Democrats accuse GOP of nuking Senate rules to pass Trump megabill
Share and Follow


Senate Democrats on Sunday accused Republicans of “going nuclear” to blow up the Senate rules so they can make President Trump’s 2017 tax cuts permanent.

The heated moment on the Senate floor came as Democrats made several parliamentary inquiries of the Senate’s presiding chair to lay the groundwork to challenge Budget Committee Chair Lindsey Graham’s (R-S.C.) use of a “current policy” budget baseline to score the extension of the 2017 tax cuts as not adding to the deficit.

“This is the nuclear option. It’s just hidden behind a whole lot of Washington, D.C., lingo,” Sen. Ron Wyden (D-Ore.), the ranking member of the Senate Finance Committee, declared on the Senate floor.

Republicans pushed back on that claim.

Graham argued that Democrats have previously used current-policy baselines to score bills. He pointed to former Senate Budget Committee Chair Kent Conrad’s (D-N.D.) use of a current-policy baseline to pass a farm bill.

Democrats, however, say that was done on a bipartisan basis and not for something as monumental as extending trillions of dollars’ worth of tax breaks.

Senate Finance Committee Chair Mike Crapo (R-Idaho) pointed out that former President Obama’s budget office in 2012 argued that the extension of the expiring Bush tax cuts should be scored as a continuation of current policy and as not adding to the deficit.

Democrats say that Congress has never before used a current-policy baseline to score tax cuts in a budget reconciliation package as not adding to future deficits.

They are pushing for the bill to be scored on a “current law” baseline.

Under current law, the 2017 Trump tax cuts would expire at the end of 2025.

The Congressional Budget Office (CBO) scores the extension of Trump tax cuts as adding to the deficit under a current-law baseline.

But under a current-policy baseline, which Republicans are using for the bill, the CBO scores the extension of the Trump tax cuts as not exceeding the bill’s reconciliation instructions or adding to federal deficits after 2034.

If extending the Trump tax cuts is scored as budget neutral, then the bill complies with the Senate’s Byrd Rule, which determines what legislation can pass the Senate with a simple-majority vote.

If Democrats win the procedural argument, the bill would have to be rewritten and the 2017 Trump tax cuts would have to be offset with huge additional spending cuts to comply with the Senate’s Byrd Rule.

If Republicans win the procedural argument, they will then be able to make the expiring portions of the 2017 Tax Cuts and Jobs Act permanent — a major policy victory.

Wyden, Senate Democratic Leader Chuck Schumer (N.Y.) and other senior Democrats made parliamentarian inquiries on the floor Sunday afternoon to set up a later challenge to the Republican baseline.

Merkley asked the presiding chair, first-term Sen. Bernie Moreno (R-Ohio), if the House reconciliation bill used current law as the operative baseline when it was first laid before the Senate.

The chair answered “yes.”

Then Schumer asked if the Senate had ever used a baseline other than current law for a reconciliation measure, and the chair responded “no.”

Sen. Patty Murray (D-Wash.), the ranking member of the Appropriations Committee, asked if the nine titles of the Senate bill other than the Finance Committee’s portion used current-law baselines. Moreno answered “yes.”

Wyden then asked if the Finance title of the legislation relied on two different budgetary baselines, both current-law and current-policy baselines, and the chair acknowledged that is true.

Those answers prompted Murray, the longest-serving Democratic member of the Budget panel, to accuse Republicans of “ignoring precedent, process and the parliamentarian.”

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
CBO says tax piece of GOP megabill could violate Senate Byrd Rule

Senate Byrd Rule potentially violated by tax component in GOP megabill, according to CBO

The Congressional Budget Office (CBO) projects that the tax piece of President…
Woman in custody after driving godson to Jacksonville hospital with gunshot wound

Young person hurt in shooting at Jacksonville party, police report

The Jacksonville Sheriff’s Office says it happened just after 9 p.m. Saturday…
Trump mocks Senator Thom Tillis and fires brutal warning to GOP

“Trump ridicules Senator Thom Tillis and issues a harsh caution to the GOP”

Donald Trump hailed the news that North Carolina Senator Thom Tillis will…
Famed fashion house brutally SAVAGES Jeff Bezos' wedding suit

Renowned fashion house offers scathing critique of Jeff Bezos’ wedding attire

A famed fashion house has brutally savaged Jeff Bezos’ wedding suit after he…
Nine new Florida laws take effect in 2025

Florida will implement almost 100 new laws starting July 1

While Gov. Ron DeSantis continues to look over bills on his desk…
SCOTUS birthright citizenship ruling causes MSNBC host to erupt on air

MSNBC host gets angry on live TV over SCOTUS decision on birthright citizenship

MSNBC host Symone Sanders Townsend gave an unhinged reaction to the Supreme…
Shocking moments world leaders have been caught cursing

Surprising times when world leaders were heard using profanity

World leaders are held in high regard by the public and expected…
Plane crash sparks mystery in Alabama as pilot was nowhere to be found

Mysterious Plane Crash in Alabama Leaves Pilot Missing

An abandoned, bloodstained plane was mysteriously found wrecked in a secluded Alabama airfield,…