Economist Brent Neiman shocked to learn Trump admin used his formula to justify tariffs: 'Got it wrong'
Share and Follow

An esteemed economist was surprised to discover that the Trump administration utilized his study to support its high tariffs. He stated that the White House misinterpreted his formula and made significant errors in calculating the tariffs for each country.

Brent Neiman, a University of Chicago economics professor, said in a New York Times op-ed that President Trump’s sweeping tariff regime should have been roughly four times less if his study had been followed correctly.

The economic expert, who co-wrote the research with three other renowned economists, noted that his first question when Trump unveiled its tariff rates was: “How on earth did it calculate such huge rates?”

“The next day it got personal. The Office of the U.S. Trade Representative released its methodology and cited an academic paper produced by four economists, including me, seemingly in support of its numbers,” he wrote.

“But it got it wrong. Very wrong,” he said.

“I disagree fundamentally with the government’s trade policy and approach. But even taking it at face value, our findings suggest the calculated tariffs should be dramatically smaller — perhaps one-fourth as large.”

Neiman, who served as a treasury official during the Biden administration, suggested Trump’s team incorrectly plugged a 25% rate into its formula to come up with the levies.

“Where does 25% come from? Is it related to our work? I don’t know,” he wrote.

“Had the trade office instead used a value closer to the 95 percent number from our work, as I believe it should have done, the computed tariffs would have been as little as one-fourth of what they are.”

The professor said the “biggest mistake” was leveraging the reciprocal tariffs to try to eliminate trade deficits with some of the Unites States’ major trading partners.

“The office said it calculated its reciprocal tariffs at a level that would theoretically eliminate trade deficits with ‘each of our trading partners,’ one by one. Is that a reasonable goal?” he wrote.

“It is not. Trade imbalances between two countries can emerge for many reasons that have nothing to do with protectionism. Americans spend more on clothing made in Sri Lanka than Sri Lankans spend on American pharmaceuticals and gas turbines. So what? That pattern reflects differences in natural resources, comparative advantage and development levels.”

“The deficit numbers don’t suggest, let alone prove, unfair competition,” he added.

Neiman’s reaction comes after Trump announced a 10% baseline tariff on all imports to the US last week, as well as higher duties on some of the country’s biggest trading partners — ranging from premium Italian coffee and Japanese whisky to sportswear made in Asia.

Trump has justified the hefty levies by arguing the “reciprocal” tariffs were a response to duties and other non-tariff barriers put on US goods.

He has insisted, too, that the tariffs would boost manufacturing jobs at home.

 

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
Dick Cheney, former US Vice President, dies aged 84, family announces

Former Vice President Dick Cheney Passes Away at 84, Family Confirms

Former U.S. Vice President Dick Cheney, a prominent advocate for the Iraq…
85-year-old Nancy Pelosi confronted about political future

85-Year-Old Nancy Pelosi Faces Questions on Political Future Amidst Leadership Speculations

On Tuesday, former House Speaker Nancy Pelosi’s aides swiftly dismissed any inquiries…
Election Day: What's on the ballot in the first general election since Donald Trump became president

Exploring the Ballot: Key Issues in the First General Election Following Donald Trump’s Presidency

As the nation reflects on the first anniversary of Donald Trump reclaiming…
Actors Elle Fanning, Dimitrius Schuster-Koloamatangi say filming new 'Predator: Badlands' movie was a challenge

Elle Fanning and Dimitrius Schuster-Koloamatangi Reveal Challenges in Filming ‘Predator: Badlands

“Predator: Badlands,” the latest addition to the science-fiction saga, has hit the…
Statewide and Southeast Georgia 2025 Election | Results

Georgia 2025 Election Results: Key Outcomes and Insights from Statewide and Southeast Races

First Coast News is closely monitoring the final results of the November…
Avalanche in Nepal kills 7 climbers on Mount Yalung Ri

Tragic Avalanche on Nepal’s Mount Yalung Ri Claims Lives of Seven Climbers

An avalanche struck a camp in Nepal on Monday, resulting in the…
Security at California Coast Guard base opens fire on U-Haul truck posing 'direct threat'

California Man Faces Federal Charges for Allegedly Targeting Coast Guard Officers with U-Haul

Federal prosecutors have charged a 26-year-old man from Oakland, California, following an…
LISTEN: The moments before near-miss at Hopkins Airport

Exclusive Audio Reveals Tense Moments Leading to Near-Miss Incident at Hopkins Airport

CLEVELAND (WJW) — An investigation has been launched by the National Transportation…