ICE: Federal judge sides with Trump in allowing immigration enforcement in houses of worship
Share and Follow

WASHINGTON — A federal judge on Friday sided with the Trump administration in allowing immigration agents to conduct enforcement operations at houses of worship for now, despite a lawsuit filed by religious groups over the new policy.

U.S. District Judge Dabney Friedrich in Washington refused to grant a preliminary injunction to the plaintiffs, more than two dozen Christian and Jewish groups representing millions of Americans.

She found that the plaintiffs lack standing, or the legal right to sue, since only a handful of immigration enforcement actions have been conducted in or around churches or other houses of worship and that the evidence at this point doesn’t show “that places of worship are being singled out as special targets.”

FILE - A sign that prohibits the entrance of ICE or Homeland Security is posted on a door at St. Paul and St. Andrew United Methodist Church in New York, Jan. 21, 2025.

FILE – A sign that prohibits the entrance of ICE or Homeland Security is posted on a door at St. Paul and St. Andrew United Methodist Church in New York, Jan. 21, 2025.

AP Photo/Seth Wenig, File

The plaintiffs are reviewing the decision and assessing their options, said their lead counsel, Kelsi Corkran.

“We remain gravely concerned about the impacts of this policy and are committed to protecting foundational rights enshrined in the First Amendment and the Religious Freedom Restoration Act,” said Corkran, the Supreme Court Director at the Institute for Constitutional Advocacy & Protection.

The religious groups argued the policy violated the right to practice their religion. Since President Donald Trump took office in January, attendance has declined significantly, with some areas showing double-digit percentage drops, they said.

The judge, though, found that the groups had not shown their drops were definitively linked to the church policy specifically, as opposed to broader increased actions by Immigration and Customs Enforcement or other agencies.

“That evidence suggests that congregants are staying home to avoid encountering ICE in their own neighborhoods, not because churches or synagogues are locations of elevated risk,” wrote Friedrich, who was appointed by the Republican president during his first term.

That means that simply reversing the policy on houses of worship wouldn’t necessarily mean immigrants would return to church, she found.

On Jan. 20, his first day back in office, Trump’s administration rescinded a Department of Homeland Security policy limiting where migrant arrests could happen. Its new policy said field agents using “common sense” and “discretion” can conduct immigration enforcement operations at houses of worship without a supervisor’s approval.

Plaintiffs’ attorneys claimed the new Homeland Security directive departs from the government’s 30-year-old policy against staging immigration enforcement operations in “protected areas” or “sensitive locations.”

The plaintiffs did offer a handful of examples of enforcement or surveillance, according to the judge’s ruling. They cited reports of an immigrant arrested at one Georgia church and of an Immigration and Customs Enforcement search at a Georgia church day care center. The plaintiffs also cited four cases of immigration officers appearing to conduct surveillance near faith-based sites, such as photographing people in line for food.

The ruling comes as Trump’s immigration crackdown hits courtrooms around the country. On Thursday alone, another judge cleared the way for the administration to require people in the country illegally to register with the government even as the Supreme Court ordered the administration to work to bring back a man mistakenly deported to prison in El Salvador.

There have been at least two other lawsuits over that sensitive locations policy. One Maryland-based judge agreed to block immigration enforcement operations for some religious faiths, including Quakers.

A judge in Colorado, though, sided with the administration in another lawsuit over the reversal of the part of the policy that had limited immigration arrests at schools.

Despite the immediate setback, the plaintiffs can continue to press their case in the lawsuit.

Copyright © 2025 by The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved.

Share and Follow
You May Also Like
'See you in court': Muslim civil rights group responds to terrorist designation by Florida governor

Florida Tops U.S. Execution Charts in 2025: Unveiling the Reasons Behind the Record-Breaking Trend

ST. PETERSBURG, Fla. — As 2023 draws to a close, Florida has…
Daily Mail reveals bottled waters with most toxic 'forever chemicals'

Shocking Discovery: Bottled Waters Contaminated with Dangerous Forever Chemicals Unveiled

Bottled water is often perceived as the safer option for drinking, largely…
Texas 19-year-old Camila Mendoza Olmos vanishes outside her home on Christmas Eve

Texas Sheriff Confident Remains Discovered Are Those of Missing Teen Camila Mendoza Olmos

This article addresses the topic of suicide. If you or someone you…
Southcom carries out strike

US Military Executes Precision Strike, Dismantles Three-Vessel Narco-Terror Convoy at Sea

The U.S. military executed a series of overnight strikes targeting a convoy…
Jacksonville council's late meeting sees budget debate

Unauthorized Gun Log Discovered in Jacksonville: State Investigation Uncovers Lack of Approval

An inquiry revealed that a manager was responsible for maintaining a record…
Missing juvenile found during Flagler County stop, sex offender and teen arrested after pursuit

Flagler County Traffic Stop Leads to Arrest of Teen and Sex Offender; Missing Juvenile Recovered

Footage from body-worn cameras reveals two individuals trying to escape from Flagler…
Mark Williams still has resentment over nixed Lakers trade: 'F–k y'all'

Mark Williams Expresses Frustration Over Cancelled Lakers Trade: ‘F–k Y’all

There remains no love lost between Mark Williams and the Los Angeles…
Stranger Things sparks 'woke' fury as raging Netflix viewers groan

Netflix Viewers Clash Over ‘Stranger Things’ Themes, Igniting Debate

The hit series “Stranger Things” has ignited a wave of controversy, as…