Gender identity debate grows amid academic freedom concerns
Share and Follow


() The topic of gender identity has come under scrutiny in classrooms and school board meetings across the country, raising concerns about academic freedom in the United States.

A video filmed at Texas A&M went viral in September, featuring a student arguing with a professor during a children’s literature class over whether it was legal to talk about gender identity in the classroom. The student said discussing transgender topics violated her religious beliefs and federal policy that recognizes only two sexes.

The video led to the professor’s firing and the resignation of the university’s president. Texas Gov. Greg Abbott weighed in on the debate, sending out a letter that pointed to President Donald Trump’s executive order and a new state law that defines sex strictly as male or female.

Since then, a ripple effect has spread throughout the Lone Star state. At least four public universities including Texas Tech, the University of North Texas, Texas Woman’s University and the University of Texas have ordered faculty to ensure their coursework complies with the state and federal levels. The universities have stressed that the reviews are about compliance but haven’t said what, if any, changes will be made once those reviews are complete.

In response, LGBTQ+ advocates have argued a dangerous precedent is being set. The Texas Tribune reported that no state law explicitly prohibits teaching topics such as gender identity or the existence of more than two sexes. 

“They are endangering academic freedom. They are weakening our institution’s credibility and they’re depriving students of the full education that they deserve,” Ash Lazarus Orr, a transgender activist, said. “So, if we really want universities that are preparing students for the real world, that means protecting the truth, the scholarship and inclusivity over politics.”

In August, Abbott signed a bill barring transgender people from using multiple-occupancy bathrooms and changing rooms that align with their identity in schools and government-owned buildings. The bill goes into effect Dec. 4.

From access to restrooms to classroom curriculum, debates around gender identity are playing out in states across the country. A California school board meeting took an unusual turn when a woman removed her clothes in protest. The woman, a member of the conservative group Moms for Liberty, stripped down to a bikini to protest the district’s policies on transgender students and locker rooms.

The Davis Unified School District allows transgender students to use the bathroom that aligns with their gender identity. The woman, who has a transgender child, said she wanted to give the board an idea of how uncomfortable that policy can be for bystanders.

For now, other states, such as Florida and Utah, are closely watching Texas to see how those reviews unfold and what actions are taken in response.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
Woman gets max sentence for murder of 3-year-old in Ohio store parking lot

Ohio Tragedy: Woman Receives Maximum Sentence for Heartbreaking Murder of Toddler in Parking Lot

In a Cleveland courtroom on Monday morning, a judge delivered the harshest…
Trial for Charlie Kirk’s alleged assassin will test new judge in ‘career-defining moment,’ attorneys say

Trial of Charlie Kirk’s Alleged Attacker Presents ‘Career-Defining Moment’ for New Judge, According to Attorneys

Two attorneys from Utah have expressed confidence in the newly appointed Judge…
Pork jerky recall: 2M pounds of Golden Island Korean barbecue pork jerky sold at Costco, Sam's Club recalled over metal wire risk

Urgent Recall: Metal Contamination Threat Prompts Recall of 2 Million Pounds of Pork Jerky from Costco and Sam’s Club

In a significant recall, a company based in South Dakota is pulling…
Judge to rule on suspect's court attire in Charlie Kirk case

Judge to Decide on Appropriate Court Attire for Defendant in Charlie Kirk Case

A decision is anticipated from a judge on Monday regarding whether Tyler…
Food banks brace for surge as federal food aid pause looms amid government shutdown

Federal Food Aid Halt Sparks Urgent Demand Surge at Food Banks Amid Government Shutdown

Food banks and pantries, already grappling with the effects of federal program…
'Frustrated' Wisconsin daycare worker allegedly broke baby's arm after slamming her into crib

Wisconsin Daycare Worker Accused of Injuring Infant by Forcefully Placing Her in Crib

A Wisconsin daycare worker, reportedly exasperated, stands accused of breaking a 3-month-old…
Blue city repeat offender linked to college student murder charged with new violent crimes after soft sentence

Repeat Offender’s Violent Crime Surge Exposes Flaws in Blue City’s Justice System

A New York City teenager, once implicated in the 2019 fatal stabbing…
David Foster, 75,takes Katharine McPhee, 41, to dinner

David Foster, 75, and Katharine McPhee, 41, Turn Heads at Elegant Dinner Date

Over the weekend, renowned music producer David Foster, 75, appeared weary as…