Judge says government can't limit passport sex markers for many transgender, nonbinary people
Share and Follow


BOSTON (AP) — A federal judge has blocked the Trump administration from limiting passport sex markers for many transgender and nonbinary Americans.

Tuesday’s ruling from U.S. District Judge Julia Kobick means that transgender or nonbinary people who are without a passport or need to apply for a new one can request a male, female or “X” identification marker rather than being limited to the marker that matches the gender assigned at birth.

In an executive order signed in January, the president used a narrow definition of the sexes instead of a broader conception of gender. The order said a person is male or female and rejected the idea that someone can transition from the sex assigned at birth to another gender.

Kobick first issued a preliminary injunction against the policy last month, but that ruling applied only to six people who joined with the American Civil Liberties Union in a lawsuit over the passport policy.

In Tuesday’s ruling she agreed to expand the injunction to include transgender or nonbinary people who are currently without a valid passport, those whose passport is expiring within a year, and those who need to apply for a passport because theirs was lost or stolen or because they need to change their name or sex designation.

The White House did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

The government failed to show that blocking its policy would cause it any constitutional injury, Kobick wrote, or harm the executive branch’s relations with other countries.

The transgender and nonbinary people covered by the preliminary injunction, meanwhile, have shown that the passport policy violates their constitutional rights to equal protection, Kobick said.

“Even assuming a preliminary injunction inflicts some constitutional harm on the Executive Branch, such harm is the consequence of the State Department’s adoption of a Passport Policy that likely violates the constitutional rights of thousands of Americans,” Kobick wrote.

Kobick, who was appointed by former President Joe Biden, sided with the ACLU’s motion for a preliminary injunction, which stays the action while the lawsuit plays out.

“The Executive Order and the Passport Policy on their face classify passport applicants on the basis of sex and thus must be reviewed under intermediate judicial scrutiny,” Kobick wrote in the preliminary injunction issued earlier this year. “That standard requires the government to demonstrate that its actions are substantially related to an important governmental interest. The government has failed to meet this standard.”

In its lawsuit, the ACLU described how one woman had her passport returned with a male designation while others are too scared to submit their passports because they fear their applications might be suspended and their passports held by the State Department.

Another mailed in their passport Jan. 9 and requested to change their name and their sex designation from male to female. That person was still waiting for their passport, the ACLU said in the lawsuit, and feared missing a family wedding and a botany conference this year.

In response to the lawsuit, the Trump administration argued that the passport policy change “does not violate the equal protection guarantees of the Constitution.” It also contended that the president has broad discretion in setting passport policy and that plaintiffs would not be harmed since they are still free to travel abroad.

___

Associated Press writer Rebecca Boone in Boise, Idaho, contributed.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
Marvel's 'Wonder Man' looks at an actor trying to get cast as a superhero

Marvel’s ‘Wonder Man’ Explores an Actor’s Quest for Superhero Stardom

Marvel Television is set to unveil a fresh superhero narrative. The upcoming…
Hundreds of Border Patrol agents ordered to LEAVE Minneapolis

Hundreds of Border Patrol Agents Redeployed from Minneapolis

In a sweeping reshuffle prompted by Tom Homan, the so-called ‘little Napoleon’…
Singer-songwriter Todd Snider dies at 59

Reggae Icon Sly Dunbar, Drummer for Music Legends, Passes Away at 73

As one half of the legendary duo Sly & Robbie, Sly Dunbar…
DHS probes whether agents killed VA nurse following accidental discharge during Minneapolis ICE raid

Investigation Launched: DHS Examines Fatal Shooting of VA Nurse During Minneapolis ICE Raid

The Department of Homeland Security is delving into the circumstances surrounding the…
Whoopi Goldberg Empathizes With ‘Bridgerton’ Star Yerin Ha On ‘The View’: “People Make You Feel Like You Shouldn’t Be in a Romantic Relationship With a White Guy”

Whoopi Goldberg Discusses Racial Dynamics in Romance with ‘Bridgerton’ Actress Yerin Ha on ‘The View

This morning on The View, actress Yerin Ha received valuable advice from…
Andrew Garay, US Army veteran and dad killed in Humboldt Park, Chicago shooting, remembered as selfless, hardworking

Honoring Andrew Garay: A Selfless US Army Veteran and Devoted Father Tragically Lost in Chicago Shooting

In the wake of a tragic weekend shooting on Chicago’s Northwest Side,…
Purple Heart veteran 'heartbroken' after thief nabs his American flag from California home

California Veteran Devastated as Thief Steals Cherished American Flag from Home

A Vietnam veteran, who has been honored with the prestigious Purple Heart,…
Why hasn't body camera footage been released in Minneapolis ICE shootings?

Unveiling the Mystery: Delays in Minneapolis ICE Shooting Body Cam Footage Explained

(NEXSTAR) – In recent weeks, federal agents have been involved in two…