New Jersey restaurant sparked backlash over 'Proud Boys Burger' menu special
Share and Follow

A restaurant in New Jersey faced significant backlash after adding a burger to its menu in honor of the “Proud Boys,” a far-right group. The online community reacted strongly to this move, prompting the owner to issue an apology for unintentionally supporting the controversial group.

Aqua Blu Kitchen & Cocktails’ “Proud Boys Burger” included ingredients that were listed on the menu as “white American cheese,” “layers of truth,” “cancel culture coleslaw,” and “liberty sauce.”

After an online firestorm of outrage began when a customer uploaded a picture of the menu, owner Cathy Varriale tried to distance herself from her eatery’s greasy item. 

“I know this may sound ridiculous, but I didn’t know what a Proud Boy was,” she told NJ Advance Media, explaining that the idea for the burger came from one of her chefs.

“I thought it was, you know, a proud boy.”

Varriale – who noted her eatery has previously featured both a Sleepy Joe and a Trump Burger – said her phone and inbox were flooded with messages after the special was advertised in a now-deleted Facebook post as “layered with boldness and liberty.”

She quickly asked her chef if the burger represented something disrespectful before removing the post and reprinting the menus. But her efforts didn’t stop the poor reception, which she said has been a “nightmare,” the outlet reported. 

“Now that I know what it is, I completely understand,” the emotional owner said.

“But how do you fix it? I don’t know how to fix it.”

Varriale said her restaurant has featured themed burgers every Thursday for the last eight years, with the ill-named special one of four listed that night. 

She had asked her staff to create two burgers this week based on their family – a request that has turned into her disputing claims that her staff and their families are linked to the Proud Boys organization.

“It was a bad decision,” Varriale said.

“It was stupidity. It was ignorance. But we do not support hatred or Nazism or any of that.”

She said angry callers have made threats of protests outside of the restaurant and others refusing to come back.

Varriale, who opened her popular eatery 13 years ago, shared a lengthy apology to Aqua Blu’s Facebook Friday morning, explaining that the burger was a mistake and her bistro stands united against hate.

“We understand how it may have been interpreted, but it was never our intention nor what we stand for. We ask that you take this into consideration as we reflect and learn from this experience,” the post, which shuttered the comments section, read.

“To those who have supported us over the years, we deeply appreciate every single one of you. Please know that we would never do anything to jeopardize the trust and respect you have for Aqua Blu. We hope you understand and accept this as a formal apology.”

The Anti-Defamation League considers the Proud Boys as a right-wing, extremist hate group that is misogynistic, Islamophobic, and anti-immigration.

Members — several-hundred strong — also espouse white supremacist and anti-Semitic ideologies, according to the ADL.

The self-described “Western chauvinists” group has been active since at least 2016, with leaders advocating for its members and followers to commit acts of violence against rivals who disagree with their extreme ideologies.

The group was famously involved in the Charlottesville “Unite the Right” rally where one woman was killed when she was mowed down by a Nazi sympathizer.

The burger special came just days after President Trump pardoned approximately 1,500 individuals convicted in connection with the Jan. 6, 2021, Capitol riot, including Proud Boys leader Enrique Tarrio.

He was freed after serving 16 months of his 22-year prison sentence – one of the longest dished out by a judge in a Jan. 6 case – for his role in orchestrating the Proud Boys’ part in the events of that day.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
Winning '$1,000 A Week For Life' lottery ticket sold in St. Augustine

St. Augustine Resident Scores Big with Lifetime $1,000 Weekly Lottery Win

In a stroke of New Year’s luck, a lucky individual in St.…
Woman arrested for deadly stabbing of man at Grand Park home

Woman Detained in Fatal Stabbing Incident at Grand Park Residence

In a tragic incident unfolding just after the holiday season, a Jacksonville…
All the eclipses, supermoons, meteor showers and planets to spot in 2026

Celestial Events to Watch in 2026: Eclipses, Supermoons, Meteor Showers, and Planetary Alignments

In 2026, the night sky promises to be a spectacle for astronomy…
Texas-based marine robotics company launches 55-day mission to find Malaysia Airlines flight wreckage

Texas Robotics Pioneer Embarks on Ambitious 55-Day Quest to Uncover Malaysia Airlines Mystery

A Texas-based marine robotics firm has launched a mission to unearth the…
Gov. DeSantis makes new appointment to St. Augustine Airport Authority

Governor DeSantis Announces Fresh Leadership for St. Augustine Airport Authority

Should the Florida Senate confirm him, Daniel Bean is set to become…
The surprising sign in your eyes that indicates if you'll get dementia

New Study Reveals Eye Indicator as Potential Early Sign of Dementia Risk

Memory loss is a well-known warning sign for the onset of dementia,…
2025 recap: New Bears era, Chicago-born Pope Leo, CPD officer killed, fiery CTA attack, Operation 'Midway Blitz', and more

Highlights of 2025: Chicago’s New Bears Legacy, Hometown Hero Pope Leo, Tragic Loss of CPD Officer, Explosive CTA Incident, and ‘Midway Blitz’ Unveiled

As 2025 draws to a close, ABC7 takes a moment to look…
Iowa vs. Vanderbilt prediction, picks: Odds, best bet for ReliaQuest Bowl

ReliaQuest Bowl 2023: Expert Predictions and Top Betting Odds for Iowa vs. Vanderbilt Showdown

Gambling content 21+. The New York Post may receive an affiliate commission…