Deadly shooting at Dutton Island shocks community
Share and Follow


Community members react to a deadly officer-involved shooting Monday night after police say a man with a rifle threatened a couple trying to help him.

ATLANTIC BEACH, Fla — Community members react after a deadly shooting at Dutton Island Preserve. Police say a 37-year-old man was killed after an encounter with nine Jacksonville officers Monday evening.

According to the Jacksonville Sheriff’s Office, the incident began Monday night when a 37-year-old man was seen firing his rifle into the water at the Dutton Island Preserve boat ramp. Authorities say a couple approached to ask if he needed help, but the man pointed the gun at them and fought with one of them when they tried to de-escalate the situation.

Investigators said the suspect then got into his vehicle and drove off, only to return and ram the couple’s car before crashing near the RaceTrac on Mayport Road. Officers say he later barricaded himself inside his own car. After more than an hour, police say the suspect reached into a rifle case, and that’s when nine officers opened fire. The man died from his injuries at the scene.

For people who know the preserve as a quiet spot for fishing and hiking, the violence feels out of place.

“I just think it’s crazy how things escalate so quickly nowadays,” said Justin Null, who often fishes at the preserve.

Community member, Kara Anderson, said she came to the preserve to go on a walk. She said the idea of a shooting there left her uneasy.

“It’s a safe, quiet area. It’s scary to be in an area that it’s even violence or protection is even needed,” Anderson said.

Others were stunned when they first realized what was happening. Longtime visitor Martha Finch said she noticed smoke from the suspect’s truck and thought it was a traffic accident, not a deadly confrontation.

JSO confirmed the man’s past included only minor traffic offenses and a misdemeanor. 

Some community members said they will keep coming, but with a new sense of caution.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
America's most notorious dine-and-dasher is EVICTED

Infamous U.S. Dine-and-Dasher Faces Eviction

An alleged serial dine-and-dasher, who has reportedly been evicted from various New…
Judge blocks ICE from making warrantless arrests in DC without flight-risk proof

DC Court Halts ICE Warrantless Arrests: New Ruling Requires Flight-Risk Justification

A federal judge issued a ruling on Tuesday that curtails the Trump…
BMW axing a 30-year-old legend after producing a Final Edition model

Farewell to an Icon: BMW Bids Adieu to a 30-Year Legacy with Exclusive Final Edition Model

BMW has decided to conclude one of its most cherished projects. The…
NYC alleged dine-and-dash influencer Pei Chung evicted from luxury apartment as she sits in jail

Influencer Scandal: NYC’s Pei Chung Faces Eviction and Jail Time in Dine-and-Dash Drama

Pei Chung, the social media influencer famously known for allegedly dining and…
Jordon Hudson's plan to lure Bill Belichick BACK to the NFL

Jordon Hudson’s Bold Strategy to Bring Bill Belichick Back to the NFL Spotlight

On a Thursday evening in February, just after 10:30 p.m., a couple…
California Christian college student founds pro-life club after school rejects Students for Life chapter

California Christian College Student Launches New Pro-Life Club Following School’s Rejection of Students for Life Chapter

A determined pro-life student at a Christian college in California has successfully…
Duval County Public Schools faces lawsuit for student's allergy death

Duval County Overhauls Book Ban Policy: What It Means for Local Schools and Libraries

A recent policy update mandates the removal of any book detailing “sexual…
Jacksonville man sentenced to 270 years for producing, distributing child sexual abuse images

Jacksonville Resident Receives 270-Year Sentence for Child Exploitation and Distribution of Illegal Images

On August 12, 2025, Joshua Davis was convicted for his involvement in…