Kohberger plea deal splits slain University of Idaho victims' families
Share and Follow

The father of Kaylee Goncalves, a murder victim from the University of Idaho, made the decision not to enter the courtroom on Wednesday while his daughter’s killer entered a guilty plea. He believed that the plea deal did not bring justice to his daughter.

ā€œI’m not going in there,ā€ Steve Goncalves said, as the rest of his family entered court.

Kaylee, along with her best friends and roommates Xana Kernodle, Madison Mogen, and Ethan Chapin, shared a close bond in life. However, the families of the victims are now divided over the plea deal made for the killer.

The families of Kaylee and Kernodle are particularly upset that they feel justice is not being adequately served. They are concerned that the killer, Kohberger, may not have to elaborate on his motives for targeting the four young women.

The families of Mogen and Chapin, meanwhile, praised the deal — saying it spares the families the worst of a lengthy trial.

Gonclaves made his stand surrounded by reporters outside the courthouse in Boise moments before Kohberger was to finalize his plea.

ā€œYou betrayed us,ā€ the Gonclaves family said in a new statement to Latah County Prosecutor Bill Thompson on Wednesday.

ā€œThis ain’t justice, no justice presided, no jury weighed the truth. Thompson robbed us of our day in court.ā€

Kernodle’s father told The New York Times that he does ā€œnot agreeā€ with the plea deal, which he said he expressed to prosecutors.

ā€œAfter nearly three years of waiting and being told there would be a trial, with evidence presented to convict him, I’m disappointed in the prosecutors’ decision,ā€ he told the Times in a statement.

Kernodle’s aunt had said earlier this week that the prosecution told them that it was to ā€œspareā€ them from the reliving grisly details of the murders prosecutors would present to the jury at trial to obtain a conviction.

ā€œWe know the graphics. They were not trying to spare us,ā€ Kernodle said.Ā 

Mogen’s father, meanwhile, said his family was dreading the upcoming trial and were relieved by the prosecution’s move to strike a deal that he believes is fair.

ā€œIt’s been this nightmare that’s approaching in our heads,ā€ Ben Mogen told The New York Times he expressed to prosecutors when they mentioned working on a deal last week

Mogen added that even if the state were to secure a death penalty, Kohberger would like to spend years on death row before his execution.

And death, he argued, is a more lenient punishment because ā€œyou don’t have to spend decades thinking about how terrible you made the world,ā€ he told CBS.

The Mogen family wants ā€œto put this behind us and not have these future dates and future things that we don’t want to have to be at, that we shouldn’t have to be at, that have to do with this terrible person,ā€ he said.Ā 

ā€œWe get to just think about the rest of lives and have to try and figure out how to do it without Maddie and the rest of the kids,ā€ Mogen added.

Chapin’s mother, Stacy Chapin, told KHQ-TV that the family would be in court on Wednesday ā€œin support of the plea bargain.ā€

The Goncalves family, in stark contrast, said in a scathing statement shared on social media on Monday that they are ā€œbeyond furious at the State of Idaho.ā€

Her family members vowed they will ā€œnot stop fighting for the life that was stolen unjustly,ā€ in a follow-up statement on Tuesday.

ā€œAt a bare minimum, please – require a full confession, full accountability, location of the murder weapon, confirmation the defendant acted alone, & the true facts of what happened that night.ā€

The plea bargain also sparked backlash online, with the Latah County Prosecuting Attorney’s Office’s inundated with negative Google reviews following news of the deal.

Kohberger, a 30-year-old former Ph.D. criminology student, hacked to death Goncalves, 21, Mogen, 21, Chapin, 20, and Kernodle, 20, at their off-campus house in Moscow, Idaho in the early morning hours of Nov. 13, 2022.

However despite troves of evidence, with no trial, we may never learn the Kohberger’s true motive behind the senseless slayings.

Kohberger was a student at Washington State University in Pullman, just about 10 miles from where the victims’ bodies were discovered.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
I visited heaven and when I returned there was no trace of my cancer

Miraculous Journey: How a Heavenly Experience Led to My Cancer’s Disappearance

After the heartbreaking loss of her husband, Rosemary Thornton found herself fervently…
Principal takes in foster teen and ends up changing both their lives

Heartwarming Journey: How One Principal’s Act of Kindness Transformed Her Life and a Foster Teen’s Future

Three years ago, a Michigan principal made a life-changing decision when he…
Kentucky State University shooting suspect charged with murder is parent of a student

Kentucky University Shooting Case: Grand Jury’s Decision Sparks Controversy

A grand jury has decided not to indict a father charged with…
The Cure guitarist Perry Bamonte dies aged 65

Guitarist Perry Bamonte of The Cure Passes Away at 65

Perry Bamonte, the renowned guitarist of The Cure, has passed away at…
Deal to sell 117 JCPenney stores in danger of collapse

Potential Collapse Looms Over Sale of 117 JCPenney Stores

A widespread JCPenney store sale, involving locations in 35 states and Puerto…
Tynesha McCarty-Wroten, charged in Zion pedestrian Darren Lucas' death while allegedly livestreaming on TikTok, out of custody

Zion Tragedy: TikTok Livestreaming Suspect Tynesha McCarty-Wroten Released from Custody in Darren Lucas Pedestrian Death Case

A woman, previously held in custody after being accused of fatally hitting…
Times Square will mark America's 250th with special July ball drop

Times Square to Commemorate America’s 250th Anniversary with Special July Ball Drop

by: Brett Samuels, The Hill Posted: Dec 26, 2025 / 03:10 PM…
Chilling discovery after doctor's wife and two children are killed

Tragic Triple Homicide: Shocking Details Emerge in Doctor’s Family Murder Case

A disturbing revelation has surfaced amid the ongoing investigation into the tragic…