A tense exchange unfolded recently when a Democratic politician from California claimed he was detained by armed settlers and the Israeli military during a visit to the West Bank. This assertion has been met with skepticism from Republican lawmakers, who have dismissed it as merely an attempt to grab headlines.
Rep. Ro Khanna, who represents Silicon Valley, recounted the incident occurring on Wednesday, during a three-day tour through Khirbet Zanuta. The ruins of this small Palestinian village, located in the occupied West Bank, served as the backdrop for the unfolding drama.
According to Khanna, the situation escalated to a point where he and his American companions only secured their release following communications with the US Embassy in Jerusalem. This was a pivotal moment in what had already been an intense encounter.
The Israeli Defense Forces (IDF), however, have firmly denied that any such detainment of visitors took place, adding a layer of complexity to the differing accounts of that day’s events.
Khanna described the scene as his group traversed an area abandoned after attacks by settlers. They were allegedly stopped by masked individuals, who were armed with what Khanna identified as ‘American-made M4s,’ and these individuals reportedly refused to let the group proceed. This confrontation has added another chapter to the ongoing tensions in the region.
The confrontation was also witnessed by one of the photographers accompanying the group, according to The New York Times.
Khanna said he was disappointed to see Israeli soldiers interact in a friendly manner with the settlers after arriving at the scene, while also blocking his group from moving forward.
‘If this can happen to an American member of Congress, imagine what life is like for Palestinians who have no smartphones, no security and no national platform,’ Khanna said in a fundraising email shortly after the incident.
A Democratic California politician says he was detained by armed, masked settlers and the Israeli military during a tour of the West Bank
Rep. Ro Khanna, a Silicon Valley congressman, said the scene unfolded Wednesday during a three-day tour of the ruins of the small Palestinian village of Khirbet Zanuta
Khanna said that he and the other Americans in his group were only released after calls were made to the US Embassy in Jerusalem
The IDF released its own statement saying it received a report of Israeli citizens blocking foreign nationals and members of the media in the deserted town.
‘Upon receiving the report, IDF troops were dispatched to the scene, quickly dispersed the Israeli civilians and reopened the blocked road,’ the military said. ‘The IDF soldiers operating in the area did not take part in blocking the road.’
Khanna’s claims drew heavy criticism from Republican lawmakers, who accused him of staging a ‘publicity stunt.’
Rep Greg Murphy of North Carolina blasted Khanna in a post on X, writing: ‘Sounds like another plea for publicity. Anything to get in front of the camera. Why else would you be there? It isn’t your country.’
Chief Strategist for the Middle East Forum Jim Hanson also described the Democrat’s claims as a ‘performative outrage stunt.’
‘You purposely had your tour bus try to enter a zone restricted for civilians. Local security stopped you and the IDF verified you were not authorized to enter,’ Hanson wrote in his own response.
‘You were not “detained,” you were properly refused entry and your agit prop failed,’ he added. ‘Now you and the NYT are trying to create an incident out of this nothing falafel.’
Hanson also said Israel was done ‘coddling the terrorists it has been forced to live side by side with’ for more than 70 years and accused Khanna of ‘peddling lies.’
The confrontation was witnessed by one of the photographers accompanying the group, according to The New York Times
Khanna’s claims drew heavy criticism from Republican lawmakers, who accused him of staging a ‘publicity stunt’
‘The lies you have been peddling about the invented “Gaza Genocide” and legitimate IDF military actions against terrorists do not change the facts on the ground,’ he wrote.
‘Israel has offered peace dozens of times, the Palestinians have offered death and destruction in return. Now they are reaping what they have sown.’
Settlement construction and settler violence against Palestinians have increased in the West Bank in recent years.
While Israeli officials have condemned some of the most serious incidents, they have often characterized them as isolated cases, and perpetrators are rarely held accountable.
The international community overwhelmingly considers the settlements illegal.
Democratic politicians in the United States have only intensified their criticism of Israel as voters have increasingly turned against the country since the war in Gaza began.
A recent survey by The Associated Press-NORC Center for Public Affairs Research found that about 58 percent of Democrats believe the nation is ‘too supportive’ of Israel.
The latest clash highlighting escalating political tensions between Israel and members of the Democratic Party came to light just before 9.30am Saturday, when Khanna made his claims public in a post on X.
‘Israeli settlers, brandishing American made M4s, detained me and other Americans on my trip to Palestine,’ the congressman wrote.
‘When the IDF arrived, they sided with the settlers and continued our detention,’ he added. ‘They made a huge mistake.’
A photo and short video clip were attached to his post, showing the moment Khanna said vehicles were stopped, preventing him and his delegation from moving. Weapons can be seen in the hands of at least two men.
The following day, The New York Times published an article detailing Khanna’s account of the incident, which he described as the most frightening part of his three-day trip organized by a staff member.