Defense lawyers urged to reexamine convictions led by fired Karen Read detective
Share and Follow

Michael Proctor’s firing from the Massachusetts State Police over his handling of the Karen Read investigation could be a wake-up call to defense attorneys around the state whose clients have been convicted based on his work.

Proctor, a 12-year veteran, lost his job after an investigation into his handling of the case kicked off following Read’s mistrial last year. During his testimony, a series of rude and lewd text messages he sent about Read were read in court, tanking his credibility in the eyes of at least some jurors. 

The internal review found he had improperly shared “sensitive or confidential information” about the homicide investigation on top of the “derogatory texts.”

A close-up of Karen Read smiling next to John O'Keefe wearing a white backwards hat.

Karen Read and John O’Keefe (Karen Read)

Edwards is predicting a number of surprises the second time around and that Read’s fate will hinge on how jurors respond to evidence the defense hopes will demonstrate an abundance of reasonable doubt in the case.

Special prosecutor Hank Brennan is a high-powered Massachusetts defense attorney who once represented mobster James “Whitey” Bulger in federal court. Read’s defense keeps adding new players, and her lawyers recently petitioned the Supreme Court to throw out two of the three charges against her.

Proctor declined to discuss the case himself, but family members told Fox News Digital last month that he had an “unblemished record” prior to the Read texts.

Michael Proctor testifies on the witness stand during Karen Read's murder trial

Michael Proctor (Kayla Bartkowski/The Boston Globe via Getty Images)

The review and a federal investigation into the fiasco both opened and closed without criminal charges against Proctor. 

“The messages prove one thing, and that Michael is human, not corrupt, not incompetent in his role as a homicide detective, and certainly not unfit to continue to be a Massachusetts state yrooper,” his sister, Courtney Proctor, said at the time.

Fox News’ Andrew Fone contributed to this report.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
Woke city hires MURDERER who killed girl to its police review board

Controversy Erupts as City Appoints Convicted Murderer to Police Oversight Board

The decision to reinstate a convicted murderer to a city’s police review…

Devastating Christmas Storm Causes Mudslide to Ravage Southern California Home

The holiday season took a disastrous turn for one homeowner when a…
Maria Shriver leads emotional family tributes to Tatiana Schlossberg

Maria Shriver Honors Tatiana Schlossberg with Heartfelt Family Tributes

Heartfelt tributes are pouring in following the tragic passing of Tatiana Schlossberg,…
Meghan Markle named most disappointing celebrity of 2025 by Toronto

Toronto’s Surprising 2025 Verdict: Why Meghan Markle Tops the List of Most Disappointing Celebrities

Meghan Markle has been labeled as the “most disappointing celebrity of 2025”…
Wendy's is offering 1-cent bacon burgers for one day only. Here's how to get one

Score a 1-Cent Bacon Burger at Wendy’s: Exclusive One-Day Offer and How to Grab Yours

If you’re a fan of bacon and love a good deal, Wendy’s…
Chicago Public Schools Board approves property tax hike to close budget gap

Chicago Public Schools Boosts Property Taxes: A Critical Move to Bridge Budget Deficit

In a recent decision by Chicago’s partially elected and partially appointed school…
FILE - Voters fill out their ballots Nov. 4, 2025, in Detroit. (AP Photo/Paul Sancya, File)

Democrats on Alert: Concerns Rise Over Trump’s Potential Influence in Upcoming Midterms

Based on historical patterns, Republicans could face challenges in maintaining control of…
Is New Year's Day a federal holiday? Here's what's open and closed

New Year’s Day: Federal Holiday Status and What’s Open or Closed

Kicking off 2026, most workers will enjoy a day off, potentially complicating…