Democratic lawmakers sue DHS after being denied access to detention centers
Share and Follow


A coalition of Democratic lawmakers is suing the Department of Homeland Security after the agency released a new policy seeking to limit how elected officials may visit detention centers.

Lawmakers have a right to make unannounced visits to detention centers, but the Department of Homeland Security has sought to curb visits with a new policy requiring lawmakers give a week’s notice before any visit. 

The suit says all 12 Democratic lawmakers were denied access to DHS and U.S Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) facilities as a result of the policy.

“The Trump Administration is systematically violating our legal right as Members of Congress to conduct oversight of DHS facilities. This blockade of Congress, deliberately interfering with our constitutional duty to perform oversight of the immigration system, is designed to stop us from checking out reports of inhumane treatment and denial of fundamental rights to immigrants in detention,”  Rep. Jamie Raskin (D-Md.), the top Democrat on the House Judiciary Committee, said in a release.

“President Trump and Secretary Noem believe they can block scrutiny of their lawless immigration enforcement sweep by closing out Members of Congress. But these brazen attempts to rebuff us—in stark violation of federal law—only deepen our resolve to get information to the American people.”

Raskin, along with Reps. Adrianno Espaillat (N.Y.), Joe Neguse (Colo.), Bennie Thompson (Ala.), Robert Garcia (Calif.), Lou Correa (Calif.), Jason Crow (Colo), Veronica Escobar (Texas), Dan Goldman (N.Y.), Jimmy Gomez (Calif.), Raul Ruiz (Calif.), and Norma Torres (Calif.) are all plaintiffs in the suit.

DHS initially rolled out a policy requesting that lawmakers give 72 hours notice before visiting a facility, but replaced the guidance with stricter rules just days later. The new policy also blocks access to visits at ICE Field Offices or other ICE facilities that are not detention centers.

The move comes after DHS closed a number of other offices that provided oversight of DHS, including the Office of Civil Rights and Civil Liberties, the Office of the Immigration Detention Ombudsman as well as the Office of the Citizenship and Immigration Services Ombudsman.

“The obstruction of Congressional oversight is not just an affront to the Constitution—it’s a threat to our democracy,” Congressional Hispanic Caucus Chair Adriano Espaillat (D-N.Y.) said in a release. 

“Since day one, we have witnessed the Trump Administration’s systematic efforts to dehumanize immigrants, detain tens of thousands—including U.S. citizens—and weaponize federal agencies to carry out a mass deportation agenda rooted in cruelty and chaos. The Trump Administration has consistently hindered oversight powers while gutting internal watchdogs,” he added, referencing the three offices, “creating the perfect storm for abuse and impunity.” 

The suit argues that the new policy violates provisions of various appropriations bills that say agency funds cannot be used to block lawmakers from visiting facilities.

The law has its roots in the first Trump administration, enacted after Escobar and other lawmakers had trouble gaining access to ICE facilities.

The Department of Homeland Security dismissed the suit as a fundraising effort.  

“These Members of Congress could have just scheduled a tour; instead, they’re running to court to drive clicks and fundraising emails,” spokeswoman Tricia McLaughlin said in a statement. 

“As for visits to detention facilities, requests should be made with sufficient time to prevent interference with the President’s Article II authority to oversee executive department functions—a week is sufficient to ensure no intrusion on the President’s constitutional authority. To protect the President’s Article II authority, any request to shorten that time must be approved by the Secretary.”

Brought in coordination with Democracy Forward and American Oversight, the suit says the new policy violates Section 527 of the fiscal year 2024 DHS appropriations bill as well as the Administrative Procedures Act.

The suit also argues there are downsides to scheduled visits, citing a 2020 House Homeland Security report that found advanced notice allowed DHS to shift its practices.

“The report emphasized that when congressional staff provided advance notice of oversight visits, ‘ICE facilities used the advanced warning to improve the conditions within the facility.’ Staff detected evidence of those improvements, including the smell of fresh paint, evidence of a major clean-up, the relocation of individuals from solitary cells to the general population, and the installation of new guards,” the suit states.

Those experiences, they argue, “demonstrate the importance of conducting that oversight in real time, without prior notice.” 

Updated at 5:19 p.m.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
Riverdale Mayor Lawrence Jackson convicted on perjury, obstruction of justice charges, federal prosecutors say

Riverdale Mayor Lawrence Jackson Found Guilty of Perjury and Obstruction, Announce Federal Prosecutors

The mayor of Riverdale, a suburb in southern Illinois, has been found…
Chinese Shenzhou-20 astronauts begin return to Earth after debris struck spacecraft

Shenzhou-20 Astronauts Safely Begin Earthbound Journey Following Space Debris Collision

After a brief delay caused by space debris impacting their craft, three…
Full story of diarrhea incident at Gwyneth Paltrow's Hamptons house

Inside Scoop: The Unforeseen Incident at Gwyneth Paltrow’s Hamptons Residence

Gwyneth Paltrow remains upset and humiliated by a disastrous incident involving a…
'Your voices matter to us': Jacksonville Apna Bazar withdraws request for meat processing facility

Jacksonville Apna Bazar Listens to Community, Cancels Meat Processing Facility Plans

The decision to withdraw follows vocal opposition from local residents worried about…
Illegal alien truck driver presses for blood samples, vehicle analysis in deadly Florida disaster

Florida Tragedy Unfolds: Illegal Alien Truck Driver Demands Crucial Evidence Examination

An undocumented truck driver, accused of triggering a fatal accident in Florida,…
K-pop star HyunA collapses mid-performance, sparking concern over recent weight loss

K-Pop Star HyunA’s On-Stage Collapse Raises Alarms Over Drastic Weight Loss

On November 9, K-pop sensation HyunA caused alarm among her fans when…
University of Iowa conservative group leader defiant after recent table flipping attacks: 'builds character'

University of Iowa Conservative Group Leader Stands Firm After Table-Flipping Attacks: ‘Character Building Experience

A conservative student organization at the University of Iowa remains resolute in…
Cruise ship death mystery: Cheerleader's final posts hint at heartbreak and resilience as dad breaks silence

Cheerleader’s Heartfelt Final Posts Reveal Strength Amid Tragic Cruise Ship Death, Father Speaks Out

The FBI has launched an investigation into the tragic death of Anna…