Defense seeks to exclude rap videos in murder trial of Prince Holland
Share and Follow


The defense in a high-profile murder trial seeks to exclude YouTube rap videos as evidence, arguing they are irrelevant and prejudicial.

JACKSONVILLE, Fla. — The defense in the high-profile murder trial of two men accused of killing 13-year-old Prince Holland is seeking to exclude YouTube rap videos and social media posts as evidence, arguing that the content is irrelevant and prejudicial.

Marcel Johnson and Kentrevious Garard appeared in court Friday for a hearing that could affect the presentation of evidence in their upcoming double trial.

Holland was fatally shot in 2022 while riding in a car home from football tryouts in the Moncrief area.

Prosecutors contend the videos, including Instagram Live posts and YouTube clips, establish connections to the shooting and suggest identification of the murder weapon. A key part of the state’s argument was that the videos show a firearm linked to the crime.

“What the state’s going to argue is a gun is the murder weapon, but at least there’s a firearm that could have been used on the scene,” said the lead prosecutor.

Defense attorneys countered that the videos show Garrard only in the background while co-defendant Johnson raps, sometimes with a gun. They argued the videos contain improper character evidence, including racially charged language and gestures not connected to the shooting.

“The danger here, Judge, is the jury would see my client making these racial slurs, cursing, gesturing with his hands like guns, waving a handgun that isn’t even alleged to be part of this case,” Johnson’s defense attorney said. “None of that proves who committed the crime. It only paints my client as the type of person who may be guilty because of the lifestyle that he lives.”

The prosecution was unable to present the actual redacted videos in court Friday, prompting the judge to delay a ruling. He said he needs to review the edited footage carefully before deciding what may be shown to jurors.

“I don’t think I can really… until I look at the redacted video,” Judge Jeb Branham said. “Even in the absence of that, we probably have to weigh in to some degree how I think the redacted video meets with my order.”

A final decision on the admissibility of the videos is expected at a follow-up hearing scheduled for Sept. 18 at the Duval County Courthouse.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
Urgent questions Timothy Busfield's wife Melissa Gilbert must answer

Melissa Gilbert Faces Pressing Questions About Her Life with Timothy Busfield

He insists on his innocence. Actor and director Timothy Busfield, 68, has…
FILE - Tyler Robinson, who is accused of fatally shooting Charlie Kirk, appears during a hearing in Fourth District Court in Provo, Utah, Dec. 11, 2025. (Rick Egan/The Salt Lake Tribune via AP, Pool, File)

Suspect in Charlie Kirk Case Requests Judge to Remove Prosecutors

In Salt Lake City, a significant legal battle is unfolding as Tyler…
JSO officer arrested on petty theft charge

Jacksonville Officer Faces Charges for Battery and Witness Tampering Following Domestic Dispute

Jose Guerra, a seasoned corrections officer with nearly two decades of service…
Illegal immigrant indicted in assault on ICE agents in Texas

Undocumented Immigrant Charged in Alleged Assault on ICE Agents in Texas

An illegal immigrant has been officially indicted following an assault on federal…
Nicole Richie addresses her daughter's new identity on 18th birthday

Nicole Richie Shares Heartfelt Message About Her Daughter’s Journey on 18th Birthday

Nicole Richie has opened up for the first time about her daughter’s…
Massachusetts town faces lawsuit for allowing criminal immigrant, sex offender to renew business license

Massachusetts Town Sued Over Business License Renewal for Immigrant with Criminal Record

A Massachusetts woman has initiated legal action against the town of Hopkinton,…
Jacksonville woman arrested after allegedly punching trooper during ICE confrontation, Florida AG says

Jacksonville Woman Charged: Alleged Assault on Trooper During ICE Encounter Sparks Legal Action, Says Florida AG

A Jacksonville woman, Jennifer Cruz, was apprehended on Tuesday and is now…
SoCal raid: ICE agents climb onto roof, chase construction workers

ICE Agents Ascend Rooftop in Southern California Raid Targeting Construction Workers

MONTEBELLO, Calif. — A wave of immigration raids swept through Southern California…