorney for the Central District of California

Essayli wrote: 'If you approach law enforcement with a gun, there is a high likelihood they will be legally justified in shooting you. Don’t do it!'

Essayli wrote: ‘If you approach law enforcement with a gun, there is a high likelihood they will be legally justified in shooting you. Don’t do it!’

Loesch argued back, saying the legal possession of a gun does not equal approaching a law enforcement with a gun

Loesch argued back, saying the legal possession of a gun does not equal approaching a law enforcement with a gun

The NRA itself also condemned Essayli's statement as 'dangerous and wrong'

The NRA itself also condemned Essayli’s statement as ‘dangerous and wrong’

Pictured: The Gun Owners of America statement on the shooting of Pretti

Pictured: The Gun Owners of America statement on the shooting of Pretti

Pretti, an intensive care nurse at Minneapolis Veterans Affairs hospital, was seen holding his phone to film agents on Saturday.

He got into a scuffle with DHS agents after going to help an unidentified female protester who they’d shoved. Pretti was seen being pepper-sprayed.

Seconds later, he was shoved to the ground with multiple DHS agents trying to hold him down.

Footage appears to show one of those agents clearly removing Pretti’s handgun from his waistband.

He had a concealed carry license and the weapon was legally registered, according to Minneapolis Police Chief Brian O’Hara.

A few seconds after the gun was removed, one of the DHS agents shot Pretti in the back.

The same agent then shot him nine more times, with Pretti seen falling to the ground and dying. 

None of the agents have been named. The agent who shot and killed Pretti is an eight-year veteran of the Department of Homeland Security who is from Minnesota.

Minneapolis lawmakers are suing to try and preserve evidence from the scene ahead of a possible investigation.  

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
Federal agents stand near the site of a shooting Saturday, Jan. 24, 2026, in Minneapolis. (AP Photo/Abbie Parr)

Tragic Loss: ICU Nurse Fatally Shot by Federal Officer in Minneapolis Sparks Outcry

MINNEAPOLIS (AP) — A Minneapolis tragedy has sparked conversations about compassion and…
Mamdani urges ‘abolish ICE’ after armed protester shot in Minneapolis — ‘Abolish ICE’

Mamdani Calls for ICE Abolition Following Minneapolis Protest Incident

On Saturday, Mayor Mamdani expressed strong criticism of ICE, alleging the agency…
Gov. Tim Walz vows Minnesota will lead investigation into Saturday's deadly shooting

Governor Tim Walz Commits to Spearheading Minnesota’s Investigation into Saturday’s Fatal Shooting

In the wake of a fatal shooting by federal immigration officers, Minnesota’s…
Pentagon tells US allies to handle their own defence in new strategy

Pentagon’s New Strategy Urges US Allies to Strengthen Self-Defense Capabilities

The United States government has issued a directive to its allies, including…
ICE in Chicago: Eighteenth Barber Co. Ponte Tus Moños fundraiser in Pilsen to support families impacted by immigration operations

Chicago’s Pilsen Fundraiser: Eighteenth Barber Co. Mobilizes Community Support for Families Affected by ICE Operations

CHICAGO (WLS) — In a unique show of solidarity, a local activist…
All the videos that captured fed agent shooting of Alex Jeffrey Pretti

Comprehensive Video Footage Surfaces of Federal Agent’s Shooting of Alex Jeffrey Pretti

The city of Minneapolis finds itself engulfed in turmoil once again following…
Senate Democrats vow to block DHS funding bill after Minnesota shooting, raising partial shutdown risk

Senate Showdown: Democrats Threaten DHS Funding Block Over Minnesota Shooting, Heightening Shutdown Stakes

The recent events in Minnesota have drawn significant attention, with Senate Democratic…
Family of slain anti-ICE protester rings out

Family of Deceased Anti-ICE Activist Speaks Out

The family of a Minnesota protester who was fatally shot by border…