North Dakota’s overturned abortion ban won’t be in effect during appeal, court rules
Share and Follow


BISMARCK, N.D. (AP) — North Dakota’s abortion ban will not be enforced while the state appeals an earlier decision that found it unconstitutional, the state’s highest court ruled Friday.

That appeal has yet to fully play out in the state Supreme Court after a judge struck down the law in September.

North Dakota has had no abortion providers since the only one moved from Fargo to neighboring Moorhead, Minnesota, in 2022. The only scenarios in which North Dakotans can currently obtain an abortion in the state would be for life- or health-preserving reasons at a hospital.

The plaintiffs had contended that keeping the overturned ban from being enforced was important for patients with pregnancy complications who go to a hospital seeking medical care that might be delayed because of the law.

Attorneys for the state had asked the North Dakota Supreme Court to grant a stay pending appeal. They said a stay “is warranted because this case presents serious, difficult, and unresolved constitutional questions that are of profound importance to the people of this State,” among other reasons.

State District Judge Bruce Romanick had earlier denied a requested stay, saying: “It would be non-sensical for this Court to keep a law it has found to be unconstitutional in effect pending appeal.”

The Center for Reproductive Rights, which represents the abortion clinic and several physicians who challenged the law, opposed a stay. The court heard oral arguments on the state’s request for a stay in November.

“Today’s decision to keep the abortion ban blocked was the only logical outcome,” Meetra Mehdizadeh, senior staff attorney at the center, said in a statement. “People are dying without access to abortion, and still the State sought to stop pregnant North Dakotans facing dangerous situations from getting the care they need. It’s shameful. We will not stop fighting until this ban is struck down once and for all.”

In a statement, North Dakota Attorney General Drew Wrigley said: “This is only a decision on the stay motion, not on the constitutional merits of the legislation. North Dakota will continue moving forward to fully litigate this matter before the state Supreme Court, where we intend to establish that the law passed by our legislature is clearly constitutional.”

The case has had a winding road since the Red River Women’s Clinic initially challenged the state’s previous abortion ban in the wake of the U.S. Supreme Court overturning Roe v. Wade in 2022.

In 2023, North Dakota’s Republican-controlled Legislature revised the state’s abortion laws. That law criminalized the performance of an abortion as a felony, with the only exceptions to save the life of a mother or to prevent a “serious health risk” to her. The ban also allowed for abortions in cases of rape or incest but only up to six weeks gestation, which is often before many women know they are pregnant. The plaintiffs said the law was unconstitutionally vague and its health exception too narrow.

Republican state Sen. Janne Myrdal, who introduced the 2023 bill that became law, said she doesn’t view Friday’s decision as a setback.

“It’s not a reflection of the validity of the constitutionality of the law … and I don’t read anything more into that fact, actually,” Myrdal said.

Justice Douglas Bahr recused himself from the state’s request for a stay. In an email to The Associated Press in which he cited the state judicial ethics code, Bahr said he represented the state as solicitor general in a previous Supreme Court case involving the clinic.

A Center for Reproductive Rights spokesman said the clinic has no current plans to return to North Dakota.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
Chicago firefighter, another person injured after West Side church fire spreads to another building at N. Lotus Ave., W. Huron St.

Chicago Firefighter and Civilian Injured as West Side Church Blaze Extends to Adjacent Building on N. Lotus Ave. and W. Huron St.

A blaze erupted on Sunday night, injuring a Chicago firefighter and another…
Australian PM Albanese gets booed during Bondi Beach vigil honoring Hanukkah attack victims

Australian PM Albanese Faces Backlash at Bondi Beach Vigil for Hanukkah Attack Victims

During a vigil held on Sunday to honor the victims of the…
Baby girl dies after dad fell asleep in hot tub while holding her

Tragic Incident: Father Falls Asleep in Hot Tub, Resulting in Infant’s Death

A heartbreaking incident unfolded when a one-year-old girl tragically drowned after her…
MFTK holds 2nd annual Spartan Showcase in Jacksonville

Discover the Thrills: MFTK’s 2nd Annual Spartan Showcase Captivates Jacksonville

High school athletes from various parts of the South flocked to the…
Jesus Martinez charged with setting CTA Blue Line fire near Damen Blue Line stop in Wicker Park: Chicago Police Department

Chicago Police Department Charges Jesus Martinez in CTA Blue Line Arson Near Damen Station in Wicker Park

A man has been charged after allegedly igniting a fire on a…
Iran executes man convicted of spying for Israeli intelligence

Iran Executes Convicted Israeli Spy: Unveiling the High-Stakes Espionage Drama

Iranian authorities have executed a man accused of espionage for Israel’s intelligence…
Convicted killer kept in police oversight role as city council dismisses concerns over public safety

City Council Faces Backlash for Retaining Convicted Killer in Police Oversight Role Despite Safety Concerns

A convicted murderer from Oregon has been reinstated to Salem’s police oversight…
When does Girl Scout cookie season start?

When Does the Girl Scout Cookie Season Officially Begin?

The eagerly anticipated Girl Scout cookie season is just around the corner,…